• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports


This is a really good analytical thread by Mackenzie. It explains the limitations of Ange’s high press with respect to Celtic’s matches against better European opposition as opposed to the ‘pub league team and manager’ cliches spouted by his detractors here.
It DOES give me cause for concern along with his apparent lack of desire to integrate youngsters. I do wonder if he has a plan B or can develop a plan B against teams who can beat his press. Still happy to give him the chance to find out.
 
You sure we are appointing a DOF or Sports Director, whatever we call it?

At Celtic Big Ange does both. That could be because they are too cheap to hire one or he doesn't like the staff they have, or it could be that's the way he wants to work...

if the second that's a bit no bueno.
You sure we are appointing a DOF or Sports Director, whatever we call it?

At Celtic Big Ange does both. That could be because they are too cheap to hire one or he doesn't like the staff they have, or it could be that's the way he wants to work...

if the second that's a bit no bueno.
There is no way he will be coming to Spurs expecting to work like he did at Celtic. We are getting a DoF and he will have to work under him. He did have one at Yokohama, so probably something not foreign to him.
 
He got picked out by a la liga club at age 43, fact or not fact? This is off the back of managing in Argentina, which isn't a backwater league, is it?
Ok, but it’s not like it was a flying success. It was 2 months which isn’t a good length.
He only left because his national team, one of the greats of football, asked him to be their manager. Which he did for 4 years than the U23's, winning an Olympic goal. Still well under 50 at this point.
That’s fair. Argentina is obviously a desirable position.
After that, when he resigned with them playing decent stuff and having won the olympics and come runner up in the copa america, he got the job as Chile manager, where he took them to their first world cup in 2 tournaments.
THEN he came to Europe
He didn’t advance out of the group stage of the 2002 WC, which you conveniently left out. That’s got to be disappointing for Argentina. Is winning the Olympics significant? No one seems to field real teams nowadays but I don’t remember back then.
You can't erase the fact that at age 43 he was offered a job in one of the best leagues in Europe, which he took and only left because his own national team wanted him. That' a hard fact.
Ok, but it doesn’t mean he had much experience in big leagues. It’s fair to say their experience was comparable at the time (2 months vs 0).

He didn't even have a pro licence when he went to Celtic.

Well yeah it’s a UEFA pro license, so why would he have one if he never coached in UEFA? Not sure if you were being intentionally misleading there so I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt.
I think you're sounding like a flat earther here, just trying to make up facts to prove your point.
No offense but you are doing the same thing.
 
Ok, but it’s not like it was a flying success. It was 2 months which isn’t a good length.

That’s fair. Argentina is obviously a desirable position.

He didn’t advance out of the group stage of the 2002 WC, which you conveniently left out. That’s got to be disappointing for Argentina. Is winning the Olympics significant? No one seems to field real teams nowadays but I don’t remember back then.

Ok, but it doesn’t mean he had much experience in big leagues. It’s fair to say their experience was comparable at the time (2 months vs 0).


Well yeah it’s a UEFA pro license, so why would he have one if he never coached in UEFA? Not sure if you were being intentionally misleading there so I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt.

No offense but you are doing the same thing.
Thanks.
I was about to make the same points — more or less — particularly the rather silly pojnt about a UEFA license.
The idea that a coach with ‘big 5 league experience’ (especially someone who has a win percentage of less than 33% — Poch) or one with two month’s experience at a mediocre club is somehow automatically a better candidate than someone with Ange’s résumé strikes me as arrogant to say the least.
 
Shutting off passing lanes is fine but there’s other more effective ways to press. The amount of times it goes to the oppositions FB and we are 2 to 3 seconds off the press then it doesn’t matter about passing lanes because decent players will always find the pass. We need to be more aggressive as soon as that ball is on its way to FB areas. Wide forward should be on him on his first touch and make him go inside or back. If it goes inside your centre mid on that side should be aggressive and be in front of their player and our centre forward presses the centre back and our other wide forward comes into the ten position. There’s nowhere for them to go if it’s aggressive and quick but we never go with any conviction. When you win it from there you are 20 yards from goal max.
We are the most passive team in the opposition’s defensive third I’ve ever seen. Under Poch it was the complete opposite for a time and it was brilliant to watch. Guys like Eriksen who is not classed as a workhorse but put himself into position where he won possession a lot.
I just want to see us being horrible to play against high up the pitch rather than teams struggle to break us down because we sit on the edge of our box and have our striker 35 yards from our own goal.
I don't disagree Nico. I wasn't suggesting that they stroll into an area then stand like a training dummy. They still need to cut the lanes down fast. You don't want your forwards chasing down the ball, then leaving nothing in the tank when we win it. But I think we agree on what the dynamics of the press require as a whole.
 
