• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Was sacking Ange a good idea?

  • Yes, I think it was a good idea.

    Votes: 73 64.6%
  • No, I think it was a bad idea.

    Votes: 40 35.4%

  • Total voters
    113
I'm still not convinced that he is the man for the job, but I so want him to prove me wrong.
Our league position is a disgrace, and even with our issues, we should not be losing against the likes of Ipswich and Leicester at home.
However, should this be the start of an upturn in our results and IF (and it's a big if) we manage to win the EL, then I think he deserves to stay.
 
This is all true. Can we also admit that some posters (not you) do the whole "Just enjoy your team winning!" whilst very openly provoking people they deem to have been wrong because we have finally got some of our shit together. It's like "oh yeah, unhappy cus we lost BUDDY?" whilst simultaneously going "oh haha you big fucking idiot" as if the person is annoyed at the win rather than the person bizarrely claiming a victory because we won some matches.

To put cards on the table, I didn't really have huge confidence we'd win today. Or against Brentford. I did think we would beat United. So overall we've outdone what I expected, but then my expectations were on the floor. I don't think we were great in any of the 3 games, but we have 9 points so that doesn't really matter. Ange gets credit for ship stabilisation.

I expect we will end up anywhere from 9th-12th and not win the europa league. Does that mean I want that to happen? No, I'd happily take a lot of "see? angeisdasbestcoacheva" to win a europa league title. And it's a fucking great opportunity to, the best teams left in it are fucking Bilbao, Frankfurt and Roma.

That's piss weak and eminently doable which is exciting, but I'm not very excited because of Ange. Maybe I'm completely wrong and he'll surprise me.

For sure. And FWIW I completely agree that all we've seen in these last 3 wins is green shoots. Nothing more. But given the season so far it's better than the salt ridden desert littered with the bones of our best players as they rot in the injury tent. So it's worth smiling about :D

I think what made me bite on that last post was the reference to the Cup exits. Those were brutal. Especially the FA Cup for me - because while I don't think we have what it takes to win EL I did (perhaps weirdly?) have hopes for the FA Cup given we have shown that in our day we can beat anyone in the prem.

So I do think it's harsh that we had Liverpool and Villa both away and with all our best defenders, keepers and goal scorers missing. I don't think those should be included in the otherwise abject misery of the season.

Anyway to a thirsty man even piss tastes great - so these last three league wins are somewhat of an oasis :D

But none of this moves the dial on the manager. Or at least it shouldn't.

Edit: just to add I thought this response you made earlier was on point:

I'm sorry that it annoys you that beating Ipswich, United and Brentford has not changed my opinion on the manager. I expect you can imagine how annoyed a lot of us felt when being 16th and losing to Leicester at home didn't change your opinion on the manager either.

Luckily, you're not me. So you won't be sin binned for that comment.
 
Last edited:
I'm still not convinced that he is the man for the job, but I so want him to prove me wrong.
Our league position is a disgrace, and even with our issues, we should not be losing against the likes of Ipswich and Leicester at home.
However, should this be the start of an upturn in our results and IF (and it's a big if) we manage to win the EL, then I think he deserves to stay.
If we manage to win the EL I'm giving him a piggie back down the high road!

The Everton game was when I would have got rid.
 
I'm still not convinced that he is the man for the job, but I so want him to prove me wrong.
Our league position is a disgrace, and even with our issues, we should not be losing against the likes of Ipswich and Leicester at home.
However, should this be the start of an upturn in our results and IF (and it's a big if) we manage to win the EL, then I think he deserves to stay.
He is a proven winner Mrs P, give him all of the tools unbroken and he will get us there, I reckon.
 
isnt the basement where you creepy cuck things live? cuck like behaviour to follow some bloke about that you dont even know, anddd....hes not even any good! talk about mentally ill.

i thought the son fanboys were strange...you postecoglou fanboys are unrivalled.

youll be gone soon anyway, thank god. back to mickey mouse football.
Bet you've been hating this recent run of games hey David the boy?

COYS

Aussie! Aussie! Aussie!

Oi! Oi! Oi!
 
I'm glad we won well today, but I haven't seen anything to make me think Ange is the guy. I'm still absolutely Ange out, but I hope we can do as well as possible until he is replaced, which will most likely happen in the summer now.
When you say the guy. What exactly are your expectations?

