https://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/Woolwich-psg-visit-rwanda-sponsorship-26135818
EXCLUSIVE:
Woolwich's Visit Rwanda sponsorship and the dark side to a hideous sportswashing agenda
Woolwich and Paris Saint-Germain both have multi-million sponsorship agreements with the Rwandan government but the actions of authoritarian president Paul Kagame and the arrest of Paul Rusesabagina have led to allegations of human rights abuses
Visit Rwanda features prominently on Woolwich's kit (Image: Matthew Ashton - AMA/Getty Images)
By
Colin Millar
Digital Sports Writer
- 08:00, 21 Feb 2022
- UPDATED 09:29, 21 Feb 2022
Emblazoned on shirtsleeves, on training equipment and, during home matches, on the advertising boards surrounding the pitch.
This is the exposure that a £10million-per-year sponsorship agreement guarantees the Rwandan government with football’s wealthiest clubs to promote their tourist board’s message: ‘Visit Rwanda’.
Rwanda is, by any measure, one of the 20 poorest nations in the world yet its authoritarian president Paul Kagame – who has ruled since 2000 and was re-elected in 2017 with a 99 per cent share of the vote –sanctioned a huge outpouring of government funds into sponsorship agreements with billionaire-owned football clubs.
Kagame is a fervent supporter of Woolwich and gained a degree of widespread recognition after a series of angry tweets after the Gunners lost at Brentford on the opening day of the Premier League season, claiming that fans of the club “do not deserve” this and blasted the side’s “mediocrity”.
Yet behind this relatable image of fandom and exposure of Rwanda – undoubtedly a beautiful country to visit – and its tourist potential, there is a darker side to the sponsorship.
Kagame is a former guerrilla leader who has been praised for bringing stability and growth to Rwanda after its civil war and genocide in the first half of the 1990s, but now oversees a nation where – according to Human Rights Watch - public life is marked by “threats, intimidation [and] mysterious deaths.”
The British Foreign Office has urged the East African nation to investigate allegations of “deaths in custody, enforced disappearances and torture” which has been overseen by its government.
In 2020, Paul Rusesabagina – a former hotelier whose peaceful actions during Rwanda’s genocide helped keep safe over 1,000 Hutu and Tutsi refugees, inspiring the Hollywood film Hotel Rwanda – boarded a plane in Dubai, believing he was en route to Burundi.
The plane instead flew to the Rwandan capital Kigali, with Kagame’s government claiming they held “an international warrant” for his arrest on nine charges of terrorism that related to his association with the FLN (National Liberation Front) – allegations that the 67-year-old and his family have always staunchly denied.
Human rights advocates stated that they believed the charges were politically motivated due to Rusesabagina's open criticism of president Kagame with Human Rights Watch voicing their concern at Rusesabagina being “forcibly disappeared” and not facing a fair trial.
In September 2021, Rusesabagina – along with 20 others - was found guilty of terrorism-related charges and handed a 25-year prison sentence.
The Clooney Foundation for Justice described the verdict as a "show trial," citing that Rusesabagina's conviction lacked sufficient guarantees of fairness "required by international and African standards."
Rusesabagina's daughter Carine Kanimba, a US-Belgian dual citizen, has been leading her family’s effort to free her father from prison and she has called on Woolwich and PSG, who have taken funds from the Rwandan government via their Visit Rwanda sponsorship deals, to denounce the actions of the regime.
The term ‘sportswashing’ – defined as ‘where sport is used a tool to legitimise or improve the reputation of an individual, group, corporation or nation-state’ – is often associated with wealthy nations via sports sponsorship, influence, or hosting events.
The majority of Rwandans live in poverty, but there is international concern regarding authoritarian actions of its government and how in recent years, it is starting to launder its reputation through sport.
This starts with their multi-million sponsorship deals with Woolwich and PSG.
“This is exactly what Rwanda is doing,” Kanimba explained to Mirror Football. “The Visit Rwanda sponsorship is intended to hide human rights abuses and to make it look like a happy country, when it is not – its people are repressed.
