• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Igor Tudor

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

I wasn't convinced Frank was flying us up the league...but to excuse Postecoglou from any blame and say its delusional that he has any part in why we are bad is just wrong

......

He didn't manage an injury crisis he refused to take the league seriously because he struggled to compete......he would never have been afforded the opportunity to have a shot at the europa league if last seasons bottom 3 teams were any good.

Yes. These are all the reasons he was sacked for last season.

What on earth does any of it have to do with this current season?
 
Because he inherited a team that thought 22 losses in a season was normal
And his response to that was that "we'll play well for 10 games a season, badly for 10 games a season and average for the rest".
What a way to inspire a struggling squad!

Frank being shit had nothing to do with what happened before him, it was all his own fault.
His tactics were as basic as fuck, he had no spirit about him and he choked at the chance to work at a big club with international level players.

That anyone is even trying to excuse Franks pathetic attempt at managing us is laughable in itself.
 
Why wasn’t he able to explain to them it wasn’t?

it was also a team that got to the Semis of both cup competitions. How come Frank didn’t continue that mentality from Ange?
Exactly that, any half-decent manager would have focused on the positives from the previous season and used that to build upon.
Frank somehow managed to crush our confidence even more and drive us backwards.

Last season was a spring board and the club managed to slip off the end and crack it's head on it on the way down!
 
HAVE WE BEEN RELEGATED?

And seriously, that cup win and the weeks that followed were amazing, just what we all needed after so many years.
I don't see why you're linking that to how shit we've been since?

It's because Matt1882 decided on the day Ange Postecoglou was signed that he was shit and anyone who didn't say otherwise was someone he could bully and abuse. Which he then did for two whole seasons.

His derangement was so bad he didn't even bother going to Bilbao despite having the loyalty points and despite it being our biggest moment as a club for 40 years.

So it's no surprise that having acted so appallingly to other Spurs fans for two fucking years, getting his wish (Postecoglou sacked) Matt1882 was a little crestfallen when we didn't suddenly fly up the ladder - but instead are on the brink of Relegation.

Normal people would take a moment to reflect and, perhaps, admit they had been wrong and apologise for their behaviour. But not Matt1882. He's decided it's normal Spurs fans who celebrated winning the Europa League that are directly responsible for us being in a relegation battle.

That's how derangement works. And it ain't pretty. :ange-bored: :D
 
And his response to that was that "we'll play well for 10 games a season, badly for 10 games a season and average for the rest".
What a way to inspire a struggling squad!

Frank being shit had nothing to do with what happened before him, it was all his own fault.
His tactics were as basic as fuck, he had no spirit about him and he choked at the chance to work at a big club with international level players.

That anyone is even trying to excuse Franks pathetic attempt at managing us is laughable in itself.

Bit of a straw man.

The question was related to managers doing a 180 on the prior season.

Frank was a bit shit and not suited to this job, but that doesn't discount the fact that I think very few managers would be able to bounce back from such an awful season to being back in the top 5.

There's clearly much more at play with this squad than coaching and tactics. The players still here from last season look like their life's ambition was to win the Europa League, and have effectively Wimmer'd themselves into submission.
 
Why wasn’t he able to explain to them it wasn’t?

it was also a team that got to the Semis of both cup competitions. How come Frank didn’t continue that mentality from Ange?
Aren’t there parallels though?

Frank had us 4th in the Champions League despite very poor domestic form.

I think it indicates more about the quality of the European tournaments when compared to the Premier League.
 
Bit of a straw man.

The question was related to managers doing a 180 on the prior season.

Frank was a bit shit and not suited to this job, but that doesn't discount the fact that I think very few managers would be able to bounce back from such an awful season to being back in the top 5.

There's clearly much more at play with this squad than coaching and tactics. The players still here from last season look like their life's ambition was to win the Europa League, and have effectively Wimmer'd themselves into submission.
What's a straw fucking man?
(Jesus, I hate these trendy expressions that people love to throw around these days).

Any manager with personality and confidence would have been able to build on the positives from last season and it's not like they're dealing with a squad full of talentless duds.
We've seen it happen all over the game for decades.

The players just need a manager to connect with them and give them confidence in their own abilities, not stifle their talent (like Frank), or treat them like shit (Tudor).
The manager doesn't even have to be a tactical genius, although probably slightly more tactical that Ange was to be fair! 😁
 
If Mason is the option, I'm tempted to see it out with Tudor instead.

