• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Was sacking Ange a good idea?

  • Yes, I think it was a good idea.

    Votes: 73 64.6%
  • No, I think it was a bad idea.

    Votes: 40 35.4%

  • Total voters
    113
They were inconsistent in the league for a while but his style of play was noticeable immediately and he took them to a European final in his first season. They also showed a constant if times inconsistent upward trend of improvement. That showed everyone pretty early on, he was going to be a special manager for them.

When a manager takes over a club I always look for constant improvement. I would much rather a manager take 12/27 in his first 9 games, but show constant improvement. Rather than win his first 9 games but then get worse and worse.

Only one of those above shows a manager is improving the team, and not just relying on initial new manager bounce.


It's why Amorim, well nobody should be getting carried away and calling him a flop now. Of course at some point he will need to show improvement, but it's far too early yet. That said, there is always the need for any manager to get enough results to keep their job, enough to give them the time to improve the team. You can't just keep losing and then say you need time, it doesn't work like that. That is why doing well in another competition, like a cup final, can buy you more time too. Klopp did that, Arteta won a cup. Again Ange did neither.

We only did well in those first ten games under Ange because his tactics surprised teams. As soon as teams wised up, our results got worse and it’s continued in the same vein because he just won’t change and we’ve been playing the same way since. When the injured players come back nothing will change and it will be the same. It’s why I struggle to take those defending him seriously, a lack of acknowledgment that that’s just who we are mate.
 
We only did well in those first ten games under Ange because his tactics surprised teams. As soon as teams wised up, our results got worse and it’s continued in the same vein because he just won’t change and we’ve been playing the same way since. When the injured players come back nothing will change and it will be the same. It’s why I struggle to take those defending him seriously, a lack of acknowledgment that that’s just who we are mate.
100%

It worked. Then it didn’t.

We had injuries. They came back. And we’ve been nowhere near the level of those ten games since at all.

So either it got found out and it’s ineffective or the players aren’t trying their hardest to implement that level.

I know which one I think it is.
 
Toughest the PL has ever been my absolute arse. One team of any serious quality. Forest are fucking 2nd. City in turmoil. United are absolutely awful. Woolwich are worse than last season and Chelsea are a top 4 side at absolute best. Brighton are fucking mediocre and Villa are only a small step above. Howe’s Newcastle look great right now FFS.

Chelsea, Bournemouth and Brighton have younger squads. Other teams are a whisker away. What a terrible reason to be shit. Ange apparently wanted kids and was vocal about how happy he was with the windows. Got his 65 million quid striker too. We have no proven outstanding players? Guess that depends on your definition. We have a lot of very good players relative to the top 8 who we are now erm .. all below.

Flawed is a fucking understatement. He has us facing down a relegation fight if we lose the next few games. We are bottom half. This is all happening in his 2nd full season after two transfer windows with 130m+ spent on players he apparently wanted. We have lost to Ipswich at home and Palace with zero injuries, among other total embarrassments.

Pochettino took a squad widely considered terrible (worse than the one Ange took over with far less resources) and polished it very well indeed. Shit turned south at the end of his reign but all managers will eventually fall off, you don’t expect it in the 2nd season.

Almost any coach of real quality does better right now, let’s be honest about this. Waaa waaa injuries, as if it isn’t partly his fault and they haven’t been an issue for him at other clubs. We have 3 starting XI players out - put your big boy pants on and grind out points. We looked about as shit as Wolves with home advantage.

Comparing Ange with Poch is insulting to Poch. One made us a team to be feared, the other a team other sides are excited to face. We are a joke. A giggle for rivals. Haha aren’t spurs entertaining under the Aussie clown, aren’t they fun as we watch them concede 6 and run in to each other. Fucking hell..
Yep. The only Tottenham managers Postecoglou should be compared with are Ardiles and Gross. He clearly has the most in common with the former, a stubborn idealist who refused to play a defensive midfielder because it meant dropping one of his 'famous five' . Gross because he is cut from the same cloth of a manager who did well in minor leagues but was absurdly over promoted and couldnt cope with the premier league. The results are now matching those 2 as well.
 
Comparing Ange with Poch is insulting to Poch. One made us a team to be feared, the other a team other sides are excited to face. We are a joke. A giggle for rivals. Haha aren’t spurs entertaining under the Aussie clown, aren’t they fun as we watch them concede 6 and run in to each other. Fucking hell..

