So who would you have managing us,
bus-conductor
?
I'm genuinely interested.
I assume you see us as a big club.
A club that should be at least
challenging for major titles and not some glorified southampton-esque development academy that people like
Totti
see us.
So if neither Poch or Jose is the man. Who should Levy be appointing?
I think even more important would have been having a decent DOF in place along with a much better scouting/analytics dept for the last 5 years. I was happy with Poch as a head coach for the first 2/3 years, but being manager - and head scout, head of academy, chief analyst, and finance guru to Danny Rose - was well beyond his capabilities. It would be beyond anyone's.
We've got ourselves in this mess not just because of Pochettino's failings, but Levy's too. Up to the point where he gave Pochettino the job as head coach, Levy had largely done things really well, bar the odd blip, then he took his eye off the ball to build the stadium - a time when more than ever he should have had departmental structures in place that he could have been delegating responsibilities to - only he hadn't, he'd dismantled it, acquiesced to Poch's desire to be the next SAF, and failed to replace Paul Mitchell's analytics department too.
We are not an uber club, we cannot compete with those clubs in terms of finances - yet anyway - so it's important we do things smartly. The last 4/5 years we did things very stupidly. I think Poch was a good coach of footballers to a point, but tactically wasn't the smartest and in terms of knowing what the right footballer was, for the right tactical set up, I don't think he was very good at all. And whilst in games against most his coaching - combined with what had been pretty smart recruiting in the years leading up to his time - overcame that, as soon as we came up against the biggest tests, that inability to match up personnel and tactics let him down. So we get Chadli and Townsend in his first cup final instead of Lamela and Dembele. Then we have Son as a LWB in another semi. The shambles that was the CL final. Things like Dier and Sissoko as CM's. Moura as a CF. Winks as a DM etc etc. And much of the last 2 and half years was fucking atrocious.
There are plenty of good coaches out there, but most of all we need the right structure in place. The club needs to have an over arching philosophy of how it wants to go about things (that matches it's financial capabilities) and recruit smartly to match that philosophy, and coach and integrate our very best academy products smartly to match that philosophy, and appoint our coaches to match that philosophy.
I don't necessarily have an issue with the concept of Mourinho per se, in the mess we were in, I could see the thinking behind it, I just don't like the reality of it. Using a formula 1 analogy, our car isn't competitive any more, so we've chosen to bring in one of the best drivers there has ever been - but the trouble is, despite still winning the odd race, he hasn't won the drivers championship for many years, and what we really needed was to strip the whole car down and rebuild it, and then put a young hungry driver in it.