Nothing real new, and no natural authority. Not at all confident he can come in and change things to the better.

Have you already forgotten how he used to pick his friends as first on the matchsheet, however flat their last games had been?
Surly it’s just better to go with Harry and Sherwood with the likes of Defoe , Teddy or Sir Les helping out. It’s all hands on deck time with people who care about the club. Not some has been non entity like Tudor and his back room team. Exactly what experience do they bring. Sure they should have kept Jonny H after Frank was sacked.
 
Tudor should have at least acknowledged Kinsky as he left the pitch, but going up and making a point of shaking Tudor’s hand just shows what a disrespectful little prick Spence is!

The same Spence that snubbed Frank when leaving the pitch.

It’s attitudes like this that need ejecting from this club tout suite!
I'm not his biggest fan but I actually quite liked that from Spence.
I saw it as him making a point to the manager that you just don't ignore a player who has tried their best for you.
Even if they've come up short you should appreciate them, not just ignore them.

If a manager is going to treat his players like that, like chess pieces, then they are never going to fight for him, not in today's game.
 
Like his predecessor I don't blame Tudor for being appointed but whether you are a manager or a player, you must make a positive difference or you need to be relieved of your duties as a manager,or droppe/sold as a player.

We are a club riddled with rewards and retention for inadequacy.
 
Last edited:
I'm not his biggest fan but I actually quite liked that from Spence.
I saw it as him making a point to the manager that you just don't ignore a player who has tried their best for you.
Even if they've come up short you should appreciate them, not just ignore them.

If a manager is going to treat his players like that, like chess pieces, then they are never going to fight for him, not in today's game.
Hmmmmmnn.......
 
What's a straw fucking man?
(Jesus, I hate these trendy expressions that people love to throw around these days).

Any manager with personality and confidence would have been able to build on the positives from last season and it's not like they're dealing with a squad full of talentless duds.
We've seen it happen all over the game for decades.

The players just need a manager to connect with them and give them confidence in their own abilities, not stifle their talent (like Frank), or treat them like shit (Tudor).
The manager doesn't even have to be a tactical genius, although probably slightly more tactical that Ange was to be fair! 😁

It isn't a "trendy expression". It's a form of logical fallacy going back to the 1700s.

To borrow a more informed description

The straw man fallacy occurs in the following pattern of argument:
  1. Person 1 asserts proposition X.
  2. Person 2 argues against a superficially similar proposition Y, as though an argument against Y were an argument against X.
This reasoning is a fallacy of relevance: it fails to address the proposition in question by misrepresenting the opposing position
  • Quoting an opponent's words out of context—i.e., choosing quotations that misrepresent the opponent's intentions
  • Presenting someone who defends a position poorly as the defender, then denying that person's arguments—thus giving the appearance that every upholder of that position (and thus the position itself) has been defeated
  • Oversimplifying an opponent's argument, then attacking this oversimplified version.
  • Exaggerating (sometimes grossly) an opponent's argument, then attacking this exaggerated version.

The question posed was

"How come Frank couldn’t make a similar improvement?" (e.g. a small improvement on the prior season's performance in the league)

The irony of that, of course, is that we're currently on 29 points from 29 games, having lost the last 3 under Tudor, off the back of a season where we got 38 from 38. So at this stage of relevance, the PPG is absolutely par, even being totally abominally shite.
 
I'm not his biggest fan but I actually quite liked that from Spence.
I saw it as him making a point to the manager that you just don't ignore a player who has tried their best for you.
Even if they've come up short you should appreciate them, not just ignore them.

If a manager is going to treat his players like that, like chess pieces, then they are never going to fight for him, not in today's game.
Nah!

We’ll just have to agree to disagree on that one!

I thought he was just being a twat and reinforcing everything I think is wrong with him attitude wise.

That’s two managers he’s humiliated on the public stage.
 
Last edited:
Exactly. He's walked into a floating dumpster fire and been handed a shit sandwich with a side of horrendous luck.

He’s essentially Admiral Dönitz taking over the Third Reich on May 1st 1945 .

Who was also , somewhat “ hamstrung “ by previous events ( to put it mildly ) .

If You Know Your History…..as used to be sung , when there was a football club over there .
 
Last edited:
Back
Top