Lallana, Tadic, Wanyama, Mane, Fonte, Shaw all ended up fantastic for their next clubs so pretty stupid point to be honest lol. Those are the kinds of signings who help you win titles, ask Liverpool.
Look at who were bought for other top teams when they won titles... United bought Young, Van Persie & Rooney who won them Fergie's last title. City bought big with Nasri, Milner, Barry, Clichy etc.
Anyone can identify good players. Not everyone can identify which out of the hundreds of top players you can buy would elevate your team and improve it. Many of us would probably have been interested in Shevchenko and Torres when they went to Chelsea yet they flopped hard... it's really not as easy as it sounds.
Missed my point... Buying Mane from S'oton in an EPL-proven price-band in 2016 (when 30m was still considered a fair whack) isn't exactly what Mitchel and his mythical black book was brought in for.... Maybe finding the 'new Mane' but not the actual, already unearthed Mane....
I'm not saying Lallana, Tadic, Wanyama, Mane, Fonte, Shaw weren't good signings....
For S'ton(*). That was obviously the
nature of signing's we brought Mitchell in for.... Not to buy them in that 'already discovered' phase of their career.
I'm not sure who exactly we should attribute to him during his time with us, but his tenure being Nov 14 > May 16, one would suspect Trippier, N'jie, GKN, Wimmer, Jansen.... Son
maybe? Dele was Pleat's work.... Dier was already on the books.... Davies & Vorm were in.... Toby already had Ajax, Saints, Atleti & Belgium on his CV.
(*You say ask Liverpool, but look at how few of those Poch era S'oton players thrived after their big moves..... Mane is the biggy and Vic was great for us whilst he lasted, but at 30m per pop old money; the likes of Lovren, Lallanna, Shaw, Schniedlerlin etc. weren't particularly good buys.... Being rather polite in some cases.)
As to your closing comments... I totally agree; you don't see me acting the scout on here for good reason. Doesn't mean to say we can't make a critical appraisal of those that work for the club.... Not like our current scouting dept. are dripping with universal praise is it?