This is a really good analytical thread by Mackenzie. It explains the limitations of Ange’s high press with respect to Celtic’s matches against better European opposition as opposed to the ‘pub league team and manager’ cliches spouted by his detractors here.
It DOES give me cause for concern along with his apparent lack of desire to integrate youngsters. I do wonder if he has a plan B or can develop a plan B against teams who can beat his press. Still happy to give him the chance to find out.
It is a very good thread, those Tifo Football guys are great.

From that analysis, and from reading and watching some other stuff about Ange, it seems like his methodology is to be pretty rigid in the way his teams play. Not that he would set up the press in the exact same way at Spurs that he did at Celtic, but that he wants the squad to have a very deep understanding of what they do and to impose that on the game rather than being reactive.

Very different tactics to Conte, but an analogous philosophy. They aren't Plan B guys. The answer to problems with Plan A is to do Plan A better.

There are benefits to that. I think it helps for integrating depth and youth, the instructions are very clear and that experience can accrue over time. And I think it's obvious that your basic tactical setup will be different as Celtic in the Scottish league versus Spurs in the Premier League. He's not an idiot.

But still, I agree, it's scary to think about our bunch of wasters being set out to play a high risk press against top sides who can ease right through it.

Slot or Nagelsmann would be in a position to do some version of the same thing though. As indeed Mason did the last few weeks. This is the tactical transition we've chosen.
 
Bigoted? I haven’t accused of anything. Yes assume your English. I don’t think that’s offensive is it?

Maybe you’re not English fair enough. Apologies for assuming you are. You’re the one that used the term ‘taig’ and I said that’s an offensive word. Please don’t use it. You then accused me of ‘supporting the ira’ again pretty offensive.

Yes Nire is just shortened for Northern Ireland it’s easier to write. I never said it was widely used. Weird .


Also I’m not from the north but Dublin. No interest in any personal beef. Frankly a lot if this thread is. Train wreck. All I’m asking is to avoid pretty offensive term and if you do know loads about Northern Ireland I’m sure you’ll agree it’s an awful word.
Mate don’t waste your time explaining yourself to that wank.
 
Shutting off passing lanes is fine but there’s other more effective ways to press. The amount of times it goes to the oppositions FB and we are 2 to 3 seconds off the press then it doesn’t matter about passing lanes because decent players will always find the pass. We need to be more aggressive as soon as that ball is on its way to FB areas. Wide forward should be on him on his first touch and make him go inside or back. If it goes inside your centre mid on that side should be aggressive and be in front of their player and our centre forward presses the centre back and our other wide forward comes into the ten position. There’s nowhere for them to go if it’s aggressive and quick but we never go with any conviction. When you win it from there you are 20 yards from goal max.
We are the most passive team in the opposition’s defensive third I’ve ever seen. Under Poch it was the complete opposite for a time and it was brilliant to watch. Guys like Eriksen who is not classed as a workhorse but put himself into position where he won possession a lot.
I just want to see us being horrible to play against high up the pitch rather than teams struggle to break us down because we sit on the edge of our box and have our striker 35 yards from our own goal.
I agree that Kane and son are both dreadful pressers at this stage in their careers but for different reasons.

Kane just rarely is willing to move anymore as he conserves energy for attacking. He’s an ok presser when he commits to it. He’s not quick but he’s at least smart about it and strong enough to win the ball.

Son is almost the opposite. He is willing to put in sprints but he’s pretty much a headless chicken when it comes to pressing. He will sprint half the pitch at the keeper only to get beat by a simple pass. And it’s just wasted energy.

We may be able to survive with one of them and then the rest of the team being organized pressers. But I doubt the remaining 8 field players can carry both of them.
 
Son is almost the opposite. He is willing to put in sprints but he’s pretty much a headless chicken when it comes to pressing. He will sprint half the pitch at the keeper only to get beat by a simple pass. And it’s just wasted energy.
Pressing is all about coordination, and that's the aspect where we're absolutely dogshit.

A combined effect of our dinosaur tactics and the poor morale and professionalism level in the squad.

Our press was the class of the division just 6 years ago. Time to get that back, there really aren't tactics that work in modern football that don't place a heavy emphasis on disturbing the opponent's build up and forcing them into bad situations.
 
I've started watching too many videos of him now and you can see he's a likeable person. Whether he can transfer his coaching and way of playing to the PL is a massive question. It could go either way. Sounds like the start could well be tough though while or if the players can get used to it. Seems like they'll have to have a lot of energy and desire.

I'm coming around to him, but honestly, it could go either way.
 
Back
Top