• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Management Poll: Who do you want most as our next manager?

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Who would be your first choice?

  • Graham Potter

  • Scott Parker

  • Ten Hag

  • Rafa Benitez

  • None of the above - comment below

  • *Marcelo Bielsa

  • *Ralf Rangnick

  • *Ralph Hasenhüttl

  • *Steven Gerrard

  • *Julen Lopetegui

  • *Christophe Galtier

  • *Marcelo Gallardo

  • *Oliver Glasner

  • *Ryan Mason

  • *Maurizio Sarri

  • *Gian Piero Gasperini

  • *Mauricio Pochettino

  • *Antonio Conte

  • *Eddie Howe

  • *Gareth Southgate

  • *Nuno Espirito Santo

  • *Paulo Fonseca

  • *Gennaro Gattuso

  • *Ernesto Valverde


Results are only viewable after voting.
Lazio before Inzaghi: 4th, 7th, 9th, 3rd, 8th (Inzaghi took over as caretaker in April)

Lazio with Inzaghi: 5th, 5th, 8th, 4th, currently 6th

Spurs before Poch: 5th, 4th, 5th, 6th

Spurs with Poch: 5th, 3rd, 2nd, 3rd, 4th

Inzaghi has won a Coppa Italia and seen Lazio into the CL group stages, all on a limited budget. But he hasn't taken the club up a level the way Poch did.

Anyway, this smells like contract negotiations with Lazio, the club Inzaghi has been at in one role or another since 1999.
I'd still argue that those are fairly comparable performances. Lazio and Spurs are clubs of comparable size in their respective leagues and I do not think that Inzaghi would be a name that we should scoff at.
 
I'd still argue that those are fairly comparable performances. Lazio and Spurs are clubs of comparable size in their respective leagues and I do not think that Inzaghi would be a name that we should scoff at.

I wouldn't scoff at it but I don't really see how it makes sense for either side.

Inzaghi is an Italian who has spent his whole playing and managerial career in Italy, with most of it at Lazio. As you say we are similar-ish level clubs, I would say we are bigger but not such a massive jump that it is career changing job for him. Perhaps he feels he has done all he can at Lazio and wants a new challenge but that would be a pretty big change for a guy who has spent his whole life in Italy.

For us, he is a fine, not great manager, with no history of rebuilding a club, not a massive record of working with youth, isn't noted for playing a super attacking style or one that fits with the club although not a defensive dinosaur either, he doesn't bring a history of winning trophies, isn't a big name or a well known name for PR purposes. I am failing to see what Levy would see in him over other candidates that could fill at least some of those things.
 
For us, he is a fine, not great manager, with no history of rebuilding a club, not a massive record of working with youth, isn't noted for playing a super attacking style or one that fits with the club although not a defensive dinosaur either, he doesn't bring a history of winning trophies, isn't a big name or a well known name for PR purposes. I am failing to see what Levy would see in him over other candidates that could fill at least some of those things.
The Levy case is pretty simple, and that's a proven history of doing more with less and being fairly content about the lack of ambition from ownership.

Combine that with some notable successes, attacking football (Lazio aren't Atalanta but they're pretty buccaneering by Italian standards), and player development bona fides, and that's a fit on Levy's end.

Makes less sense on Inzaghi's, but we'll outbid Lazio if it's about money.
 
The Levy case is pretty simple, and that's a proven history of doing more with less and being fairly content about the lack of ambition from ownership.

Combine that with some notable successes, attacking football (Lazio aren't Atalanta but they're pretty buccaneering by Italian standards), and player development bona fides, and that's a fit on Levy's end.

Makes less sense on Inzaghi's, but we'll outbid Lazio if it's about money.

I just think Levy would go with someone like Parker over him as Parker brings so much more PR cover for him.

Plus, I can't see Inzaghi coming here for cheap or to just be Levy's lapdog as he is in a very good situation in Lazio and I don't see Levy giving him a big contract or any control.
 
I just think Levy would go with someone like Parker over him as Parker brings so much more PR cover for him.
Would he? After taking Fulham down? Who gives a shit about Scott Parker?

Now Steven Gerrard would be PR cover, which I agree is a not insignificant consideration here. Social media followers are a huge part of securing commercial deals, and sacking Jose will have been damaging in that regard.

Still, before Jose Levy had generally taken the same attitude toward managers that he had towards players thinking that he could identify undervalued assets in the marketplace and outsmart everybody.

I think Levy wants three things from this appointment:

- A "name" to appease sponsors
- Attacking football to appease the fans
- Someone he genuinely believes is a top tactician who can pull this squad back into the CL without major investment

Unless Conte is actually available, the only person who ticks all three of those boxes is Brendan Rodgers. We've not heard the last of that pursuit, I bet.
 
Can't believe anyone is taking the Inzaghi links seriously. It's obvious bollocks to try and get a pay rise out of Lazio. Every rumour coming out of Italy is a stream of shit. Sarri, Conte and now Inzaghi... It's all bollocks.
 
Would he? After taking Fulham down? Who gives a shit about Scott Parker?

Now Steven Gerrard would be PR cover, which I agree is a not insignificant consideration here. Social media followers are a huge part of securing commercial deals, and sacking Jose will have been damaging in that regard.

Still, before Jose Levy had generally taken the same attitude toward managers that he had towards players thinking that he could identify undervalued assets in the marketplace and outsmart everybody.

I think Levy wants three things from this appointment:

- A "name" to appease sponsors
- Attacking football to appease the fans
- Someone he genuinely believes is a top tactician who can pull this squad back into the CL without major investment

Unless Conte is actually available, the only person who ticks all three of those boxes is Brendan Rodgers. We've not heard the last of that pursuit, I bet.

If we get Brenton that would be awful, so disappointing. Slightly better than Jose, but not much.

I think that for many fans Scott Parker is a very likable guy, much like Mason. I think that fans would immediately want to support him, have trouble criticizing him and would get a lot, especially the more casual fans, excited based just on the name. I also think that Parker has the reputation as being a progressive manager, whether that is true or not, so he would also cover the attacking aspect.

Plus Parker covers the two most important things to Levy in my view, cheap and willing to do whatever Levy says.

Gerrard for me would do the opposite, a lot of fans would be pissed that we are bringing in a Liverpool guy and would be very quick to turn on him the minute things went wrong.

I think the name aspect will be more important for the fans than the sponsors, in Levy's view so that he can take some of the heat off of him from the ESL stuff and get fans back into the stadium spending money. He will use the stadium and Kane to butter up the sponsors and bring that money in.
 
I think that for many fans Scott Parker is a very likable guy, much like Mason. I think that fans would immediately want to support him, have trouble criticizing him and would get a lot, especially the more casual fans, excited based just on the name.
Agree to disagree on all three.

The "legacy" fan isn't going to forgive the disarray of the ENIC project for a manager that just took Fulham down, and the upwardly mobile Malaysian junior executive who is the ESL dream fan doesn't know who Scott Parker is.
 
Back
Top