Two thumbs=two more?
The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...
Two thumbs=two more?
I don't think you can count the WB as pure defenders, though. And 4/5 for 2 WB positions, given what's asked of them, is not bad. We do need an extra player for the front 3 and we're fine in midfield. I'd have Skipp over Benta, however.Our current squad, with adjustment for obvious outgoings. HG quota narrowly met.
![]()
There's a bit of an imbalance as we have 12 defenders for 5 positions, but only 9 FWD/MIDs for 5 positions.
We can add another player without having to get rid of anyone else, as long as they are HG.
A non-HG in would mean we need a non-HG out.
Rodon out (loan?) for another CB seems like a no-brainer. An attacking midfielder would also add squad balance. One of those 2 would have to be HG.
Tanganga may as well be loaned as he won't get much game-time, even though we'd be left with a smaller squad.
Luis disagrees with youIt's rare for a Barca player to leave and do better elsewhere?
Like I said, he did well when he arrived & then got usurped by Barcelona's 100 odd million quid winger in the same role, as well as a few others who they paid big money for. Not surprising that the player on loan got pushed to the sidelines.
But as Airfixx pointed out, he did get some minutes but wasn't productive during them. Think he got some matches in Europa and couldn't deliver.
This isn't really true though..... You're including Rodon & Tanganga whilst neglecting to include Gil & Sarr.
Flip that and it's:
DEF: 10 for 5
ATT/MF: 11 for 5
Yes because whether I include Rodon or his CB replacement, it doesn't change the number of CBs.
That current squad as I listed means we have a maximum of 24 players in our squad overall.Not what I was suggesting, but without re-crunching the numbers, you're saying that without Rodon (who's not HG in Europe anyway) or Japh, we're consigned ot only having 19 outfield players in the squad? or 21 with them?
Djed Spence has 4 goals in 112 games.
Do you not want him either?
Yeah, I agree with having 5 WBs for the 2 positions, especially as Spence is an unknown quantity.I don't think you can count the WB as pure defenders, though. And 4/5 for 2 WB positions, given what's asked of them, is not bad. We do need an extra player for the front 3 and we're fine in midfield. I'd have Skipp over Benta, however.
But Gibson has been the difficult one, the asshole in this particular dealCheap as chips, and has Levy written all over the deal.
Great signing.
Yes because whether I include Rodon or his CB replacement, it doesn't change the number of CBs.
Gil and Sarr as different as they are likely to be loaned out like last season,
That current squad as I listed means we have a maximum of 24 players in our squad overall.
We can't add a non-HG to that (whether Gil, Sarr or a new player) unless you take a non-HG out.
The very fastest network of any country in the world, but I see your point lolJust curious why some people think we can’t secure a transfer in or out while we are in Korea? They do have a mobile phone network there right?
No VAR replay required then ... phew
He won’t rank up with Bissouma or Perisic for elite name but I have been quite excited to get him.
Obviously caught the eye against Woolwich in the cup. He is very raw but we haven’t had a full back/wing back with this level of speed or physical power and aggression since Walker. The game against Woolwich he murdered Martinelli who is one of Arsenals quickest players so having someone who has out and out elite pace will be a benefit.
I think we'll get another CB in this window, but let's see.I suspect if we're up for selling Rodon it doesn't depend on a replacement.
Gil/ Sarr won't make the CL squad, and very likely to be both loaned out. Maximum they'll stay till Jan to get some Conte training and League Cup matches, before being loaned out then.I don't think you or I really have that insight...... At least not until the end of the window.
UCL. Domestic we easily make squad requirements. But if we want to fight for trophies on multiple fronts, we need big and balanced squads in both UCL and PL.You're talking Domestic here? ......Cos obv. Davies, Doh & Rodon are a curve-ball in terms of Europe.
Maybe the rest of the window. Apart from outs I reckon we are done for the window.
If Spence is half as good an RWB as Doc I will be delighted.Don't anyone try to convince me DJ isn't a big upgrade on Doherty or Royale.
Ever.