Perhaps not, perhaps the jury is still out on him - I was using him as he was used by others in the posts I was replying to, but perhaps unfairly. I guess the point is that there are many championship players touted as the next big thing, yet many of them make little or no impact in the EPL, but people tend to ignore all of those (relative) 'failures' and simply point to the few successes saying "see, I knew we should have signed him, everyone knew he was destined for big things" etc. It's more difficult than people realise to predict which of them will actually be very successful in the EPL in the future (as opposed to claiming 'it was obvious' after the successful few have done it).Is Scott a failure?
IIRC, he had back to back injuries, with at least one of them being serious, ACL?