Player Ratings: Newcastle (h) 4-1

[mummy]

I included your ratings in the forum select 10 because I considered them to be fair and balanced. Can you rate those 2 please in case I need to change the final average.
Of course admin should be doing this and would do I'm sure. !!

...which makes your 'forum ratings' 100% bogus and unreliable, making your presentations meaningless.

 

[Airfixx]

I'm not getting involved in this discussion again. I put up the comparisons for people to draw their own conclusions.

You doctor them to match your own opinions.

 

[Billy Bob mate]

Postecoglou: 10
Vicario: 10
Porro: 10
Romero: 10
Davies: 10
Udogie: 10
Skipp: 10
Højbjerg: 10
Sarr: 10
Bissouma: 10
Lo Celso: 10
Donley: 10
Son: 10
Richarlison: 10
Kulusevski: 10
Johnson: 10
Gil: 10



Submit your ratings | View match averages | View season averages

 

[Billy Bob mate]

The dealer rn

He's given me a consoling kiss. He's coping.

 

[Deuterz]

Postecoglou: 10
Vicario: 10
Porro: 10
Romero: 10
Davies: 10
Udogie: 10
Skipp: 10
Højbjerg: 10
Sarr: 10
Bissouma: 10
Lo Celso: 10
Donley: 10
Son: 10
Richarlison: 10
Kulusevski: 10
Johnson: 10
Gil: 10



Submit your ratings | View match averages | View season averages

The dealer rn

 

[mummy]

It doesn't matter whether I agree or not. The ratings just have to be sensible and seemingly unbiased. Which can't be said for a fair proportion. ie 10s for every player etc.

Can you grasp the fact that, by making a selection of ratings based on your value judgements, you're embedding your opinions into the result, creating a bias in the statistics and thereby invalidating any figures you come up with? Not that it matters anyway, because it doesn't.

 

[Kekerinho]

Postecoglou: 8.5
Vicario: 7.5
Porro: 9
Romero: 7
Davies: 8.5
Udogie: 7.5
Højbjerg: 6
Sarr: 8.5
Bissouma: 7.5
Lo Celso: 6
Son: 9
Richarlison: 8
Kulusevski: 7.5
Johnson: 7



Submit your ratings | View match averages | View season averages

 

[cretinousgoat]

Postecoglou: 9
Vicario: 8
Porro: 9
Romero: 7
Davies: 8
Udogie: 9
Skipp: 6
Højbjerg: 6
Sarr: 8
Bissouma: 7
Lo Celso: 6
Donley: 6
Son: 9
Richarlison: 9
Kulusevski: 8
Johnson: 8
Gil: 6



Submit your ratings | View match averages | View season averages

 

[The Dealer]

Why don't you just call her Posto?

Because its not part of her name.

 

[mummy]

Give them both a 7

Careful now - he might not agree with that.

 

[The Dealer]

Can you grasp the fact that, by making a selection of ratings based on your value judgements, you're embedding your opinions into the result, creating a bias in the statistics and thereby invalidating any figures you come up with? Not that it matters anyway, because it doesn't.

No because I'm just omitting the rubbish which admin does anyway.

 

[mummy]

No because I'm just omitting the rubbish which admin does anyway.

By using the word 'rubbish' you're confirming a bias. Bias and statistics are mutually incompatible. Your stats are therefore meaningless.

 

[mummy]

I don't select the media /Web ratings. They are what they are. By deselecting the stupid ratings , admin is doing the same as me, if not, the ratings are nonsense.

But who decides which ratings are 'stupid'? You do.

Did my ratings form part of your set?

 

[Admin]

Click here to submit your player ratings for the 4-1 win against Newcastle in the Premier League.

View the current season averages here.

 

[Smogz]

Postecoglou: 9
Vicario: 9
Porro: 9
Romero: 8.5
Davies: 8.5
Udogie: 8.5
Skipp: 6
Højbjerg: 2
Sarr: 8.5
Bissouma: 8.5
Lo Celso: 7
Donley: 5
Son: 9.5
Richarlison: 8.5
Kulusevski: 9
Johnson: 8
Gil: 6



Submit your ratings | View match averages | View season averages

 

[Deleted member 13260]

Postecoglou: 10
Vicario: 7.5
Porro: 8.5
Romero: 8
Davies: 9
Udogie: 9
Skipp: 6
Højbjerg: 6
Sarr: 9
Bissouma: 8.5
Lo Celso: 6
Donley: 6
Son: 9.5
Richarlison: 9.5
Kulusevski: 7.5
Johnson: 7.5
Gil: 6



Submit your ratings | View match averages | View season averages

 

[Starks]

Postecoglou: 9
Vicario: 7
Porro: 8.5
Romero: 7
Davies: 7
Udogie: 8
Skipp: 6
Højbjerg: 5
Sarr: 8.5
Bissouma: 7
Lo Celso: 6
Donley: 5
Son: 9.5
Richarlison: 8
Kulusevski: 7.5
Johnson: 7
Gil: 5



Submit your ratings | View match averages | View season averages

 

[zin]

Postecoglou: 8.5
Vicario: 6.5
Porro: 7
Romero: 7
Davies: 7
Udogie: 7
Højbjerg: 6
Sarr: 7
Bissouma: 6
Lo Celso: 6
Son: 8
Richarlison: 9
Kulusevski: 6
Johnson: 6



Submit your ratings | View match averages | View season averages

 

[Murphy]

Postecoglou: 8.5
Vicario: 8.5
Porro: 8.5
Romero: 8.5
Davies: 8
Udogie: 9
Sarr: 8
Bissouma: 7.5
Son: 9
Richarlison: 9
Kulusevski: 8.5
Johnson: 8



Submit your ratings | View match averages | View season averages

 

[mummy]

Postecoglou: 10
Vicario: 9
Porro: 10
Romero: 9
Davies: 9
Udogie: 10
Sarr: 8
Bissouma: 8
Son: 9
Richarlison: 9
Kulusevski: 10
Johnson: 10



Submit your ratings | View match averages | View season averages