I’d preferred if Kane stays (obviously!), but if he wants to leave, let’s not keep an unhappy player
The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...
One of Kane's qualities in terms of mindset/ethics (whatever you want to call it) is loyalty. So it is not surprising that he is loyal to Jose by all accounts.Just playing devil's advocate here but what if Kane is on Jose's side in all this?
We have to assume Levy will talk to Kane about the split in the dressing room. What if Harry turns round and says that the players are the problem? That they're not doing what they are told?
What if, and this is a big one, he says he'll stay as long as Jose stays and is allowed to replace the sulkers?
EDIT: Alternatively of course he could turn round and tell Levy he won't sign another contract, knowing that most fans won't blame him for leaving now.
In fairness I don't think it would happen. Just chucking another scenario out thereThat's a lot of what ifs and maybes based on zero indication that is the truth.
I can't see anyway Kane says keep Jose or I am gone, it makes very little sense at all. But if that was the demand then I would say sell Kane. Can't have one person above the club. If his attitude is that, and again I doubt it is, then what is to stop him from coming in later and demanding something else or threatening to leave again.
To me that kind of attitude would show me he is already part way out the door anyways so I would look to move him now.
In fairness I don't think it would happen. Just chucking another scenario out there![]()
Dunno if it is hypothetical that we keep him...Fair enough, I guess I am just a little tired of all the ifs and maybes and hypotheticals when it comes to Jose.
There is more than enough to go off on what he has done without trying to make up hypotheticals to keep him.
He isn’t the problem but also has not been the solution like we’d expect a world class star striker to be when we need him the most. He puts up godly numbers but time and time again falls short in crucial moments
For sure. Carrick, Berbatov, Modric, Bale - we were worse off after selling every single one of these. Kane is irreplaceable. Fortunately he's under contract until 2024. Even if gets itchy feet this summer we should keep him. He's not the sort to down tools, and hopefully next season will bring better things for the team.You do not improve our chances of success next season by selling our best players. Kane is not the problem.
I'm to the point where I hope we sell him for big money this summer to PSG. I can watch him and Poch win something, Spurs receive big money that we invest (doubtful but I'm hopeful) and we do not have to see Kane for anything PL club.
i dont get the impression he is on his side, hes lost the enthusiasm he had earlier in the year. unless hes just fed up of being around such shit footballers, the service he gets from the midfield is non existent, take last night for example..winks,dele,sissoko! what the hell is that going to provide for the players further up the pitch?Just playing devil's advocate here but what if Kane is on Jose's side in all this?
We have to assume Levy will talk to Kane about the split in the dressing room. What if Harry turns round and says that the players are the problem? That they're not doing what they are told?
What if, and this is a big one, he says he'll stay as long as Jose stays and is allowed to replace the sulkers?
EDIT: Alternatively of course he could turn round and tell Levy he won't sign another contract, knowing that most fans won't blame him for leaving now.
18 months ago, I would have thought Kane would have said no to a move to another PL team, however, now I think he would jump at the chance.Some guy named Dan on ESPN FC was talking with shaka and others and said he heard about Kane to Man City deal.
Obviously these are just rumors and it's far too early, but I would hate to see that as a Spurs fan.
But I would love to see that as a football fan.
Well if Kane says that, then he gets to play for a shitty team the rest of his career.Just playing devil's advocate here but what if Kane is on Jose's side in all this?
We have to assume Levy will talk to Kane about the split in the dressing room. What if Harry turns round and says that the players are the problem? That they're not doing what they are told?
What if, and this is a big one, he says he'll stay as long as Jose stays and is allowed to replace the sulkers?
EDIT: Alternatively of course he could turn round and tell Levy he won't sign another contract, knowing that most fans won't blame him for leaving now.
Poch is gone. Get over it or join a PSG forum.I'm to the point where I hope we sell him for big money this summer to PSG. I can watch him and Poch win something, Spurs receive big money that we invest (doubtful but I'm hopeful) and we do not have to see Kane for anything PL club.
Why would Kane be on Jose's side? He would be on his own side. He needs to win something and very very soonish.Just playing devil's advocate here but what if Kane is on Jose's side in all this?
We have to assume Levy will talk to Kane about the split in the dressing room. What if Harry turns round and says that the players are the problem? That they're not doing what they are told?
What if, and this is a big one, he says he'll stay as long as Jose stays and is allowed to replace the sulkers?
EDIT: Alternatively of course he could turn round and tell Levy he won't sign another contract, knowing that most fans won't blame him for leaving now.