Spurs Player Ratings 23/24

  • The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sort by date Sort by reaction score

The Dealer

No changes from last season. 0.50 increments encouraged for more accuracy if desired.
I will put up last seasons ratings shortly.
For clarification this ratings system is not for fun or an opportunity to vent.
 
Last seasons ratings which are low compared to other seasons apart from Kane.
These players started 25 games or more.

1. Kane ........6.63
2. Hojbjerg. 6.19
3. Kulusev....6.19
4. Davies......5.94
5. Lenglet.....5.89
6. Royal.........5.88
7. Romero.....5.87
8. Dier.............5.83
9. Lloris...........5.81
10. Perisic......5.74
11. Son............5.53

21/22 ratings

1. Dier...........6.65
2. Romero....6.58
3. Lloris.........6.45
4. Skip/ Son..6.37
5. Kane...........6.25
6. Hojbjerg....6.21
7. Sanchez.....6.18
8. Moura.........6.17
9. Royal...........6.08
10. Davies......5.91

20/21 ratings

1. Kane..........6.63
2. Hojbjerg...6.41
3. Tony............6.35
4. Lloris...........6.22
5. Ndombele 6.20
6. Son...............6.19
7. Dele.............6.18
8. Loco.............6.16
9. Dier..............6.10
10. Lamela......6.08
11. Aurier........5.86
12. Davies.......5.84




.
.
 
Media / web player ratings v Brentford average across 10 reports.
Vicario....5.45
Royal.......7.20
Romero...7.45...limited minutes
VDV..........6.55
Udogie.....7.15
Skipp.........5.65
Bissouma 8.35
Maddison 7.85
Kulusevs...5.75
Richi...........5.15
Son..............5.30
Sanchez... .6.35
 
My ratings v Brentford.

Vicario......6.5
Royal.........6.5
Romero.....NA
VDV...........6
Udogie......7
Skipp..........5.5
Bissouma. 8.5
Maddison 8.5
Kulusevs...6
Richi............5
Son...............5
Sanchez......6

Posto...........6.5
 
TonySoprano said:
What’s the difference between a 6 and a 6.5?

I mean, what gives you the extra 0.5?
Click to expand...

That's a good question. Looking at the final averages for a game and especially the seasons final averages might help. The difference between 6 and 6.5 is massive. No player has ever hit the magic 7 since I've been collating. A player consistently finishing with a 6 is under achieving whereas a 6.5 is very good. Kane hit 6.65 I think last season.
It might seem a small increment but a 0.50 margin is more significant especially over a long period.
I considered giving Vicario a 6 but thought he was maybe better, but not deserving of a 7. So I gave a 6.50 based on a reasonable performance considering his acclimatisation has only just started.
You could look at your ratings ( which I haven't) and ask.....was he a dead 6 or 7 or in between, or a 5 or 6 or in between and so on in relation to any player. If the answer is.....no my ratings are all dead on whole numbers....fair enough.
 
The Dealer said:
That's a good question. Looking at the final averages for a game and especially the seasons final averages might help. The difference between 6 and 6.5 is massive. No player has ever hit the magic 7 since I've been collating. A player consistently finishing with a 6 is under achieving whereas a 6.5 is very good. Kane hit 6.65 I think last season.
It might seem a small increment but a 0.50 margin is more significant especially over a long period.
I considered giving Vicario a 6 but thought he was maybe better, but not deserving of a 7. So I gave a 6.50 based on a reasonable performance considering his acclimatisation has only just started.
You could look at your ratings ( which I haven't) and ask.....was he a dead 6 or 7 or in between, or a 5 or 6 or in between and so on in relation to any player. If the answer is.....no my ratings are all dead on whole numbers....fair enough.
Click to expand...
But why can’t you just make 6.5 a 7?
 
I only need 10 posters ratings and I have selected 9 plus mine for this. They were selected randomly but excluding any obvious bias. Admin informed me he did this also if he has time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom