That's me. And it was an accurate assessment at the time. He is indeed physical, and he was a bit loose and careless with some of his play.
I did say he can defend, only that he rarely tracked back. No lies there either.
He's definitely better than I thought, much better, but the laziness wasn't something only I noticed either. I even said a few weeks back how surprised I was by his defensive workrate. Something a lot of people have also said about Maddison btw.
I'm sure I pointed out his lack of crossing in that or some other post too, and how that might be a problem under Conte. His style of short passing and 1-2s instead of crossing like Porro is also exactly what I talked about.