Or...
...you can start accepting that how people watch football games is subjective.
Some will think player X had a good game while others will think he didn't.
Some will appreciate the contribution of player y more than someone else will.
Some lean towards attacking players being more influential than defenders so score accordingly.
Your issue is, and has always been, that everyone should watch and score the game how you see it which is obviously bollocks.
I genuinely think these ratings threads add value to this site and, to be fair, the analysis you post shows that the forum collectively scores pretty well.
It's just a shame every single one has to be spoilt by your nonsense.