Frankly, we are in a mess.
If I were rebuilding the squad, unfortunately, I’d say we have to start from the back. We need a new goalkeeper; one that will command the area. I’d clear out Forster, Whiteman and Austin. I’d also, sell Vicario and get a replacement. Kinsky can remain #2 and we can promote a youth goalkeeper. 5 goalkeepers are too many and you get whatever you can for the leavers and save on their wages (Levy’s ears are pricking up as we speak).
Then, we have to look at the defence. Reguilon has to go. Udogie and Porro need to be replaced by proper fullbacks. Ben Davies; I don’t dislike him, but, pick a single position for him or move him on. Retain Spence, but keep him in one position (and make sure it is his optimal position).
Sell Romero for as much as you can and put Danso in. Bring this guy Vuskovic into the squad and Phillips. That, alongside Van der Ven is 1 at 6’3 and 3 at 6’4 at the back. Dragusin is back in December (I think). He is another 6’3 player. Set this as your baseline and get a proper set piece coach in and, if needs be a defensive coach. Rigorously assess each player based on performance.
Go from there and assess based on what they do with 2 proper fullbacks and a powerful, commanding goalkeeper that communicates. I don’t care if he looks like Oliver Kahn or Peter Schmeichel when doing it. We need a goalkeeper who acts like a second captain and centre halves that can protect the back.
In midfield, both Bissouma and Bentancur need to be moved on. They aren’t giving us what we need. Werner needs to be removed from the wage bill (kerching, Daniel)…
Assuming the back gets fixed, then front needs work (but later as we cannot change the whole team in one window).
Tbh, I’m sure I’ll get disagrees, but our goalkeeper, defensive and the other players mentioned are currently just not serious.