Skip to content

What life would be like under Van Gaal

9 min read
by Jai B

We know the man, we know the name, but what does Louis van Gaal the manager believe in? Is he a “get out there and run around” or is he dossier dude? Jai B delves into his mind and footballing philosophy.

The Fighting Cock recently posted an article on Louis van Gaal that focused on his personality more than his football philosophy. The article received a great variance of opinions in the comments and forum. To counter balance this I thought it would be a good idea to give more of an insight into the footballing ethos and philosophies of Van Gaal.

download (1)If he is to be our next head coach, it would be a worth a look to see how his system could be implemented at Tottenham as well as the players that would fit into a Van Gaal formation. I’ll be analysing this through the use of slides he had prepared with his time at FC Barcelona.

In general Van Gaal has stuck to the same system throughout all of his clubs, and if needed I will further look into his work at Ajax and Bayern Munich at a later date; but fundamentally there will be significant overlaps.

Van Gaal had set three main targets for the Spanish giants. These were: to win the greatest number of trophies available, to do achieve this with an attractive style of football, and to play this football with the greatest possible number of players that have been trained at the club’s academy.

Perhaps though the main attribute to a Van Gaal style of play, that is not listed, is that the team is greater than all of the individual players.

In his Barcelona presentation Van Gaal writes, “Each individual player has an obligation to meet and defend the idea of the club.”

The Van Gaal system 

The Dutchman treats the game of football in four main sections. The transition from going from without the ball to with the ball, being in possession of the ball, the transition from losing the ball, and playing without the ball.


The transition phases are focused around the positioning of the players after possession changes to prevent goal scoring opportunities for your opponents, and to create these opportunities for yourselves.

Van Gaal believes that this is important high up the pitch, as winning possession in the attacking third would allow less time for the opponent for positional organisation whereas his Barcelona side would already be set up for seizing goal scoring opportunities after the transition of position.

The current Netherlands manager describes being in possession as, “using the space and time, in relation to colleagues, to take possession of the ball for as long as possible.” Holding the possession is then split into four further subsections: phase construction, preparing to create a chance, creating the chance, and scoring. I will look more deeply into how this is achieved further down in the article.


You could argue that Van Gaal’s default formation is a 4-3-3 with a deep lying midfield playmaker, but in truth this one system can be tweaked and changed almost effortlessly depending on the type of opposition that the team is playing against.

This formation is based on a set of positions, with horizontal/vertical/diagonal lines drawn to form triangles which allows for a perfect coverage of the pitch via movements of the ball, with further positional rotations to retain the fluidity of the system, and players, while not deviating from these passing lines.


The biggest advantages can be seen when playing against either the 4-2-3-1/4-4-1-1 formation or 4-4-2. The key advantage when playing against one man upfront is that the centre backs are allowed more time with possession.

We will look into the passing roles of the centre backs later on. Even if the opposition secondary striker, or number 10, presses the centre backs whilst they are in possession, the number 6 is made free to receive passes and dictate the play.

The number 6 holds the key advantage when playing against a 4-4-2, the player in the number 6 position holds the most paths in terms of passing lines. And when paired with the centre backs in a 3v2 situation against the opposition forwards, the numerical overload would allow for greater time on the ball to pick which of his eight passing channels would be most effective in terms of changing possession into a view to create a goal scoring opportunity; the next phase of possession as outlined above.

Within the teamwork and positional play that Van Gaal had set up for FC Barcelona, and his other clubs, he still appreciates the personality, technical and physical qualities of the players available in his squad. I will only examine briefly, the centre backs, and the three central midfielders.

The two centre backs, most likely chosen from Dawson/Vertonghen/Chiriches/new transfer (I don’t see Kaboul signing a new contract with the club), are as important as starting the attacking play as defending in this system.

It is their responsibility to change the direction of the game, in order to catch the opposition out of position; they must always be available to receive the ball between them with the potential to switch the play of attack.

This is on top of regular defensive work, Van Gaal writes that “ability to communicate marking techniques effectively within a game” as the main mental aspect towards the role of his ideal centre back. With Dawson’s leadership skills and perhaps some more training on his sporadic diagonal balls it is reasonable to assume he would be a stalwart in Van Gaal’s side.


Further forward in the central areas of the field lays perhaps the most important player in the Van Gaal system, the number 6. Both Pep Guardiola and Xavi have taken up this role for Barcelona under the tutelage of the Dutchman.

The number 6 should be always available to receive the ball, can pass the ball directly, and create space in central areas by off the ball movement, whilst also adding to the goals scored column. Which Spurs players come to mind after reading this description?

Personally, I believe that Lewis Holtby or perhaps Moussa Dembele would be the best fit. Holtby, in particular, shows a great work ethic and does have the ability to influence the game from deeper areas.

In his slides Van Gaal has described his ideal number 6 as: “a leader/conductor, disciplined and responsible, showing self confidence with authority and charisma.”

Holtby has captained his national side at u21 level, and has also played under Felix Magath, an intense and hardworking coach, for two different clubs; making him already conditioned for life under Louis van Gaal. It is important to also note that Dembele has previously played for Louis van Gaal at AZ, winning the Eredivisie by an 11 point margin.

