Your argument was that he was too good for us. I disagree. Yes he won plenty at United but come on that was more down to them having players like Ronaldo and Rio and Vidic and Tevez and Evra and peak Rooney than because they signed Michael blooming Carrick!And what did he go on to win after his move?
What did we win after his move?
Granted at UTD there times he could have been used more effectively but that is the thing about UTD they are able to have such a large squad packed with talent and Fergie knew how to get the best out of his players.