Why so long winded?
Be it Pochettino or Southgate: the question is the same. Do you put a semi final hat- trick hero on the bench so as to start a player that has been out crocked since the first leg of the quarterfinals. I work in construction and don’t claim to have the skills either Southgate or Pochettino have; but I do have some footballing common sense and I was arguing this point immediately after Amsterdam so how did Pochettino mess up so badly - why did he cave in? And cave in is exactly what he did!
Did Klopp put a 2 goal hero in Origi on the bench to start off with and is Liverpool's depth as a squad greater than ours?
Would you feel the same about Kane not starting if we had won a 1st half penalty and Son or Lucas taken it and missed like both have done already this season I believe? It's all hear say, there's no way of knowing that if Kane hadn't started and Lucas had that we would have won 1-0 or lost by even more. Impossible to say or to conclude but with my hand on heart, I do think playing Harry in a one off biggest game was the right call.
In the league games played after Kane got injured we played 6, won 2 and lost 3 & drew 1, meaningless game at the end of the season
Huddersfield - won 4-0
Man City - lost 1-0
Brighton - won 1-0
West Ham - lost 1-0
Bournemouth - lost 1-0
Everton - drew 2-2
Apart from the brace Sonny scored in the quarter finals, one of which went straight through the goalkeeper, he hasn't exactly been in great form. Yes he missed the last game of the season but I'm surprised more hasn't been made of Sonny over Lucas. Just my opinion though.
Personally I don't think it was Pochettino caving in, I think he did what he felt was right and that was play one of the worlds best strikers in a Champions League final. Right or wrong or what his reasons were we aren't to know. It was harsh on Lucas but he did still get 30 minutes to impacts the game and the best chance did fall to his feet which he scuffed across the floor when it landed to his feet at a very good distance out.
I don't know what was the right call or not, all I know was when I saw the teamsheet I was happy with what I saw knowing Lucas could change a game off the bench more than I believed Harry or Sonny could. That for me was a deciding factor that made sense to me more so than any reasons people can speculate about but as mentioned it's each to their own.