Who would win?

[tbonepremier]

Spurs 1:
[formation=4231, Lloris, Walker, Kaboul, Vertonghen, Davies, Bentaleb, Capoue, Lamela, Eriksen, Townsend, Soldado][/formation]

Vs

Spurs 2:
[formation=4231, Worn, Naughton, Chiriches, Dawson, Rose, Dembele, Paulinho, Lennon, Holtby, Chadli, Adebayor][/formation]

Subs: Friedel, Fryers, Dier, Assou-Ekotto, Sandro, Carroll, Mason, Kane.

That's some squad depth right there.

 

[HowittzerCOYS]

It would definitely be number 1. They'd have the freedom of the entire pitch. Although, Team 2 would be difficult to beat down the bottom right hand side...

 

[Thelonious]

I don't think we have quality in depth, we merely have a lot of players.

 

[Reedy49]

What a strange formation..

(EDIT): The post has since been edited and wasnt a mess like before

 

[moley]

Team two don't seem to be set up correctly, is Sherwood the manager?

 

[Melspurnian]

Thats the old

10-0-0 formation with all 10 at right back. It could work wonders down that side, in fact its probably the best defensive set out of all.

 

[tbonepremier]

The formation builder wouldn't accept 343. Coded by a consevative sucker?

 

[tbonepremier]

Depends what you mean by quality. I'd say the first team would be close to top 4, the second one 7th'ish.

 

[Thelonious]

a defence containing Dawson, Naughton and Rose would struggle for the top half of the table imo.

 

[shangweibaliu]

Uno.

 

[tbonepremier]

a defence containing Dawson, Naughton and Rose would struggle for the top half of the table imo.

Click to shrink...

Should have better cover for CB positions (Musacchio, Please!), and we should play 3-4-3 cause our full backs is an issues (and for several other reasons).

But I have to point out that a defence containing Rose, Naughton and Dawson for a lot of games made it to sixth last season.

 

[Admin]

343 should work now.

 

[LLB Part Deux]

Indeed, I'd go with the team that doesn't have Danny 'last pick in the line' Rose. Seriously though, the 1st team is far stronger on paper / screen.

 

[Thelonious]

Should have better cover for CB positions (Musacchio, Please!), and we should play 3-4-3 cause our full backs is an issues (and for several other reasons).

But I have to point out that a defence containing Rose, Naughton and Dawson for a lot of games made it to sixth last season.

Click to shrink...

We did indeed, that said, next season, 6th will be tougher to get than it was last season imo.

 

[Murphy]

Team one. Team 2's defence will struggle with the high line.

 

[siggy]

a defence containing Dawson, Naughton and Rose would struggle for the top half of the table imo.

Click to shrink...

that was our defense last season. :adebaehug:

 

[Melspurnian]

Can davies play a wing back role? If so having walker and him at wing back with a CB trio of chriches kaboul vertonghen wouldn't be so bad.

 

[Thelonious]

that was our defense last season. :adebaehug:

Click to shrink...

this was already pointed out.

 

[sammyspurs]

Team 2 for me....

Stronger in attack, and also have attacking midfielders that can defend and hustle people.

I think Bentaleb and Capoue would have too much to do in Team 1, and eventually get over run.

 

[tbonepremier]

How about these, who would win (first eleven, different formations)?

MySpurs:
[formation=343, Lloris, Walker, Vertonghen, Kaboul, Lennon, Sandro, Paulinho, Rose, Lamela, Adebayor, Eriksen][/formation]

PochSpurs:
[formation=4231, Lloris, Walker, Kaboul, Vertonghen, Davies, Capoue, Bentaleb, Lamela, Lennon, Eriksen, Adebayor][/formation]