• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Was sacking Ange a good idea?

  • Yes, I think it was a good idea.

    Votes: 73 64.6%
  • No, I think it was a bad idea.

    Votes: 40 35.4%

  • Total voters
    113
Flesh out the hypo here, on what date did Southgate take over from Ange?


Yup this has been my experience as well both IRL and elsewhere on the internet.
Let's say Southgate was brought in at the end of January, when we were 15th and losers of 6 out of 7, but still could have salvaged the domestic cups. I think at that point 90% were Ange Out except those who didn't want to make a change but for the cups.
 
Spoken to a few Spurs fans over the past two weeks and what strikes me is that not one of them has been completely anti-Ange as some are in here.

Even at the Brighton game everyone was unsure of what we should do.

I'm not sure keeping Ange would divide the fanbase as some on here would have us believe.
Story checks out

A lot of our fans are about as bright as an eclipse
 
Spoken to a few Spurs fans over the past two weeks and what strikes me is that not one of them has been completely anti-Ange as some are in here.

Even at the Brighton game everyone was unsure of what we should do.

I'm not sure keeping Ange would divide the fanbase as some on here would have us believe.
Your anecdote is also word for word the opposite of another poster can't recall his name think he has Gascoigne in his avatar. Said he was at the Brighton game and loads of people he spoke to were not devastated by the idea of removing Postecoglou. So I'm not sure you're making a great case for Anges retention. Just telling us about sample size. What's that axiom about the plural of anecdote not being data.
 
Your anecdote is also word for word the opposite of another poster can't recall his name think he has Gascoigne in his avatar. Said he was at the Brighton game and loads of people he spoke to were not devastated by the idea of removing Postecoglou. So I'm not sure you're making a great case for Anges retention. Just telling us about sample size. What's that axiom about the plural of anecdote not being data.
Attention span of the average football fan is woefully short in this day and age, wait for the inevitable ropey downturn in league results right around when the CL league stage games start and half these people will have flipped on him before September is out.
 
Do you really think there's something unique in our case that disbars that possibility? We had top 8 finishes and cup final appearances under Redknapp, Poch x2 and Mourinho/Mason. We lost the CC final under Redknapp on penalties. Are you saying divine intervention prevented us from winning that final because we were too high up the league at the time? Or that despite the teams being unable to be separated after 120 minutes (the same Fergie Utd side that were the reigning CL AND PL champions at the time btw) there was some failing on the part of Redknapp or Levy/the board that we lost a shootout?

Win or lose in football it's always a collective success and failure respectively from board down to players however the person that can make a difference on the day is the coach.

We can talk about luck, divine intervention, injuries etc...but I'll be honest no-one gives a fuck about all that if you don't win, the history books do not remember runners up and you don't get any prizes for finishing 2nd.

If you're willing to throw the blame at the manager for losing 22 matches which is more than fair by the way then you gotta keep the same energy when he wins and wins something significant at that , something that this club hadn't done for 17 years previously.

I watched it. Doesn't erase all the times I watched us get dicked down by absolute dross in the league though, or watching team performances get steadily worse in the league for 18 months.

You value the league form over a cup win, that's your prerogative, cool 😎
 

Apologies if this has already been posted and discussed ; but why wouldnt it make senes for MC to come in as assistent to AP . He’s completely grounded in English football and the EPL . He was tremendously effective as a player ( and that includes before , whilst and after playing for us) .

If the Ange post - UEFA / Europa : MC dream ticket goes very badly wrong ; Daniel could bin-off Ange and go with the new best thing . From what I’ve read he’s considered to be an excellent coach and tactician .

Last and by no means least he’s a free agent and would cost precisely nothing to bring on board .

I can well see MC eventually breaking into the big time as a manager / coach . Why shouldn’t that be with us .

Stranger things etc ….
MC got canned from Boro for a lot of the same issues that we have with Ange.

Too set on his way to play football and struggling to adapt to his opponents or make in game changes.
 
Win or lose in football it's always a collective success and failure respectively from board down to players however the person that can make a difference on the day is the coach.

We can talk about luck, divine intervention, injuries etc...but I'll be honest no-one gives a fuck about all that if you don't win, the history books do not remember runners up and you don't get any prizes for finishing 2nd.

If you're willing to throw the blame at the manager for losing 22 matches which is more than fair by the way then you gotta keep the same energy when he wins and wins something significant at that , something that this club hadn't done for 17 years previously.



You value the league form over a cup win, that's your prerogative, cool 😎
You still seem to be making the representation that this is a binary issue, that there exists no such person in world football management who may have similar chances to Ange of winning a trophy (especially if gifted such an easy run to a final) without having to utterly sacrifice the league campaign to achieve it. The proof is there in that we have reached 4 finals, including the most prestigious final in world club football, inside the 17 year timeframe between our two most recent trophy wins. You have to play just as many games to lose a final as win one, which means actually getting over the line at the final hurdle has absolutely no bearing on whether the league form would have suffered to the same extent.

I don't really understand how me not wanting to roll the dice with the only Tottenham manager to accumulate a points total that has got teams relegated in the premier league era, equates in your head to "valuing league form over a cup win". I would take 8th and a cup over 4th and no cup, even if it meant no CL qualification. There is a gulf of difference between being ok with a 25-30% placement underachievement in exchange for silverware vs rolling the dice on genuine relegation form on the off chance we can Stoke our way to another cup next season.
 
A major European trophy that was won by beating England’s 16th best team in a final after knocking out AZ Alkmaar, Frankfurt and Bodo Glimt. After beating the likes of Qarabag and Elfsborg in the groups. Context is awesome isn’t it?
Context is awesome. It’s just better when it’s applied evenly and not solely to support an agenda. Like how you highlight beating Man Utd in a final being different to losing to Liverpool or Man City in one breath, yet in the next downplay the entire achievement of winning the Europa League based on the quality of opposition, conveniently ignoring all the times Tottenham have lost to less than stellar competition in previous cup competitions (Butbutbut they weren’t taking it seriously, they were fully focused on winning the ‘4th place finish in the league trophy!’) Anything to avoid giving the manager a shred of credit I guess.

Remember Mourinho getting pumped 3-0 and dumped out of Europe by Dinamo Zagreb (who?) I’m certain if we put our heads together we could come up with other examples. You know what’s a hell of lot worse than beating sides the quality of Bodo, Frankfurt, and AZ Alkmaar? Losing to sides of that quality and not winning a goddamn thing.

Cheer up and enjoy it.
 
This coming from the man who said a few pages ago he doesn't believe the concept of "luck" exists, you will excuse me if I don't lose any sleep over your half-arsed attempt at a put-down.

LOL, luck is a made-up idea by humans as a psychological and cultural mechanism for coping with randomness.

It is not a force, you cannot measure it, it is a completely subjective and made-up

The concept exist but luck itself does not outside of peoples imagination.
 
I suggest they make an announcement quickly. 😆 😆😆

Gsnjak-VXs-AAa7-CN.jpg
 
Back
Top