I look at our squad and it’s about 5-9th in the league taking into account your average injury list per season in a premier league side.

You have our fans lauding emery, Howe etc and they have largely had an injury free season (with Howe playing far less games) and they are both likely to finish outside of champions league and in villas case, maybe conference league.

How is that much better than Ange given the tools at their disposal
 
1. Ange does lack experience at the top level... that is facts and it shows.
2.EPL is the best and richest league in the world so its not an entitlement.
3.All teams who qualify Europe all rotate if they have too, injured or not.

Going by your history you are a hardcore Ange follower. You ONLY post on Postecoglu's thread land you will be gone when he leaves after this season.

Get the fuck out of here.
Ahhh Rooster - whilst I am Antipodean, I have followed the EPL for decades, and even lived on White Hart Lane. Great times!

You should be thankful that whilst Tottenham fans like to think they're a deserving club (and they are successful financially and with support), having Ange on board allows the growth of interest in the club, unless of course you're xenophobic.

Tottenham have either being medicore for years, OR underachieved for years... but I am not sure which one it is... what's your take?

On the subject of telling me to get the fuck out of here... I appreciate your desire to be a 'gatekeeper' of appropriate supportership.

I'm sure when with other non english managers were installed, this forum would have had other nationalities following the club, and posting their thoughts? Unless of course, English wasn't their first language.

Anyway... it seems you are interested in my history, as you searched what I like to post on. So to give some further context, I too have followed a team that for nigh on 50 years failed to have success (after being very successful in the 50's and 60's) and finally won a trophy/premiership in 2021. The relief was palpable.

This forum reads EXACTLY the same as that forum (Demonland)... the same gnashing of teeth about the capability of the manager, the same posturing about who has more right to support a club. The same people going off the 'eye-test' versus those using 'data' in how they wish to interpret whether the club can win something or not. The same wringing of hands when there is a slump, the same failing to take into account how injuries impact performance, or other contextual nuances....etc etc.

Following sport is the same around the world... Setting a club up for success is the same around the world.

It needs stability and it needs an environment that promotes learning and psychological safety when learning...

Ange is a proven winner... and whilst there is a strong yearning for immediate success from the fan base... growth is NEVER linear, as much as we would like it to be... I can only imagine the reasons, the players are still playing for him... And whilst they are, then he is the right manager at this given point in time.
 
Last edited:
I’d still place the bet mate, toe even goes on that line with me now and it’s instantaneous.

But yeah, nice and calm. Contrary to posts I actually enjoyed the game, it was an entertaining mess. Referee sucked. I enjoy league matches currently, actually feel like free hits.*

My enjoyment of the win won’t stop me from arguing back if someone gets in my E-face and screams ‘SEE? SEE YOU WERE WRONG IM A GENIUS’ because we won a match.

*sorry The Extra Mile(sey) The Extra Mile(sey)
Glad you enjoyed the win :)
 
If it's going to take stuff like;

-Deflected shots going in (see Spence's goal today)
-Opposing forwards missing sitters (see Garnacho last week, Wissa the week before)
-Opposing keepers making grave errors (see Onana last week)
-Vicario making highlight reel material saves on a regular basis

for us to go on a run then I'm not very hopeful. All stars rarely align like that in a certain match, let alone across several matches. I guess players are more fresh and therefore cover more ground due to less congested schedule, but other than that I don't see much of a difference. Giving the ball away playing out from the back, chaotic running around masquerading as pressing, players getting vastly caught out of position are all still there.
Um, that’s football. That happens in every single game.
 
We will not win the Europa League and we will still finish 10th or below. Does that do it for you? Or essentially, the season overall will be viewed extremely negatively when it closes, and Ange will end up losing his job. Nothing in the last 3 wins has remotely come close to changing that opinion for me.
I think Ange will be given next season irrespective of results now. As long as we don’t go into freefall I should say. A quarter or semi in the EL and a finish around 8th in the PL, he’s safe.
Remember Levy signed him for 4 years. Ange is known as a project manager and Levy would have been sold that from Ange. It’s the one time Levy will actually show some restraint and try have some stability. He knows Ange is instilling cultural change. Plus the injury crisis has given him some leeway this season.
Wish him gone all you like, you’re going to be disappointed.
 