In his stint at Ajax Van Gaal said:

Lots of coaches devote their time to wondering how they can ensure that their players are able to do a lot of running during a match. Ajax trains its players to run as little as possible on the field. That is why positional games are always central.”

The other central midfield players are the number 8, and 10; who clog the central areas of the pitch. One of the main aims for the clogging of the centre is to increase the numerical advantages in the system, in terms of bodies. Through triangular passing rotations the extra men in midfield will be able to move the ball forward, using quick passes, in order to create goal scoring opportunities; with a view to play the ball to the centre backs who can switch the play if an opportunity doesn’t present itself.

The skills that are heavily required from the more creative and advanced midfield players are: the ability to beat a man in a congested area, smart and overlapping runs, quick mental thinking with and without the ball, and the decision making to score goals for the team.

In a defensive aspect, these two players must be able to communicate effectively to construct successful presses to regain possession high up the pitch with a view to create a goal scoring opportunity from the transitional phase. 


However, this form of passing is not only done in the midfield. Louis Van Gaal’s system has automatically set up shapes of play, known as ‘Rondos’. The above graphic shows the potential overloads in every area of the field. ‘Rondos’ allow for quick passing of the ball, and keeping the possession too.

This is both effective when clearing the ball from the back, and fishing out opportunities to create goal scoring chances in the attacking third. An example of a ‘Rondo’ is shown in the video below, here the Spanish u21 side are successful in keeping possession in a tight defensive area after winning the ball back from the opposition in the transition phase. Then, as I’ve stated above, they move the ball through to the other side of the pitch in via the centre backs to shift the play.

There are three lines of passes used in a ‘Rondo’. These are aptly named: first, second and third line passes. The first line pass refers to a pass that is directed to a teammate using the horizontal pass lines. The second line pass is a pass that goes past a defender, but not in the space in between them, with a third line pass being one that dissects the two defenders. The technical advantages of this is to create one and two touch short passing, with a quick rhythm of play with constant movement, and improved control with the ball at your feet.

Players such as Christian Eriksen and Gylfi Sigurdsson would be ideal for the advanced midfield positions, especially in regards to third line passes, with the likes of Tom Carroll and Nabil Bentaleb probably playing cup games in these positions, or the number 6 role.

Youth players like Carroll and Bentaleb would relish an opportunity to play under Van Gaal as he picks a team regardless of previous merit, age and reputation. If you recall, his third target when taking over FC Barcelona was to use the greatest number of players trained in the club academy as possible.

In fact Van Gaal was the one to promote Carles Puyol and Xavi from the FC Barcelona ‘B’ team. The arrogant Dutch manager has also always kept one coach from the previous reign to help his knowledge on the youth players of the club. This worked wonders at FC Bayern Munich as David Alaba, Thomas Mueller, and Holger Badstuber.

During his time in Germany he also reinvented Bastian Schweinsteiger as a deep lying midfielder, though he was less successful when playing Rivaldo as the number 11 rather than in the centre at FC Barcelona; leading to a famous row between the two. With Rivaldo being quoted as saying: “He does not like to listen to the opinions of the players”.

An ideal situation for Tottenham would be for Van Gaal to take over as head coach for the start of next season, with Tim Sherwood as his direct assistant.

This would allow Tim Sherwood to further increase his coaching potential by learning from the best, and it would also give allow him to work closely with Van Gaal on the development of the younger first team players. With a certain footballing philosophy being transferred to Sherwood and the younger players at the new training centre, this could be a second second start in the modern era of Tottenham Hotspur.

All views and opinions expressed in this article are the views and opinions of the writer and do not necessarily represent the views of The Fighting Cock. We offer a platform for fans to commit their views to text and voice their thoughts. Football is a passionate game and as long as the views stay within the parameters of what is acceptable, we encourage people to write, get involved and share their thoughts on the mighty Tottenham Hotspur.

Jai B


  1. Jim
    05/03/2014 @ 3:55 pm

    Somehow, the quotes are omitted. Nice article regardless.

    • Jim
      05/03/2014 @ 3:58 pm

      Now they are there. Maybe it is just me.

  2. David
    05/03/2014 @ 4:06 pm

    Interesting stuff, thanks. So, with your knowledge of Van Gaal’s systems and the sort of players he likes, I wonder whether you could have a go at answering the following:

    Where would Sandro fit in, if anywhere? If the deepest-lying midfielder (the 6) is someone who can pass, you mention Dembele and Holtby, would Sandro be an option there or is he the wrong sort of player? I’m also wondering about Paulinho, would he fit there or one of the other two midfield positions best? Or again, not at all? It sounds to me like Huddlestone may have been ideal for this position :-(

    Further forward, if we have a front three, does he like a lone striker with wingers on either side? So would we be looking at, say, Adebayor supported by Lennon/Chadli/Townsend? Or does he favour players such as Mourinho uses in those roles, attacking midfielders? Would Adebayor suit the main striker role? Or Soldado? Whereabouts would you see Lamela playing, if at all?

