• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Was sacking Ange a good idea?

  • Yes, I think it was a good idea.

    Votes: 73 64.6%
  • No, I think it was a bad idea.

    Votes: 40 35.4%

  • Total voters
    113
To fix this mess we need a poch mark 2 with a history of winning trophies or always challenging.
Thing is, everyone seems hell bent on a coach being the silver bullet but the team that Poch stumbled into is more what we need again.

Who is our Kane, Son, Dembele, Dele and Eriksen Mark 2?

I wonder how likely we are to recruit a team that good ever again. And tbh when you see what Maresca is doing with the same squad Poch had, part of me wonders if we slightly overrate Poch’s role in that team rising to the level it did.
 
I wonder what Pep would do in Ange’s shoes

Probably stick to what he does. Pep is a philosopher too, one suited to the top echelon of clubs. An elite coach for sure but the way he's been of late at City has pretty much proven he's terrible at handling adversity as a coach. He's a perfectionist so if you give him brilliant musicians he will be the best conductor possible but with average musicians he's as likely to start lobbing violins at them as he is to improve them.
 
Probably stick to what he does. Pep is a philosopher too, one suited to the top echelon of clubs. An elite coach for sure but the way he's been of late at City has pretty much proven he's terrible at handling adversity as a coach. He's a perfectionist so if you give him brilliant musicians he will be the best conductor possible but with average musicians he's as likely to start lobbing violins at them as he is to improve them.

I think that’s pretty likely.

It’s going to be interesting to see how long he sticks around with City in such a big mess.
 
I wonder what Pep would do in Ange’s shoes

Maybe Worse. Pep would be a horror show at this club and I say that as someone who accepts he is one of the greatest managers of all time. He plays such a high risk technical style and it works brilliantly with the right players but getting our players to attempt it would be nuts, we are miles off any attempt at that.
 
Thing is, everyone seems hell bent on a coach being the silver bullet but the team that Poch stumbled into is more what we need again.

Who is our Kane, Son, Dembele, Dele and Eriksen Mark 2?

I wonder how likely we are to recruit a team that good ever again. And tbh when you see what Maresca is doing with the same squad Poch had, part of me wonders if we slightly overrate Poch’s role in that team rising to the level it did.

Pochettino was literally the one who put Maresca on this path. Their form before he was sacked was as good as anything they've been this season - the pathway was set. He guided them through a very difficult period with 500 players, finally got some cohesion together and Caicedo, Palmer etc performing and then he got sacked, probably for political reasons as much as anything else.
 
never mind the fact his kamikaze shit puts players at risk of getting injured anyway, he fucking rushed two back when they clearly wasnt ready! putting their careers at risk. fucking horrendous

never mind the fact his kamikaze shit puts players at risk of getting injured anyway, he fucking rushed two back when they clearly wasnt ready! putting their careers at risk. fucking horrendous stuff.
Agree, really horrendous and very embarrassing, unthinkable at this level.
 
I really don't think Southgate has any desire to be a club manager. He's not an unintelligent man and knows that premier league management is a knife fight. He's got his pick of cushty roles in this country and will always be a bit of a media darling with a solid reputation.

Trading that in to manage Spurs? Nahhhh.

Maybe but I think Southgate will have a sense of unfinished business having not got over the line with England. And if Levy can get Conte to come I reckon he could find the levers to convince Southgate if he (Levy) felt there was no other option.

Having said that I don't think the people around Levy will agree and push for a more progressive manager that's more in line with our recent squad building. Is that a plus for an Iraola type? Hopefully...
 
I think that’s pretty likely.

It’s going to be interesting to see how long he sticks around with City in such a big mess.
I remember someone describing him as a boutique manager, and thats pretty apt. He may well be the most brilliant coach ever, certainly of my lifetime. But I think he would go off kilter or maybe even lose a bit of hunger if he didn't have the elite options available to enact his football. Less that he "couldn't" do it with lesser players. More that he wouldn't care to do so because he couldn't achieve the level on the pitch that would excite him.

We're seeing it now. Or the start of it at least.
 
Pochettino was literally the one who put Maresca on this path. Their form before he was sacked was as good as anything they've been this season - the pathway was set. He guided them through a very difficult period with 500 players, finally got some cohesion together and Caicedo, Palmer etc performing and then he got sacked, probably for political reasons as much as anything else.
I know a few Chav fans and they were ropable that Poch left after having finally made the team into something functional.

I'm sure they aren't complaining now after Maresca has built on those foundations but Poch absolutely did the heavy lifting
 
Pochettino was literally the one who put Maresca on this path. Their form before he was sacked was as good as anything they've been this season - the pathway was set. He guided them through a very difficult period with 500 players, finally got some cohesion together and Caicedo, Palmer etc performing and then he got sacked, probably for political reasons as much as anything else.
Maresca has taken them up a level though and it was still a billion pound squad of talent.

Poch isn’t a bad coach, that’s not what I’m saying. What I’m mainly saying is the quality of talent was the biggest factor in that team we had reaching the levels it did.

How likely are we to turn a 5m Championship kid into another Dele? Or another Kane to come through our academy? Or even another Walker from a Sheffield UTD?
 
Maresca has taken them up a level though and it was still a billion pound squad of talent.

Poch isn’t a bad coach, that’s not what I’m saying. What I’m mainly saying is the quality of talent was the biggest factor in that team we had reaching the levels it did.

How likely are we to turn a 5m Championship kid into another Dele? Or another Kane to come through our academy? Or even another Walker from a Sheffield UTD?

Has he? They're basically a top 4 side. Their title challenge thing was a myth and they're within a couple of points of Forest. I can't be arsed to look but I'm almost certain Pochettino prior to his sacking was in the top 3 in the form table. They won nearly all their end of season games including piecing us up. Maresca came in to a team where Caicedo etc had settled, his job was to finetune and apply his own preferences.

I feel like there's been a huge about turn on this forum. A lot of people (I swear including you?) were waxing lyrical about the talent we had not long ago. Yeah it still needed work and depth but people have gone from overrating to underrating the squad weirdly. We have a collection of useful footballers and some genuinely promising young talent under the right circs.
 

View: https://x.com/TheSpursExpress/status/1872775818260492667

Sesame Street Reaction GIF by Muppet Wiki
 
I remember someone describing him as a boutique manager, and thats pretty apt. He may well be the most brilliant coach ever, certainly of my lifetime. But I think he would go off kilter or maybe even lose a bit of hunger if he didn't have the elite options available to enact his football. Less that he "couldn't" do it with lesser players. More that he wouldn't care to do so because he couldn't achieve the level on the pitch that would excite him.

We're seeing it now. Or the start of it at least.
I don’t believe he has the heart for what’s in front of him, but he knows that if he walks he’s going to get labelled as a quitter for walking away when the going got tough for the first time in his career.

How he must wish he’d left in the summer, I bet if he could turn back turn time he’d do exactly that.
 
Back
Top