I think Ange will be given next season irrespective of results now. As long as we don’t go into freefall I should say. A quarter or semi in the EL and a finish around 8th in the PL, he’s safe.
Remember Levy signed him for 4 years. Ange is known as a project manager and Levy would have been sold that from Ange. It’s the one time Levy will actually show some restraint and try have some stability. He knows Ange is instilling cultural change. Plus the injury crisis has given him some leeway this season.
Wish him gone all you like, you’re going to be disappointed.
Not sure its that set tbh. I think he needs a dramatic turn in results to get next season. Would need a top half finish and to make Europa semis at a minimum.

But completely agree with you about this place been totally out of touch with reality when wishing him to be sacked mid season. There was genuine hysteria about us being in a relegation scrap and needing to bring in Sean Dyche a few weeks ago. Honestly you have to just laugh at some of the stuff you see on here.

I think he'll be lucky to get next season tbh. He'll need a dramatic improvement in results so that it was obvious the injury crisis was the main factor in our terrible spell. I hope he can turn it around but he's up against it
 
Not sure its that set tbh. I think he needs a dramatic turn in results to get next season. Would need a top half finish and to make Europa semis at a minimum.

But completely agree with you about this place been totally out of touch with reality when wishing him to be sacked mid season. There was genuine hysteria about us being in a relegation scrap and needing to bring in Sean Dyche a few weeks ago. Honestly you have to just laugh at some of the stuff you see on here.

I think he'll be lucky to get next season tbh. He'll need a dramatic improvement in results so that it was obvious the injury crisis was the main factor in our terrible spell. I hope he can turn it around but he's up against it
Yep agree. I think realistically we finish around 8th and let’s hope with a trophy. 🏆
 
I’m not a mathematician but anyone tell me how many points a game, in the games he’s played, and what that would be on the ladder, if he’d played every game for Vicario, against the combined foster, Austin, Kinsky combo?

By my rough calcs we’d be top four if Vicario had played every game at the same points per game, and equal with Ipswich/leciester based on the three headed monster we’ve had to play in his spot.

Sometimes it’s not that complicated.
 
I’m not a mathematician but anyone tell me how many points a game, in the games he’s played, and what that would be on the ladder, if he’d played every game for Vicario, against the combined foster, Austin, Kinsky combo?

By my rough calcs we’d be top four if Vicario had played every game at the same points per game, and equal with Ipswich/leciester based on the three headed monster we’ve had to play in his spot.

Sometimes it’s not that complicated.

Since his return, Vic has been massive. It's not just the goalkeeping, it's the leadership on the pitch.
 
Still can’t say I am sold on him even with the uptick in results in the league recently but he’s guaranteed himself the job until summer so we might as well get behind him.

If he brings home a trophy, then all is forgiven.
 
Why does everyone go on about the past 3 games - we’ve won 3 of our last 5 - why does getting knocked out of both cups in the space of 3 days no longer count.

9 points in the last 3 league games means very very little - I would have been far happier with 3 points and winning both cup games.

If we go on a bit of a run in the league and finish say 9th - are people seriously going to want Ange to continue? If so, why?
Suppose more the last two games when Vicario, Maddison and Johnson have come back. The point that returning players have helped.
 
I think Ange will be given next season irrespective of results now. As long as we don’t go into freefall I should say. A quarter or semi in the EL and a finish around 8th in the PL, he’s safe.
Remember Levy signed him for 4 years. Ange is known as a project manager and Levy would have been sold that from Ange. It’s the one time Levy will actually show some restraint and try have some stability. He knows Ange is instilling cultural change. Plus the injury crisis has given him some leeway this season.
Wish him gone all you like, you’re going to be disappointed.

Ange is absolutely not known as a project manager. His club jobs have been 2-3 years before he moves on.

He has no body of work to show that he can develop a young team over 4+ years. He’s very much a “win now” manager just from a much lower level than we’ve had before.
 
If there is a club buyout i think ange will be first out the door.
Regardless of that, even without injuries a lot of the results have been poor going back over a year.
It's fairytale football, all out attack and left so exposed its laughable, there should be no happy ending for him here time to go in the summer.
 
Back
Top