The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...
100% ACL on arrival.If we want a winger from spammers it's Bowen we should be after, not Summerville. Rarely less than 7/10 performances, goals and assists and plays lots of games, and he is the finished article. Likely wants to stay in London and too good for championship. Genuine competition for Kudus and good enough to play other side as well at a push. He also works like a dog and would need to to help Porro out.
It really has.
I think his future with us hinges on whether or not he can play well as an 8*.
His ideal position is that pressing 10 kind of role, suits him best, but I dont think that suits us.
Maddison, Xavi, that sort of player should be our 10 - genuinely creative, players to make things happen.
*Even if he can transition to an effective 8 - theres a bloody queue of players for that position. And is Gallagher of the type of player to suit the role in a RDZ side? I genuinely doubt it.
Gallagher is going to end up being one of those buys that just causes issues for years, through no fault of his own.
We have him on stupid wages, which means to move him on will cost us (supplementing his salary?), or just be difficult, and can even impact us buying players if he is a burden on the wage bill...
And after all that - I do like him. I just dont really see how he fits, and also just cannot fathom why we even bought him
Bentancur’s performances under RDZ are what made him worth persevering with for the next year in my mind.
Showed an element of composure that a lot of the others lacked in the run-in.
I ultimately agree on Maddison but I think the CM situation is the biggest problem.
They aren’t good at protecting the defence, nor do they pass through the thirds, nor do they put our attackers (limited as they are) in favourable positions.
I think you might be overthinking it a bit.It really has.
I think his future with us hinges on whether or not he can play well as an 8*.
His ideal position is that pressing 10 kind of role, suits him best, but I dont think that suits us.
Maddison, Xavi, that sort of player should be our 10 - genuinely creative, players to make things happen.
*Even if he can transition to an effective 8 - theres a bloody queue of players for that position. And is Gallagher of the type of player to suit the role in a RDZ side? I genuinely doubt it.
Gallagher is going to end up being one of those buys that just causes issues for years, through no fault of his own.
We have him on stupid wages, which means to move him on will cost us (supplementing his salary?), or just be difficult, and can even impact us buying players if he is a burden on the wage bill...
And after all that - I do like him. I just dont really see how he fits, and also just cannot fathom why we even bought him
How robust is he?
We seem to have had a plethora of Argentinian sick notes in recent years.
I think he'll be a starter. De Zerbi likes him and he does the off the ball work you need your midfield to do.I think you might be overthinking it a bit.
If we view Gallagher as a guaranteed starter then, yes, there's a potential issue there as you describe
But as a squad player I think he's absolutely fine. Can cover at 10 and 8 when we need him. Can come off the bench to provide energy, can start as a super aggressive pressing 10 in games where that's a tactical solution.
He's a useful player to have in the squad and, while that's a lot of salary to spend on a squad player and certainly not the wisest allocation of funds, I think he will always have his uses and won't be a burden unless he starts demanding to start every week.
Relative to other big clubs we don't have many players on massive wages, so we can probably afford to overpay a couple of players. We do need to be careful not to get carried away with wages like United did, though.
.. Plus his wanky haircut tooPlus he has that high pitched scouser whine like a straight cut gearbox that makes dogs howl!![]()
For me he should be a horses for courses guy. I think his best position is how he's played under De Zerbi as a pressing 10, but if we play him there every week he's gonna block Maddison and our creative number 10s. If we start him every week I think he'll become a hindrance in some games as he's simply not that brilliant technically or creative enough to be effective against low blocks.I think he'll be a starter. De Zerbi likes him and he does the off the ball work you need your midfield to do.
On the ball he's been average but I think he'll be alright under De Zerbi's pattern plays next season. He has a decent shot on him as we sat at Villa and under Poch he got 5 goals and 8 assists. Also when he was at Palace had 8 league goals and 3 assists so I think we can see something similar under De Zerbi.
If he can add goals and assists on top of what he brings off the ball we'll have a really good player.
Which players in our team can take on players?I don't want anymore runners. We need some fucking passers, Jesus fucking Christ.
He did seem to really come into his own in the second half of the season for West Ham. Some of his runs were absolutely nuts - think there was one against Brentford or Newcastle where he hit the bar that would've been a goal of the season contender had he scored it.Which players in our team can take on players?
Tel = Sometimes
Richarlison = No
Solanke = No
Maddison = No
Gallagher = No
Summerville would be a great signing.
Then we're in trouble. We need someone that can carry and pass the ball. We got RDZ lite ball because we played with what we have. But if we're not going out and getting a proper midfielder, who'll likely play with Bentancur, then talk of us being serious, is unserious.I think he'll be a starter. De Zerbi likes him and he does the off the ball work you need your midfield to do.
On the ball he's been average but I think he'll be alright under De Zerbi's pattern plays next season. He has a decent shot on him as we sat at Villa and under Poch he got 5 goals and 8 assists. Also when he was at Palace had 8 league goals and 3 assists so I think we can see something similar under De Zerbi.
If he can add goals and assists on top of what he brings off the ball we'll have a really good player.
Well, that's a problem If we go to next season with just two CB's.Lol why?
Hasn't RDZ literally said he wants two for every role?
I don't want anymore runners. We need some fucking passers, Jesus fucking Christ.
I think you might be overthinking it a bit.
If we view Gallagher as a guaranteed starter then, yes, there's a potential issue there as you describe
But as a squad player I think he's absolutely fine. Can cover at 10 and 8 when we need him. Can come off the bench to provide energy, can start as a super aggressive pressing 10 in games where that's a tactical solution.
He's a useful player to have in the squad and, while that's a lot of salary to spend on a squad player and certainly not the wisest allocation of funds, I think he will always have his uses and won't be a burden unless he starts demanding to start every week.
Relative to other big clubs we don't have many players on massive wages, so we can probably afford to overpay a couple of players. We do need to be careful not to get carried away with wages like United did, though.
I really just don't rate him much as an 8 to be honest. It can work in certain games, but his career best form imo was always playing as a 10 for Chelsea with Palmer on the right, or as a 10 for Palace. All his best performances for us have also been in that role.Agree with what you say here, but, I see him as being a guaranteed starter for us. My take is that he's an 8 that can cover the 10. I think he'll start at the 8 for us most games next season, and cover the 10 only in situations where tactics might demand it, or if Maddison or Simons aren't fit. And I'm fine with that- I much prefer him to Bentancur.
I see RDZ's depth chart as this at present:
CAM: Maddison, Simons, Gallagher
CM: Gallagher, Bentancur, Sarr, Gray, Bergvall
CDM: Palhinha(?)
I expect we'll see Bentancur start games where Gallagher is at the 10- especially towards the beginning of this next season where he will need to rotate with Maddison at the 10 to help preserve Maddison's fitness. In this scenario, at least one or two of Sarr, Gray and Bergvall will have difficulties finding enough minutes next season given our lack of European football.
That's ok though- club can figure out something to do about that, which are of course, loans. I suppose something more radical could happen, like RDZ choosing to use Bergvall and Gray at the 6 and not retaining Palhinha, but it seems like he doesn't really trust the kids- I'm not seeing him changing his mind about that in three months or less.