Most people will look back at Real Madrid at Wembley as one of our proudest and best European nights.

You mention some of the players who played there as some of the best in Spurs history and people will laugh at you.

50% of the players who started get absolutely rinsed as being useless on here. So were they useless? Were they great for a short while? So that meant our squad was the greatest ever™️

Football fans are great at being hypocritical if nothing else. Go and read their player threads if you disagree people.

Are these players all world class - or were they for a short while??? Out performing their actual ability.
Did Poch and his team just work with what they had and produce a bit of magic like the song says?

Sanchez
Dier
Trippier
Davies
Winks
Alli
 
Klopp relaxed his mental press. Pep too. Theres a different reason city are where they are in my opinion

No they did not

Klopp didn't change a thing when players like Lovren and Karius were hung out to dry and didn't change when his Liverpool team were clearly burnt out a few years back.

Pep hasn't altered a thing throughout his career and notably this season hence why City are struggling this season
 
I'm sorry but this is a completely bollocks take.

The ONLY reason Ange is still in a job is because he has the dressing room.

Conte was in 4th when he lost the dressing room.

This isn't an argument to keep Ange - it's just to point out what a horrendous take you've just given.

We are well on the stage of let's make up any bullshit and blame the manager, Fekin hilarious to read tbh
 
No they did not

Klopp didn't change a thing when players like Lovren and Karius were hung out to dry and didn't change when his Liverpool team were clearly burnt out a few years back.

Pepe hasn't altered a thing throughout his career and notably this season hence why City are struggling this season

Of course Pep has altered things. He plays with a lamp post up front now, he plays with 4 huge CBs across his defence, he has played with CBs in midfield, he’s played with full backs coming inside, he’s played with a full back shuffling across into a back 3 in possession, he’s played with a false 9, he’s done many different things at City.

His basic principles of football haven't changed but he’s tried lots of different things while staying within those principles. Ange by contrast has only ever really adapted due to injuries.
 
Of course Pep has altered things. He plays with a lamp post up front now, he plays with 4 huge CBs across his defence, he has played with CBs in midfield, he’s played with full backs coming inside, he’s played with a full back shuffling across into a back 3 in possession, he’s played with a false 9, he’s done many different things at City.

His basic principles of football haven't changed but he’s tried lots of different things while staying within those principles. Ange by contrast has only ever adapted due to injuries.

This is the point, we are talking about football principles - the OP compared Ange to Amorim saying they are system managers and won't budge from their idealogies...Pep and Klopp are of the same ilk...they may do some minor tweaks here and there but philosophy stays the same.
 
It's because they are utterly fucking clueless. The majority of football fans, are completely clueless. They won't realise it until it's too late, and we've lost another half dozen games, maybe even finish the season 15th. Yet they still will find excuses for Ange, say back him in the summer, give him next season.

If people cannot see the many many reasons why Ange should be sacked, and that another manager could do far better with this current squad, then they never will think he should be sacked. For them, it's injuries, lack of backing, always anyone but the manager etc

It's pointless debating with them on twitter, they are all just dumb as fk.

It's the chairman who makes the hiring and firing decisions, yeah the fans have their own opinions but we are completely powerless in these decisions. If the chairman is happy atm with Ange and hasn't sacked him then I will stay fully behind the manager and the team. We are going through hard times, i don't deny that,but maybe its times like these we have to show true support until the change is made. Unless there is a remarkable turnaround I think every fan knows that Ange hasn't got much of a chance remaining in charge beyond the end of the season so it's just a waiting game really until the chairman makes the change. Until then surely it's better to quit all this talk of " hope we lose to either Newcastle, Tamworth, or Liverpool, or Woolwich, so that Ange is immediately sacked" and support the team no matter if we win lose or draw.
 
It's the chairman who makes the hiring and firing decisions, yeah the fans have their own opinions but we are completely powerless in these decisions. If the chairman is happy atm with Ange and hasn't sacked him then I will stay fully behind the manager and the team. We are going through hard times, i don't deny that,but maybe its times like these we have to show true support until the change is made. Unless there is a remarkable turnaround I think every fan knows that Ange hasn't got much of a chance remaining in charge beyond the end of the season so it's just a waiting game really until the chairman makes the change. Until then surely it's better to quit all this talk of " hope we lose to either Newcastle, Tamworth, or Liverpool, or Woolwich, so that Ange is immediately sacked" and support the team no matter if we win lose or draw.
it's your football club. the chairman of any club listens to the fans especially now through social media etc. It's what got it into this mess post Poch. if you are content with what you are watching now, then it won't change.
 
