• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Management ENIC

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

ENIC In or ENIC Out


  • Total voters
    209
Rice is a better (and younger) player than Maddison, so in that sense, yes, it's the better signing.

However, *if* we had the same 105M to spend, with our current squad and needs, Maddison for 40 is a much better signing than Rice for the whole 105

IF
Is he?

maddison-table-1687951172-110204.png
 
How are folk comparing Rice to Maddison, they're completely different players?

They’re just trying to bash levy for not spending £105 million on a player because we have more areas of the team to improve than just 2 or 3 like them. Despite the fact Man City pulled out at £90 million and Chelsea, Man Utd and Liverpool didn’t want to pay that either despite all probably wanting the player. It’s apparently levy’s fault he’s gone there despite us signing Maddison. Some people just have them on the brain.
 
Ok, as you're being a dick.

Do you really think signing Rice is better than signing Maddison?

You realise we have also signed a keeper this week too? I struggle to see how you think Woolwich are showing us up?
Not showing us up but Rice is a good player and could be a stellar signing. Maddison is the better deal pound for pound I would think
 
They’re just trying to bash levy for not spending £105 million on a player because we have more areas of the team to improve than just 2 or 3 like them. Despite the fact Man City pulled out at £90 million and Chelsea, Man Utd and Liverpool didn’t want to pay that either despite all probably wanting the player. It’s apparently levy’s fault he’s gone there despite us signing Maddison. Some people just have them on the brain.

Thought bashing Levy was out of fashion lately, clearly not 😆
 
They’re just trying to bash levy for not spending £105 million on a player because we have more areas of the team to improve than just 2 or 3 like them. Despite the fact Man City pulled out at £90 million and Chelsea, Man Utd and Liverpool didn’t want to pay that either despite all probably wanting the player. It’s apparently levy’s fault he’s gone there despite us signing Maddison. Some people just have them on the brain.
No

My criticism would be whether Levy would done a similar deal when we flying in 2016-2018 and he didn’t
 
Rice is a better (and younger) player than Maddison, so in that sense, yes, it's the better signing.

However, *if* we had the same 105M to spend, with our current squad and needs, Maddison for 40 is a much better signing than Rice for the whole 105

IF

£40m for Maddison is WAY better than £105m for Rice and there is no argument on earth that can convince me otherwise.
 
£40m for Maddison is WAY better than £105m for Rice and there is no argument on earth that can convince me otherwise.
I mean it's like saying buying Kevin Wimmer for 4.3M, getting some decent performances out of him when others were injured, and then recouping 18M for him two summers later is a better deal than Virgil van Dijk for 75M.

On one level the transfer market is about value and getting the best deals. On another level football is about having the best players.
 
I mean it's like saying buying Kevin Wimmer for 4.3M, getting some decent performances out of him when others were injured, and then recouping 18M for him two summers later is a better deal than Virgil van Dijk for 75M.

On one level the transfer market is about value and getting the best deals. On another level football is about having the best players.
Best players for the situation too. Sometimes you overpay if the situation requires and it’s still good value (cost not price)
 
Hard to let go of that missed opportunity. We had an amazing 11 and completely shit the bed

Agree tho. Early, sensible deals in key positions suggest a step change
Tbf we have been going backwards for years, with others spending big Levy had little choice but to get the checkbook out unless he wanted bottom half and worse to come with Kane leaving the following year. Levy always has spent when back to the wall, it’s when we’ve needed ambition to go for the top he’s went AWOL. Looks like we are aiming to get back competing for Europe monie$ he’s missing so well done him…
 
Back
Top