Football Leaks

  • The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports


The Portuguese computer hacker whose release of a huge cache of documents led directly to Manchester City being charged with 115 rule breaches by the Premier League has received a suspended prison sentence by a court in Lisbon.

City have always denied any wrongdoing and say they have “irrefutable evidence” that will clear them.

Other revelations included that Chelsea paid the families of youth players, which is believed to form part of another Premier League investigation. The leaks also led to publication of apparent ethnic profiling of players by an employee of Paris Saint-Germain, information about the transfer fees and salaries of stars such as Lionel Messi and Neymar, and an accusation of rape against Cristiano Ronaldo, which he has always denied.

During his trial Pinto admitted he was behind the information but argued that he was a whistleblower, not a criminal, and had acted in the public interest for no personal gain.

His lawyers told the court that Pinto has helped authorities in Europe and beyond to tackle crime in the sport, especially murky financial dealings. Pinto was co-operating with authorities in France, Belgium, Switzerland and Malta in their football investigations, the lawyers said.

Pinto told the judges he was “shocked and disgusted” by what he found in his hacking activities.

There is a second case against Pinto, which is yet to go to court, in which Portuguese prosecutors are accusing him of 377 other hacking-related crimes, but that case could take several years to be resolved under the slow-moving Portuguese legal system.

The nine offences do, however, include some of the most serious accusations, including one count of attempted extortion. He was also found guilty of five counts of unauthorised entry into computer systems and three counts of intercepting emails.

The court convicted Pinto of hacking computers belonging to the Doyen Sports investment fund, the Portuguese attorney-general’s office and a Lisbon law firm.

“The freedom to inform does not justify violations of privacy,” the presiding judge, Margarida Alves, told the court where Pinto, who had been released from house arrest while awaiting trial, appeared wearing a surgical mask.

“The court has no doubt . . . It has clearly been established that he was hoping to get money,” Alves said.

Prosecutors alleged that Pinto sought between €500,000 to €1 million from the head of Doyen Sports, Nelio Lucas, to stop publishing compromising documents.
 
Whistleblowing sounds fine and public spirited

But 'The court convicted Pinto of hacking computers belonging to the Doyen Sports investment fund, the Portuguese attorney-general’s office and a Lisbon law firm.' suggests otherwise and '.Prosecutors alleged that Pinto sought between €500,000 to €1 million from the head of Doyen Sports, Nelio Lucas, to stop publishing compromising documents'. suggests it wasn't whistleblowing at all which was his main aim.


So without a lot more information, its really unclear what to think.
 
Whistleblowing sounds fine and public spirited

But 'The court convicted Pinto of hacking computers belonging to the Doyen Sports investment fund, the Portuguese attorney-general’s office and a Lisbon law firm.' suggests otherwise and '.Prosecutors alleged that Pinto sought between €500,000 to €1 million from the head of Doyen Sports, Nelio Lucas, to stop publishing compromising documents'. suggests it wasn't whistleblowing at all which was his main aim.


So without a lot more information, its really unclear what to think.
Whatever his own motives, it does encapsulate Whistleblowing (Public Interest Disclosure).

Hope he doesn’t get Jail time, but, it does appear this was about money, perhaps initially, then hopefully his conscience took over.

The trouble with these dynamics is, what if Man City, Chelsea et al. are forced to change, authorities forced to clamp down upon them, it is vital that excessive punishment is not placed upon an individual for “Whistleblowing” (in my non-legal mind = all charges should be downgraded in severity if Whistleblowing is found the main activity).

More than a little bit Julian Assange / Edward Snowden = blurred lines where ethics filter into Law.
 
Back
Top Bottom