    Of course, these are all players currently with us, we would more than likely sell/buy a few but based on what you’ve said and what we have at present, would this be a fair guess at a first team?

    Walker – Chririches – Vertonghen – Rose/Fryers
    Eriksen – Sigurdsson
    Lennon – Adebayor – Chadli

    Possibly with Dembele replacing Sigurdsson and Lamela in the equation somewhere…

  3. Chris
    05/03/2014 @ 4:10 pm

    All sounds great….. the only fly in the ointment…… will Levy allow him to DO THE JOB!
    Restrain himself from firing the man if we fail to win all the first 30 games.
    Van Gaal is as good as anything out there !
    His track record is without equal.

  4. Spurgatso
    05/03/2014 @ 4:29 pm

    I believe avb came hghly rated,Epl is somewhat different to European style,another 18months while the systems get implemented and absorbed.Then if hasnt worked what then,another 18months titting about with the next super manager and so on …

    • David
      05/03/2014 @ 4:39 pm

      To be fair Spurgatso, whilst I share your pessimism to an extent, he has achieved a lot more than AVB in his career so it’s not a fair comparison really. But it is true that success elsewhere doesn’t mean automatic success here. I was encouraged by an article I read earlier in which one of the de Boers was adamant that Van Gaal would be successful wherever he went.

    • AnythingButPenalties
      06/03/2014 @ 10:47 pm

      Look at the managers who have won the Premier League in recent years. Apart from Ferguson, they’ve all been continental Europeans. There’s highly rated, then there’s winning Dutch, German and Spanish titles and three Champions League finals.

  5. abe
    05/03/2014 @ 4:42 pm

    Nothing against avb but he had one good season at Porto with some fantastic players. Very few managers out there have a cv like van gaal. And the best number 6 based on above would be Tom Carroll

  6. Joe
    05/03/2014 @ 5:05 pm

    Hard to see Van Gaal and Sherwood working together. One man places ‘the system’ above all else, the others mantra is ‘systems don’t matter, palyers do’.

    One downside to Van Gaal coming in will be the Ade will have to leave. No way those two will ever be able to work together.

  7. D Doc
    05/03/2014 @ 5:14 pm

    Van Gal also turned Alaba into Left back having previously being a centre mid, He also tried various formations at Bayern before settling on 433/4411 variation.
    The good thing about Van Gal is he will adjust his system slightly if needed to facilitate players at his disposal.
    I wouldn’t be surprised to see a midfield & forward line of

  8. roy
    05/03/2014 @ 7:14 pm

    Bit beyond me , but have to say looking forward to next season And hope to see the flying Dutchman at the lane

  9. roy
    05/03/2014 @ 7:15 pm

    Bit beyond me , but a good read have to say looking forward to next season And hope to see the flying Dutchman at the lane

  10. spurian
    05/03/2014 @ 11:18 pm

    lets not start sucking each others d1ck5 just yet!. he aint here yet

  11. Philo
    06/03/2014 @ 1:34 pm

    My worry is Man Utd nipping in before us to hire LvG, not wanting to trust Moyes with spending the 200m rebuilding money.

  12. AnythingButPenalties
    06/03/2014 @ 10:38 pm

    Brilliant article. The more I read about van Gaal, the more excited I am at the prospect of having him at Spurs. There’s a long way still to go before that happens.

    He isn’t the same as our previous foreign coaches we’ve had at Spurs. He’s won the German, Spanish and Dutch League and the Champions League.

    For me his most interesting achievement is winning the Dutch League with perennial also-rans AZ Alkmar who hadn’t won a title for decades. Sounds promising.

  13. Park Lane Spurs
    07/03/2014 @ 4:10 pm

    So the first thing we need to do is buy Luka back then… he’s one of the best on the planet at that role. Also it would be a shame to let Kaboul go, before the last season or so injured, he was looking like a class act. Good Articale though and I’m much keener on his attacking football with a plan, as opposed to Tim’s random, see how it pan out… maybe he’s the right mix we have been looking for..

  14. Rob Thissen
    09/03/2014 @ 11:31 am

    Good article, as a dutch Londoner I can agree with most. Looking at yesterday’s shambles I do think the key wouldnt necessarily be the style of play and players but the whole organisation around it.

    There is a lack of structure and cohesion at the club at the moment. Van gaal will need backing from upstairs as well as in the dressing room. Our opera singer / technical director will need to go, as are half of the players he brought in. They don’t fit v. Gaals way of playing. Furthermore key will be the succession plan. V. Gaal won’t be there for years. Because of his age and because he always picks fights wherever he goes. I like sherwoods attitude Certainly after yesterday’s interview. But he will need to learn, still makes too many tactical blunders. Hope he can stay under v gaal, be the link with the club and youth academy. My fellow country man will shake things up and try to get us playing an attractive style again.. but there is a good chance hell get the sack after one or two years

  15. anup venu
    23/04/2014 @ 5:37 am

    he is going to united hahaha :P

Would you like to write for The Fighting Cock?