• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

There are so many coaches for whom that's not true.

Whether it be the Jurgen Klopp-type story of a longtime decent professional in the lower divisions whose real talent emerged in coaching, or the Julian Nagelsmann-type story of a promising young player whose career got taken away by injury, or the Maurizio Sarri-type story of someone never involved in the professional game emerging late in life up through the semi-pro divisions as a coach.

Also how does Ange being coached by Ferenc Puskas play into this?
lol all those people you listed are european which was my entire point. lower divisions in germany are at a higher level than austrailia. puskas is again, european and it's ange's exposure to him that got his foot in the door. where are the austrailians or americans or asians coaching at the highest levels? ange is the top of that heap and he just lost 22 league matches getting torn apart week after week. he's aussie ted lasso and maybe we should just get a believe sign to tape above the door. football is life mate!
 
lol all those people you listed are european which was my entire point. lower divisions in germany are at a higher level than austrailia. puskas is again, european and it's ange's exposure to him that got his foot in the door. where are the austrailians or americans or asians coaching at the highest levels? ange is the top of that heap and he just lost 22 league matches getting torn apart week after week. he's aussie ted lasso and maybe we should just get a believe sign to tape above the door. football is life mate!
I just really strongly disagree with the notion that ones experiences as a player are relevant to their quality as a manager. It isn't true.

Coaching is an entirely different discipline, and understanding the game as a coach is an entirely different thing than understanding it as a player. It gets proven over and over and over again.

Ange also developed as a coach in low-level backwaters, so some part of your point still stands, but the "good head for the game as a player = good manager" thing is nonsense.
 
I just really strongly disagree with the notion that ones experiences as a player are relevant to their quality as a manager. It isn't true.

Coaching is an entirely different discipline, and understanding the game as a coach is an entirely different thing than understanding it as a player. It gets proven over and over and over again.

Ange also developed as a coach in low-level backwaters, so some part of your point still stands, but the "good head for the game as a player = good manager" thing is nonsense.
nonsense? lol. just to use your two examples, klopp and nagelsman played in professional academies in germany since they were children and were deeply embedded in the football culture of a football mad country with history and infrastructure that makes austrailia look like a gym class. and you're also conveniently ignoring all the great coaches who were also great players. i'm not saying messi or neymar are going to be great managers but there's a reason there aren't any coaching greats from the backwaters. it's just a fact
 
nonsense? lol. just to use your two examples, klopp and nagelsman played in professional academies in germany since they were children and were deeply embedded in the football culture of a football mad country with history and infrastructure that makes austrailia look like a gym class. and you're also conveniently ignoring all the great coaches who were also great players. i'm not saying messi or neymar are going to be great managers but there's a reason there aren't any coaching greats from the backwaters. it's just a fact

There are mutiple reasons. Opportunities handed to the likes of Gerrard, Lampard, Rooney and going back our own Ossie are simply not going to happen to managers from that side of the world.

Its also a fact that one of them form the backwaters won the second biggest European Club trophy.

Oh also Ange out.
 
There are so many coaches for whom that's not true.

Whether it be the Jurgen Klopp-type story of a longtime decent professional in the lower divisions whose real talent emerged in coaching, or the Julian Nagelsmann-type story of a promising young player whose career got taken away by injury, or the Maurizio Sarri-type story of someone never involved in the professional game emerging late in life up through the semi-pro divisions as a coach.

Also how does Ange being coached by Ferenc Puskas play into this?

Interesting question. I think its shaped his philosophy completely. Postecogolou rates European football above all club competitions. He favours high scoring front-foot football ( 99.9% of the time haha). Playing with flair. These are all things that Puskas would have exposed him too. His father wouls have seen and like my father talks about the Mighty Magyars and the Real Madrid of that era (to this day). It would have been a dream as young manager to have Puskas wax lyrical about his experiences.
 
Last edited:
nonsense? lol. just to use your two examples, klopp and nagelsman played in professional academies in germany since they were children and were deeply embedded in the football culture of a football mad country with history and infrastructure that makes austrailia look like a gym class. and you're also conveniently ignoring all the great coaches who were also great players. i'm not saying messi or neymar are going to be great managers but there's a reason there aren't any coaching greats from the backwaters. it's just a fact
I agree. I also think coaches at the highest level can relate to and get respect from their players because they’ve done it before themselves.
 
Going into the 2019 final we were in bad form in the league. We rode our luck in the knockout phases and then faced THE in-form team in Europe playing an incredible system of overlapping wide players and a strong press.

Sissoko made a mistake early, Liverpool scored and then the rest of the final was mostly us - but with no real creativity in the middle and an unfit Kane we couldn't turn our possession dominance into goals. That performance would still have been easily enough to win the EL against Man U.

If that stupid Sissoko thing hadn’t happened we may have gone on to nick it. Thinking about what may have happened had we still had Dembele to play instead is wild to ponder.

10m fee vs club legend playing in a Cl final? I advocated trying to get a fee while we could. In hindsight I see it was wrong to sell him before the summer.
 
Back
Top