• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Ex-Spurs Player Emerson Royal

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

So TAA and Robertson not even good enough to make that list?
Bogus stats again.

Stats are accurate, they've left out TAA because he's way ahead of the rest and Robertson's is at 21%. It's just a meaningless stat because a cross is 'successful' even if its a harmless floaty ball. Robertson's success rate may be lower, but you can fucking guarantee he's played far more actually dangerous balls in than Emerson.
 
IMO, the fullbacks' responsibilities (in order of importance) in Klopp's system are:

1. Offensive. Direct play, providing width and additional numbers in attack. Involved in set plays on their strong foot side.

2. Transitional. High-press/intense defensive pressure in the attacking + middle third when losing possession.

3. Defensive. Recovery/dropping back into the back-4 defensive posture. Typically, 1 or 2 of the CMs (Wijnaldum, Fabinho, Henderson, Milner) will sit deep to cover for the fullbacks, and the 2 CBs will split wide. Klopp likes mobile, defensively solid CMs... the more attacking minded box-to-box types struggle in his system (Keita, Oxlade-Chamberlain).

We may be arguing about semantics here. I just don't think that what TAA + Robertson and what City's fullbacks are doing is "crossing" in the classic English sense. I mean, Pep has smashed transfer-records and gone through about 10 world-class fullbacks (of all varieties) trying to find one that works in his system. Often settling for Zinchenko (LMFAO).

As for quality "crossers" that I'd like to see at Spurs, I'm a huge fan of James Ward-Prowse (criminally under-rated) and Dwight McNeil (we should be all over him if Burnley get relegated).
This is 100% and it is not in the least a semantic distinction
 
TAA is like De Bruyne, he just happens to defend the right-back position when Liverpool don't have the ball. Pretty sure he is amongst the most creative players in the league. I think he's great to watch too, great footballer.
He is not at all a fullback in any meaningful sense of the word. He is a brilliant Beckham like midfield player nominally standing at right fullback. The moment any side with a bit of bravery and a player with pace target him he shits the bed. If he wants any kind if international career he will have move inside.
 
Deuterz Deuterz I owe you an apology for losing my shit with your perceived sarky TAA Robertson comment. It probably sounds way more chippy than it was intended. I enjoy your contributions. I think I've lost total patience with the cretins and you Kopped it. The kind make snidey halfwitted stuff like @Virginia gets. They kill the fourum for the rest of us. 👍
 
He is not at all a fullback in any meaningful sense of the word. He is a brilliant Beckham like midfield player nominally standing at right fullback. The moment any side with a bit of bravery and a player with pace target him he shits the bed. If he wants any kind if international career he will have move inside.
I definitely think England should find a way to get him on the pitch.
 
Not sure where all the hate is coming from. While Emerson hasn’t set the world alight, he’s coming from a league which doesn’t have the same standard of defending as the EPL, he’s had to learn from two different managers and systems and he’s only been here for a half a season. I understand that Contes systems needs two high flying wingbacks but I think a full evaluation on RWB can be done at the end of the season and if someone new needs to come in, so be it but I think the criticism at this point is a little unfair IMO
 
Comparing anyone to TAA is pointless. He's the best playmaker to ever play fullback and he's only 23. There's never been a player like him before and there isn't a player in his league as a playmaker currently.
 
I definitely think England should find a way to get him on the pitch.
It's tricky he needs to move and learn the discipline of playing in a two or three. If klopp leaves him where he is it will actually begin to harm him. Play him where he is against a France or Italy and he will get badly exposed. Both James and Walker are better fullbacks Southgate sees it. But you could play him wide right in a three with Rice and Philips. Kane would clean up with that wand he has.
 
Deuterz Deuterz I owe you an apology for losing my shit with your perceived sarky TAA Robertson comment. It probably sounds way more chippy than it was intended. I enjoy your contributions. I think I've lost total patience with the cretins and you Kopped it. The kind make snidey halfwitted stuff like @Virginia gets. They kill the fourum for the rest of us. 👍

Absolutely no worries my man, like I said I know you're a really good poster so assumed you just took it in a way that wasn't intended. I know it can be hard on here with all the toxic shit that gets posted so no hard feelings at all.
 
Deuterz Deuterz I owe you an apology for losing my shit with your perceived sarky TAA Robertson comment. It probably sounds way more chippy than it was intended. I enjoy your contributions. I think I've lost total patience with the cretins and you Kopped it. The kind make snidey halfwitted stuff like @Virginia gets. They kill the fourum for the rest of us. 👍

Absolutely no worries my man, like I said I know you're a really good poster so assumed you just took it in a way that wasn't intended. I know it can be hard on here with all the toxic shit that gets posted so no hard feelings at all.

Just had to check Im on the right forum.
Some much needed civility. Kudos to both.
 
For an unproven player that also a fullback, it was madness. Hes still 22 and its his first season, so I guess he deserves some time to settle. For 30m though, its a panic buy , like Sissoko was.

Beeb says £25.8m should that help chill your ire a little....


Not sure why you'd say it was a panic buy though....... We were sniffing about RBs all summer with Tomiyasu on the burner (whom we oped to bin off in favour of ER*); obviously we had options and judgements were subsequently made.

(*The wisdom of which is another discussion. )
 
Beeb says £25.8m should that help chill your ire a little....


Not sure why you'd say it was a panic buy though....... We were sniffing about RBs all summer with Tomiyasu on the burner (whom we oped to bin off in favour of ER*); obviously we had options and judgements were subsequently made.

(*The wisdom of which is another discussion. )
We needed a RB and didnt buy one till the deadline day and ended up buying a mostly unproven player for a lot of money. Sounds a bit panicky.
 
Back
Top