• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Management Poll: Who do you want most as our next manager?

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Who would be your first choice?

  • Graham Potter

  • Scott Parker

  • Ten Hag

  • Rafa Benitez

  • None of the above - comment below

  • *Marcelo Bielsa

  • *Ralf Rangnick

  • *Ralph Hasenhüttl

  • *Steven Gerrard

  • *Julen Lopetegui

  • *Christophe Galtier

  • *Marcelo Gallardo

  • *Oliver Glasner

  • *Ryan Mason

  • *Maurizio Sarri

  • *Gian Piero Gasperini

  • *Mauricio Pochettino

  • *Antonio Conte

  • *Eddie Howe

  • *Gareth Southgate

  • *Nuno Espirito Santo

  • *Paulo Fonseca

  • *Gennaro Gattuso

  • *Ernesto Valverde


Results are only viewable after voting.
I think when it came to Jesus and Aguero he likely did the same thing left it mainly up to the scouting staff and they were starting strikers as well.

Kane and Haaland are top 5 transfer in the world which is why he would be more involved. You make those deals maybe once every 5 years, even a club like City.
Oh come on.

This is Pep " Thiago oder nichts " Guardiola. "Thiago or No One".

The world's top coaches, in all sports, are fucking stubborn about who they want.
 
Oh come on.

This is Pep " Thiago oder nichts " Guardiola. "Thiago or No One".

The world's top coaches, in all sports, are fucking stubborn about who they want.

I think in some cases they can be yes, I also think that Thiago is also an outlier with his history with Pep.

My point is that with Pep his trusts the guys they have, likely because he brought them in when he came, to do the vast majority of work when it comes to transfers.
 
Oh come on.

This is Pep " Thiago oder nichts " Guardiola. "Thiago or No One".

The world's top coaches, in all sports, are fucking stubborn about who they want.
Pep and Bayern wasn't a great marriage.

Because that is definitely a club where you are there to coach the team the board gives you. But they seized the opportunity to grab Pep and try to allow their setup to learn from him. It went okay, but for nine million reasons that's not an example for us to draw much from.
 
Pep doesn't say who he wants. He says WHAT he wants.

For example, Ruben Dias, signing of the summer, right? Pep wasn't spending his very scarce time scouting CB's all over the continent. In working with his technical staff it was clear a CB was needed, Txiki Begiristain and his staff identified Dias as someone with the qualities necessary to thrive in the kind of football the whole operation has been built around playing, and Begiristain went out and made the deal.

Pep is a figure of such stature at City that if he wanted to kill the deal, I dunno, he probably could have (maybe not, who knows). But why would he? He is in full alignment with City's technical staff who he worked with at Barcelona and who brought him to the club, and there is total trust in both directions.

Maybe it is Pep that wants Kane, but if the cost in money and/or players doesn't fit with City's project, it's not going to happen. It would only get to that point if there was alignment between all the relevant parties anyway, and a deal of that magnitude obviously bears a higher degree of scrutiny.

A manager going to the board and saying "get me player X and player Y" is dinosaur age stuff.
According to Mark Lawrenson that's exactly how it works at Liverpool.

Klopp say what he wants, let's say for example, an attacking RB.
Scouts identify a list of 5 possibles.
Klopp then says yes or no to the list and specifies his preference
Board then try to get choice number 1
If they fail they then try choice 2 etc. until they get an attacking RB.
 
I don't think any of those guys were ready to step into the PL when they were bought the development time was at the Championship, not time to develop into Championship level. I think it is easier to get players at that level then get guys who can play in the PL and develop into better players.

I think they have a good plan and agree if they go down they aren't likely to be screwed, I just thin k they may be a club that is great in the Championship, but struggles to translate it to the PL.
It's possible, we shall see. I think that they will likely be a yo-yo club, just because they are still bloody small, even with Premier League money to plug the gaps, but if they stay up and get a second year, they'll be in an amazing position regardless.
 
I think Conte was using us as bait to try and get either the PSG or Real Madrid jobs. To be honest I never wanted Conte it felt like we will be here again in two years at least and that is what we just had in Mourinho. Conte may be a better coach but it would still be a short term appointment.
Yeah, he talked with us for a long time about taking a massive well paid job because he wanted a different one.

Makes sense.
 
According to Mark Lawrenson that's exactly how it works at Liverpool.

Klopp say what he wants, let's say for example, an attacking RB.
Scouts identify a list of 5 possibles.
Klopp then says yes or no to the list and specifies his preference
Board then try to get choice number 1
If they fail they then try choice 2 etc. until they get an attacking RB.
Surely this is exactly how it happens in most, if not all clubs?

It’s just that some clubs pay less wages, spend less money so end up with 8th choice or whatever.

Like us
 
This is false. Txiki was brought in with Ferran Soriano in 2012 to build a Barcelona-like operation at City, and his first managerial hire was Manuel Pellegrini.

Of course it was always obvious that City would love for Pep to coach them and had the resources to make it work, but that was a settled and already title-winning technical department that went out at hired Pep to take charge of the team several years later.


And if the deals can't be done, they'll figure it out, someone else will be acceptable.

For the caliber of player they sign and the amount of money they spend, there has been remarkably little protracted transfer drama at that club. Which serves as proof that Pep is not actually charging in with "this specific galactico or nothing" type demands. That's not really his personality anyway.
Yes, I'm fully aware Txiki hired Pellegrini first, because Guardiola had a job. And, as you say, a key objective was to build a Barca-style operation at Shitty.

But the medium term aim was always to hire Pep as soon as he became available.

I agree that Bayern was a bad fit for Guardiola. It was always going to blow up. And Shitty had spent the time creating a Home from Home for Pep, knowing that he would be very comfortable with Txiki as DoF.

But my core point is that the top coaches always insist on getting the players they want, and they often indirectly hire the GM/DoF (eg Belichick or Kyle Shanahan with John Lynch), to ensure this happens. Or make sure they have confidence the DoF will get the players they want (eg Pep & Txiki).
 


What an absolute F**CUNT. The dude literally has put forward half dozen names, nailed on to Poch etc, and then has the gall to call others out.

JPB even said he didn’t know who the next Spurs manager would be on the athletic Tottenham podcast.

I’ve been a long time lurker and occasional poster on SC and it used to be amusing, interesting posters etc but now… These guys really love the smell of their own farts.
 
Telling ya, use your membership to dive bomb shitty comments calling them out.

I say dive bomb as you'll be banned quicker then a flasher in public places but it'll be worth it.
 
qZhHq6U.jpg
 
But my core point is that the top coaches always insist on getting the players they want, and they often indirectly hire the GM/DoF (eg Belichick or Kyle Shanahan with John Lynch), to ensure this happens. Or make sure they have confidence the DoF will get the players they want (eg Pep & Txiki).
Mutual confidence between the manager and the DoF is the critical thing. And the backing of the club both in terms of patience and resources to get a well defined job done.

Spurs have never been anywhere close to something like that.
 
Back
Top