Against Fulham Dier rated over 0.50 higher on the combined average and not far off a full point by forum posters. That's Dier the Donkey v World class Romero !!
-
The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...
Manager Antonio Conte
- Thread starter Fattynomates
- Start date
Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports
What has Japh got to do with any of this then......?
You began suggesting that a shift would see Japh prove to be the prevalent player.
(....And just in case you jump to such a conclusion; I'm not some entrenched Romero super-fan. I've openly critiqued him this season, but the broader narrative you began dabbling with is/was wacky to put it mildly.)
You've literally just described random.... It's a mish-mash of whatever you're able to cobble together from week to week. Even the notion of "neutral" and unbiased is highly dubious.
I'm not knocking it if that's how you want to spend your time; but you referencing it as some credible source of player performance data is folly..... It's a curiosity at best.
Last edited:
Like I said, I've thrown it out there, let's watch!!
That other guy tho:
Crystal Palace 3-0 Tottenham Hotspur: Eagles beat leaders Spurs for first win of league campaign
Odsonne Edouard scores twice on his debut as Crystal Palace claim their first win of the season to end 10-man Tottenham's 100% Premier League start.
www.bbc.co.uk
It can only become more credible with input from knowledgeable contributors like yourself. When there are glaring differences between ratings it asks questions....who's right and why ? Have the majority missed something ?
Questions that will never be answered by a compiled average; for that is all that this amounts to.
I'm trying awfully hard not to offend you, but you seem to have a misguidedly grandiose impression about your spreadsheet.
Last edited:
Not at all. Just trying to drum up opinion and discussion.
He was the first Argentina player back from the WC.
You obviously have an agenda, not worth continuing this debate.
Who’s ratings?
I promise I will be impartial. I rate what I see.
You can look back to see the forum poster ratings on the thread. The media Web ones are usually Evening Std, Times, Sky, Football London, Spurs Web, other newspapers when accessible via YouTubes Spurs in the Media report.
My earlier question appears to have passed you by......
How does Tanganga fair on your spreadhseet?
.........In the interests of discussion of course.
Japhet did not play enough games to feature in the mid season ratings review. But neither did Romero having played 10 games out of 22. I cut off at 11 . Romero averaged 6.20 across his 10 games which is down from 6.58 for last season.
In comparison Hojbjerg averaged 6.60 over 20 games which is commendable.
In comparison Hojbjerg averaged 6.60 over 20 games which is commendable.
I thought you said you had 3 years worth?
Curious because Japh made he EPL debut 3 years ago.
Deleted member 15314
Guest
Swear that's what this is all about... or some overly elaborate trolling.
Always liked the saying “we can never truly know the world around us, all we have is our interpretation of it”.
To see what’s truly there requires viewing without Ego, impossible for most of us, most of the time.
Comparing ones ratings to others and the reasons why at least gives some reassurance ones thinking is on the right track. Its when your ratings are way off others it asks questions.
Last moments before Antonio Conte’s first Serie A title. The hug with Stellini was nice to see
