I like the way you just slipped Wharton in, if only it was that easyI'd take that.
If this was our incoming business I'd be very pleased:
Robertson
Sensei
Van Hecke
Wharton
Savio
Marmoush
Another goal keeper
The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...
I like the way you just slipped Wharton in, if only it was that easyI'd take that.
If this was our incoming business I'd be very pleased:
Robertson
Sensei
Van Hecke
Wharton
Savio
Marmoush
Another goal keeper
If we're going to break the bank, i'd go for someone who has proven they can literally boss a midfield - Bruno Guimares.
Yes.
In fact it has been total dogshit.
What is the point of comparing him against U21? We are not in U21 league.
Tel has had 2255 minutes for us in EPL. Scored 6 goals and provided 3 assists. Goals include penalty against Southampton.
So 5 non penalty goals and 3 assists. Either 9 or 8 goal contributions - that is a goal contribution for every 250 minutes or 281 minutes - whichever you prefer.
So if he plays like this one whole season, every minute of every game it will give you 13,7 goals (or 12,1 if we exclude mentioned penalty) / assists across whole season. Say 8 goals and 6 assists.
As I mentioned, Wilson has scored or assisted once every 154 minutes that is 22,2 goals / assists per full season. Pretty remarkable difference.
One can be "beautiful" and "strike well" and other be a "meh signing" but that is 9 goals from one position more. IF (!) he signs and Tel does not improve. Of course I too hope that younger player will step up his game and start contributing much more and takes the starting winger position for himself. But we cannot just base squad planning on hope without plan B.
The only position we should 'break the bank for" is for a player who can stick the ball in the onion bag.
We will have enough in defence, and midfield, what we don't have is a striker worthy of the name.
Which area are you expecting to see more done?
I guess you still have your mission against Kudus going? And don’t rate Savio?
Why bother?
For insurance reason! I am sure I mentioned the term "insurance" many times.
To literally use him (or someone else like him) as insurance so that when actually young hopefuls like Tel will not improve- then we have alternative. It is as simple as that.
You keep saying "Id rather give the opportunity to someone like Tel" - I agree with that. I would still use him as a starter. And only switch to Wilson if he does not improve. With your view we would not have an alternative. With mine we would have.
Let's look at very pragmatically - you mention "big money" - well first of all I have multiple times said that I would not go for him at any cost. He is currently at 2,8 mil pound / so ~54 thousand per week. He is no Mbappe nor Kane to demand something unrealistic. So I would assuming we would pay him 4,5 mil per year - that is nothing compared to getting so close to relegation last year around (and risking with 250 mil loss). And as someone mentioned that "he would become obsolete soon" - to which I reply - perfect. That would be awesome outcome. Then we can sell/release him to promoted team as soon as that happens. So what. You also claim that "its hard to move him on" - I can't see that happening - who was last HG player capable of scoring and assisting we failed to move on? We even got 35 mil for Johnson this season after he fell down the pecking order...
Your explanation also kind of proves that you did not fully read what I wrote. Where you say "So, we sign Wilson, just for the sake of it apparently, and while Kudus is injured (we assume) Wilson plays = Tel doesnt" which is exactly the opposite what I have repeated - I would give Tel benefit of the doubt and first chance to impress. But only when he still does not deliver the goals and assist - then we would have an alternative.
Again - for maybe 10th time - I am not saying that Wilson would be my dream signing.
I am just using him as an example of hedging bets. I feel that you prefer "all or nothing" approach. Which to me is suicidal on the back of 2 17th place finishes.
I am ONLY promoting such kind of deal to have MORE SPENDING POWER elsewhere and to get more data on the young prospects that we already have on the books. If we are to make final decision on Odobert and Tel based on what we have seen so far - it would be to axe them, feels pretty clear.
Short - you want to gamble "What if Tel improves" without alternative to fall back on.
I say - "sure, let's gamble. Let's use Tel as a starter in beginning of next season. But lets also buy a cheapish insurance policy".
Also I have absolutely no clue why you keep throwing around terms like "regressing to the mean" like I would be focusing in last season with my numbers. When in fact I am talking about 5 season average.
Kudus was marked so heavily because no opponent had to worry about us attacking down our left, we presented so little danger there. With a really tricky winger there next year opponents will not be able to tighten up on Kudus so much so we should see even more danger from him.No, I don’t. That why I said “I don’t think Kudus showed enough with us”. But, he didn’t impress me at West Ham either.
And he’s also a guy who believes he’s a number ten, so he’s never going to be at his best on the wing.
I’m not concerned that you don’t rate Kudus.I don't rate Kudus and on Savinho I saw a promising start to his Ciyy career and then nothing. That should concern everyone
As to who we bring in,no.idea, but what you proposed wouldn't scare any team. Might scare me in truth.
No missions.
I don't rate Kudus and on Savinho I saw a promising start to his Ciyy career and then nothing. That should concern everyone
As to who we bring in,no.idea, but what you proposed wouldn't scare any team. Might scare me in truth.
I'd rather Harry Wilson than Savinho.He reminds me of a signing we'd make under Jol. Some Malbranque type that'd decent but ultimately a mid table player.
I pray you are correct. I fear you aren’t and we’ve signed another bang average winger, who will give us 10 g/a for the next couple of seasons and then end up at Besiktas.Kudus was marked so heavily because no opponent had to worry about us attacking down our left, we presented so little danger there. With a really tricky winger there next year opponents will not be able to tighten up on Kudus so much so we should see even more danger from him.
I know, it's too late now - and he'd most probably would have demanded a transfer my now...but anyway...
View: https://x.com/PolymarketSport/status/2064116526295175475
Thankfully NO