He's suggesting we buy a player purely because the player is American. Fuck sake, we get it, some of the American fans think we should sign every available American player. Why are you so annoyed at people disliking his post, saying people think they are experts? Is it because you genuinely think Altidore is all that, or because of the American thing?
The thread title itself says it all. Why not another Yankee, as if it doesn't matter what the player is like, the main thing is to sign him because of where he's from. That's what people take a dislike to, I would think.