He needs a miracle in next few.
This chump will walk on water and turn water in to wine before he turns anything on the pitch around.
So his average is only 0.25 off St Poch of Mumbo Jumbo ? despite Poch having for a period the 2nd/3rd best team in a much weaker league and Ange having a pretty ropey early rebuild mess in a much stronger league?

Impressive
Or, alternatively, his average PPG is the worst of any of those managers.
Many who whom people wanted out far more than this idiot.
His PPG is also still being skewed excessively by those first 10 games.
I'm sure almost everyone now can see they were massive outlier results now.
 
Sources close to Isak have come out and said he could stay at Toon if get Champs League spot…
This is the exact thing that Ange does not get with players and what really turns the top players on .
Yes by all means we all want to win the league thats a given but to attract and keep the best players we got to be at the very least a top 4 team year in and out with a stable manager.
We already know his stubborn not naive views on not happy on Champs League spot if his “Brand” of football does not secure it.

Even with the January window and players back its real hard to see short term and long term with Ange at helm any half decent players jumping on board .
More than likely if they get champions league they can increase his wages due to FFP , don’t get me wrong players want to play in the CL but it’s always about money !
 
We only did well in those first ten games under Ange because his tactics surprised teams. As soon as teams wised up, our results got worse and it’s continued in the same vein because he just won’t change and we’ve been playing the same way since. When the injured players come back nothing will change and it will be the same. It’s why I struggle to take those defending him seriously, a lack of acknowledgment that that’s just who we are mate.

I may be wrong but I’m not even convinced it was his tactics surprising teams. I just feel there was quite a bit of luck in there such as the Liverpool win and just simply the new manager bounce. Players making more of an effort to impress, which never lasts obviously. Agree with you the people defending him can’t be taken seriously.
 
This chump will walk on water and turn water in to wine before he turns anything on the pitch around.

Or, alternatively, his average PPG is the worst of any of those managers.
Many who whom people wanted out far more than this idiot.
His PPG is also still being skewed excessively by those first 10 games.
I'm sure almost everyone now can see they were massive outlier results now.
PPG since the first 10 last season 1.36, gets you 51 pts over a season.

PPG this season 1.26. Gets you 48 pts over a season.

Its been consistantly shite for 47 league games now and its getting worse. Dread to think what it will be in 2 or 3 weeks but likely relegation fight figures.
 
PPG since the first 10 last season 1.36, gets you 51 pts over a season.

PPG this season 1.26. Gets you 48 pts over a season.

Its been consistantly shite for 47 league games now and its getting worse. Dread to think what it will be in 2 or 3 weeks but likely relegation fight figures.
The league season will peter out into a bunch of 'meh' I reckon. No relegation fight but if we finish top half it will be barely so, like 9th or 10th. Worlds away from six or seven years ago!
 
PPG since the first 10 last season 1.36, gets you 51 pts over a season.

PPG this season 1.26. Gets you 48 pts over a season.

Its been consistantly shite for 47 league games now and its getting worse. Dread to think what it will be in 2 or 3 weeks but likely relegation fight figures.
Amorim says United are in a relegation fight.
They're 2 points behind us and he is their replacement.
 
The best one was the complaints about him going for a hug with Arne Slot, nearly wet myself reading that one.

This thread legit reminds me of the Mourinho thread on SC back in 2021, the amount of rent free-ness that man was living in people's heads at the time was hilarious, literally every comment questions his press conferences, tactics, comments, manarisms etc...ah that was a funny time, this these is actually uncanny
 
Ah yes the majority of football fans are clueless and the residents of TFC in the Ange thread are the football braniacs, of course. 😆

Yes mate. I could see back in October 2023 the red flags. I would have sacked him in the summer and appointed someone else because I could see us getting worse and worse. But of course this makes me a clueless TFC football brainiac and the rest of the fan base who are backing Ange are geniuses are they? Jesus Christ. Maybe the owns are are Ange out are the ones who actually have a clue.

Remember in all walks of life the ones with a clue are always in the minority.
 
Back
Top