Normally I would agree. But when they sung it for Harry at the Newcastle game last season, it felt as if there was a unity among fans that is rarely seen (don't ask me why). The good atmosphere seemed to help us that night. So, from that point of view, I have no problem with it if makes fans unified and gives the player a confidence boost in a match.singing we want you to stay in any shape or form is cringeworthy imvho
At least nobody sings "we want you to leave"!