• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Transfers Summer 2017 transfer window or, waiting for Godot

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Status
Not open for further replies.
Interesting how much credence people give the "reports", yet Conte has said he tried to sign Walker and none of the papers picked up on it.
 
Serious question:
1) Does anyone think our current squad can make an impact on the champions league?

2) Does anyone think this squad could win a cup while resting a few key players for most the competition.

*it's a 'No' and 'No' from me

Cup runs are a matter of luck. Our current squad is better then the one of 2010/2011 when we got to the quarter finals.

We got to a final of a cup a few years back and the semi final of one yesterday. Once again, no idea why not.

When everyone's fit, our depth isn't bad at all. Lamela, Davies, Dier, Janssen, Vorm and perhaps a youngster would make up our bench. Get a signing in there like a Barkley, and it's even greater.
 
Cup runs are a matter of luck. Our current squad is better then the one of 2010/2011 when we got to the quarter finals.

We got to a final of a cup a few years back and the semi final of one yesterday. Once again, no idea why not.

When everyone's fit, our depth isn't bad at all. Lamela, Davies, Dier, Janssen, Vorm and perhaps a youngster would make up our bench. Get a signing in there like a Barkley, and it's even greater.
Barkley is the key I reckon!
 
Cup runs are a matter of luck. Our current squad is better then the one of 2010/2011 when we got to the quarter finals.

We got to a final of a cup a few years back and the semi final of one yesterday. Once again, no idea why not.

When everyone's fit, our depth isn't bad at all. Lamela, Davies, Dier, Janssen, Vorm and perhaps a youngster would make up our bench. Get a signing in there like a Barkley, and it's even greater.

Cup runs aren't just luck though and the league cup is often won by the team with the strongest B team.
If we stay in the CL beyond the groups I cant see us playing a team of much strength in the cups
 
When everyone's fit, our depth isn't bad at all. Lamela, Davies, Dier, Janssen, Vorm and perhaps a youngster would make up our bench. Get a signing in there like a Barkley, and it's even greater.
Janssen isn't doing it for me. Soon as one attacking mid is injured we are back where we were last year- needing N'Koudou to make an impact.
 
Serious question:
1) Does anyone think our current squad can make an impact on the champions league?

2) Does anyone think this squad could win a cup while resting a few key players for most the competition.

*it's a 'No' and 'No' from me
On the CL:

No, we need to buy a couple players that can challenge the starting XI to get the depth we need to make it past the quarterfinals of the CL. Don't think we will buy one that will be slotted in as we do have a strong starting XI and given the current fees I doubt Levy would spend the money on the transfer or wages, or that Poch would sign off for that matter. I think Lamela coming back will be huge though, so we probably only need another 1-2 signings that are focused on making the first team. I'd like to see some more cheap youth signings, though.

As for cups, uh, why not? We were in the semis of the FA cup last year with the same squad, and the league cup tie against Liverpool came at a bad time for us. There is a great amount of draw luck in cups, but to act like we can't win a domestic cup with this squad is a bit much. You don't think we would have beat United in the league cup final last year?
 
Yes now we are i agree. Do i think we can maintain or eventually push on with the current policy? Maintain maybe but no to pushing on.
I simply do not get the lack of support of our current policy, one that you agree has moved our club forward (and for the majority moved it further forward than they ever thought possible). When you find something that has delivered significant improvement you stick to it, you bottle it up and you do more of it and repeat it and repeat it some more. I see absolutely no logic whatsoever in abandoning it, ignoring it and going after a different policy. Only when a policy fails should reevaluate it, understand what happen and then fix it, tweak it or ditch it.

Such lack of belief and faith in the policy that has gotten us to where we are is truly mind boggling. But each to their own.
 
On the CL:

As for cups, uh, why not? We were in the semis of the FA cup last year with the same squad, and the league cup tie against Liverpool came at a bad time for us. There is a great amount of draw luck in cups, but to act like we can't win a domestic cup with this squad is a bit much. You don't think we would have beat United in the league cup final last year?
I just don't think we have the squad to juggle competitions as things stand.
Realistically our league cup team will be very young an inexperienced and not good enough to reach a final.
If we are playing a strong team in the fa cup it will be because we are out of europe.
I think we will sign one or two players on deadline day but they'll be playing fitness / 'philosophy' catch up all season.
 
Cup runs aren't just luck though and the league cup is often won by the team with the strongest B team.
If we stay in the CL beyond the groups I cant see us playing a team of much strength in the cups

Do Leicester have better depth then us? They also got to the quarter finals.

Our starting eleven is good enough to get us far in the competition. The myth of struggling after CL midweek games has been debunked so shouldn't matter.

Champions League gives us alot more money then the cups. FA Cup is played on a week the league is rested so rotation isn't key.

Poch knows the squad better then anyone.
 
I simply do not get the lack of support of our current policy, one that you agree has moved our club forward (and for the majority moved it further forward than they ever thought possible). When you find something that has delivered significant improvement you stick to it, you bottle it up and you do more of it and repeat it and repeat it some more. I see absolutely no logic whatsoever in abandoning it, ignoring it and going after a different policy. Only when a policy fails should reevaluate it, understand what happen and then fix it, tweak it or ditch it.

Such lack of belief and faith in the policy that has gotten us to where we are is truly mind boggling. But each to their own.

It's very rare to get an elite level youth team player come through. Our level is now more elite than ever. A very successful youth product is of the Townsend/ Mason / Livermore level- ie mid prem level.
It's a huge ask to ask expect them to replace transferred in experiences pros like we could be signing.
 
Serious question:
1) Does anyone think our current squad can make an impact on the champions league?

2) Does anyone think this squad could win a cup while resting a few key players for most the competition.

*it's a 'No' and 'No' from me
No

and

Yes

League and FA cup runs you can get some luck. When we got to the final 2 years ago we'd played Sheffield United in the semis and some dross to get to that point. Poch imo made a ricket of the final by playing a strong team 2 days before away in Europe. We had no energy left against a team we'd beaten 5-3 a few weeks earlier.

To win those trophies its 6 matches, and with a bit of luck some against non-PL oppo
 
Buckle up kids

giphy.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top