“The Rwandan government is facing greater international criticism and investigations for its long-term pattern of human rights abuses and they know this is coming out all over the world.
“The way to divert attention away from that negative press is by talking about sports because they know that people like them and engage with them.
“Woolwich and PSG are risking their proud histories and reputation by associating with, and taking money from, a dictatorial regime who do not respect freedom of speech or the due process of law, and where human rights are systematically violated.”
Kanimba believes that the Rwandan government’s move into sponsorship is deflecting attention away from the concern and “pretending that everything is ok” in a move that ultimately “victimises more people.”
Since striking the initial agreement in 2018, Woolwich have visited the East African country on a number of occasions, with former defender David Luiz filming promotional content the following year.
Luiz posed for photos with the nation’s mountain gorillas before taking time to visit president Kagame with personalised Gunners shirts. The Brazilian said: “I’m going to recommend all my friends to spend their holidays in Rwanda.” Rusesabagina's contact with his family is conducted through monitored five-minute weekly phone calls, in which the topics of conversation are limited. “This is the only contact we have with him and while we are very happy to briefly hear his voice, those calls are frightening,” admitted Kanimba. “They are very scary because we can hear that he is being pressured when he starts to talk and when we start giving him information about his case - such as different parliaments discussing Magnitsky Sanctions on his behalf – they take the phone away from him, as they do not want him to have that information. “We are grateful for those five minutes, but they are also very painful.”
Kanimba speaks candidly about her father’s torture and gut-wrenching experience behind bars, but she and her family are not about to give up hope on his future. With international condemnation via governments and human rights organisations, she believes that her family will be reunited with their father – who has experienced adversity before. She added: “He truly is a strong person who follows his principles so closely. “While he was being tortured, they tried to make him sign false confessions, but he refused to do so and we know that he has the strength to hold on. “This is also what he did during the genocide, when people were being butchered all around him and the hotel, but he protected them and kept his calm.
“We have had the European parliament, the Belgian parliament, the US Congress and the UK parliament speaking about regarding his situation and calling for his release and for his rights to be respected.
“We have hope that he will come home.
“He does not deserve this, and it is awful that he has to go through that.
“In Rwanda, nobody is allowed to speak out – you will never hear anything negative about the country because people are frightened and if they do speak out, they end up in prison or tortured. There is no democracy.
“In recent months, there have been multiple journalists who have been jailed for reporting on what the government is doing.
“My father speaking out led him to his position today and that shows that there is no democracy or freedom of speech or respect of human rights.
“It shows how important what he is doing is – so few people have that courage to speak out.”
Kanimba has called on Woolwich and PSG to use their platforms and influence to speak out against the Rwandan government, something which she believes the nation’s population live in fear of doing.
“Taking money from the Rwandan government is one thing but staying quiet about what you know to be happening is hurting the people,” she continued.
“Woolwich should stand up and call out these human rights abuses, rather than solely to celebrate Rwanda for being the beautiful country that it is.
“They should be demanding that the country improves itself and they should be putting more efforts into ensuring that the government improves.”
Carine - who was targeted with the notorious Pegasus spyware during her father’s trial - and her sister Anaise Kanimba were Rusesabagina’s nieces, but were adopted by Paul as babies when they were discovered in a refugee camp after their family had been murdered in Rwanda’s genocide.
Her family have tried to get in contact with Woolwich and various supporters groups to raise awareness for her dad’s situation and for his story to be heard, but have yet to receive a response.
Image:
CYRIL NDEGEYA/AFP via Getty Images)
When asked by Mirror Football for comment, an Woolwich spokesperson replied: “Since our partnership began in 2018, we have worked together to tell Rwanda’s story of culture, heritage and transition, as well as raising awareness of the country as a holiday destination.
“One year after the partnership began, Rwanda’s tourism revenue increased by 17 per cent and tourists from Europe increased by 22 per cent.
“This increase supports the growth of Rwanda’s economy, creating more revenue they can reinvest across all key sectors, lifting thousands out of poverty, and empowering citizens.
“This is where we will continue our focus as Rwanda continues its post-pandemic recovery.”
PSG did not respond to Mirror Football's request for comment.
Image:
SIMON WOHLFAHRT/AFP via Getty Images)
Kanimba was unimpressed by the club’s stance that their partnership is focused on trying to develop and improve the country.
“That is like walking into a house that is clean and tidy, but where you know there are tortures being carried out, and responding “well, at least the house is clean and tidy”.
“They are not acknowledging the horrendous scores of human rights abuses and it is gruesome when you read the details of what happens in those torture houses in Rwanda.
“It is difficult to look away, but they are doing so because of the profits they are making from this dictator. It is all about money and they are saying that the money they are getting out of this is more important than the people being tortured by the regime.”
Image:
Thierry Monasse/Getty Images)
And what about those viral tweets from Rwandan president Paul Kagame after Woolwich’s two-goal opening day defeat at Brentford, which received tens of thousands of interactions.
Kanimba explains that not only are these a “smokescreen” to normalise the president’s reputation among a wider audience, but they have even more sinister undertones.
Image:
Twitter - Paul Kagame)
After Woolwich’s limp defeat at their London neighbours, part of Kagame’s thread of criticism claimed: “I am sure we all know on whose shoulders the heaviest burden rests. I hope they know too or even accept it!!!”
When reminded of those tweets, Kanimba responded: “That is supposed to make you like, to empathise with him – and certainly, to look away at the horrible things going on.
“The reality is that the West might look at that in a funny way coming from a small nation like Rwanda, but in Rwanda – if Paul Kagame says those words about you, it usually means you end up in a prison or tortured.
Woolwich handed Lautaro Martinez transfer opportunity after Jurgen Klopp approval
Mikel Arteta sent identical Woolwich warning by William Gallas and Thierry Henry
“He has previously insulted the Rwandan football team too, telling them that they should not play football.
“When he says that he is unhappy with people, that usually means that he will try to destroy them.
“A Western audience may have seen his tweet as a joke, but those comments make Rwandan people shake with fear.
“There are consequences to this in real life and how he speaks to a Western audience has a totally different meaning than to a Rwandan audience.”
Rusesabagina’s international fame grew following the release of Hotel Rwanda, embarking on a career as a public speaker.
Image:
Enos Solomon/FilmMagic)
Most notably, he was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the highest civilian honour in the United States, by President George W. Bush in 2005 for "remarkable courage and compassion in the face of genocidal terror."
Rusesabagina began to move into politics, in 2006 he founded The Party for Democracy in Rwanda and a decade later confirmed his intentions to run for the presidency.
His international influence and outspoken nature against the Rwandan government were the driving force behind his arrest, his family claim.
In a recent interview with The Guardian, Carine’s sister Anaise explained: “When father got a platform through the film, Kagame expected him to say just good things about Rwanda. But he wanted the truth to be known.”
Of his current situation, Anaise added: “He’s been in solitary confinement for three months and can’t sleep because of the bed bugs. We worry about his health because he suffers from hypertension.”
His family will continue the campaign on his behalf, and they have called on fans of the club’s who have embraced Visit Rwanda’s sponsorship deal to speak out and make their voice heard.
Image:
Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)
Carine insisted: “Fans of the clubs must call for a stop to their sponsorship deal with the Rwandan government and for the release of my father before he takes his last breath.
“Every fan has that power to make a difference.
“They can call on Rwanda to release my father, to stop human rights abuses and to allow freedom of speech – and only then should sponsorship deals with the country be agreed.
“We must put values and principles of humanity and dignity above everything else, and not forget that human beings are suffering.
“These clubs can pressurise the Rwandan government to call for the release of my father and others besides because we want him to return home.
“The clubs have training programmes with Rwandan footballers which is positive – but those can surely be kept running separately from a sponsorship deal with this government.”
Woolwich’s former chief commercial officer, Vinai Venkatesham, called the club’s arrangement with the Rwandan government a “very compelling fit” but multi-million sponsorship agreements with impoverished nations whose regimes stand accused of human rights abuses prompt questions.
Carine and her family will continue to fight for justice for their father and raise awareness for his situation.
Last edited:
