• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Was sacking Ange a good idea?

  • Yes, I think it was a good idea.

    Votes: 73 64.6%
  • No, I think it was a bad idea.

    Votes: 40 35.4%

  • Total voters
    113
Losing your main center back is pretty much to worse thing that can happen to a squad. Go look at Liverpools win record without VVD, Arse without Saliba, City without Dias. All dropped significantly.

We are without both CBs and our keeper. Our first choice backup CB injured and replaced with an 18 year old who is not a CB.

We have continued to score plenty of goals through this patch, but simply cannot stop the rot at the back.

So, what should Ange have done against Forest? Park the bus and let them attack our makeshift defence? Or control the game, dominate the ball and score as we always do?

I'm not sure he got the game wrong. They didn't create much and their goal was a product of poor defending. We dominated the ball, but our players didn't deliver.

Kulu was too slow on the ball. Always holding onto it too long and getting tackled.

Solanke rarely looking for the goal and always with his back to goal looking to lay the ball off. He really suits being park of a strike pairing rather than a lone striker.
Your analysis is all based on 1 game. If it was a once off thered be no problem. But everyone knew what would happen yesterday. We've been found out months and months ago but nothing has changed
 
The thing is we have been saying for years we would take a lower half League finish if it meant we won a cup, I guess we will see next week when the transfer window opens how levy feels , if we get some reinforcements in straight away then we know levy is all in.

I still would take a lower half finish for a trophy.

Levy has turned down major January reinforcements when we have been flying at Christmas but strangely enough, I almost feel like he might be more likely to make some when we are in trouble.
 
Your analysis is all based on 1 game. If it was a once off thered be no problem. But everyone knew what would happen yesterday. We've been found out months and months ago but nothing has changed
Everyone knew what would happen this season before a ball had even been kicked. Only 3CBs, 69 games. We struggled last season with 41.

You didn’t need to be mystic Meg to see we’d be fucked if even one of them was crocked.
 
Ange in for the rest of the season IMO, no viable alternatives at the moment...let's see if he can turn it round, if he can't then change in the Summer.

I'm not having no Ryan Mason managing this club for the rest of the season sorry, you can do one and anyone that wants that is an impatient fool who doesn't want the best for this club.
 
What’s Guardiola and Amorin over the same period?
Got to be similar.

Is that their level too? Are we saying Pep is done?
Amorin is not up to the job? Not even getting a new manager bounce!

Totally different scenarios. City are engulfed in an off-field crisis that could see them being relegated and titles stripped away. Their only good midfielder is out for the season and they always had a poor record without him even when they were on top. They are an ageing team at the end of a cycle.

United are just shit, Amorim needs some time to change that awful squad. They have wasted hundreds of millions on shit ex-Ajax players.

Ange has been here for 18 months, stacked the squad with his signings yet we still can’t keep a clean sheet. We can’t win away from home. We can’t create chances against a stubborn defence, etc. We are getting worse and worse as time goes on. He is using injuries as his excuse but like Ten Hag that will not work forever. Everyone in football can see how badly organised this team is.
 
Totally different scenarios. City are engulfed in an off-field crisis that could see them being relegated and titles stripped away. Their only good midfielder is out for the season and they always had a poor record without him even when they were on top. They are an ageing team at the end of a cycle.

United are just shit, Amorim needs some time to change that awful squad. They have wasted hundreds of millions on shit ex-Ajax players.

Ange has been here for 18 months, stacked the squad with his signings yet we still can’t keep a clean sheet. We can’t win away from home. We can’t create chances against a stubborn defence, etc. We are getting worse and worse as time goes on. He is using injuries as his excuse but like Ten Hag that will not work forever. Everyone in football can see how badly organised this team is.

How are you pardoning Manchester fucking city and Pep and making allowances for them because they're missing one player yet pure firmly sticking it to Ange and haven't acknowledged that he's missing half his squad, what are we actually doing here?
 
Ange in for the rest of the season IMO, no viable alternatives at the moment...let's see if he can turn it round, if he can't then change in the Summer.

I'm not having no Ryan Mason managing this club for the rest of the season sorry, you can do one and anyone that wants that is an impatient fool who doesn't want the best for this club.
Mason got us to a cup final in his first stint , put some respect on his name! :mourthumb:
 
How are you pardoning Manchester fucking city and Pep and making allowances for them because they're missing one player yet pure firmly sticking it to Ange and haven't acknowledged that he's missing half his squad, what are we actually doing here?

Because it IS a completely different situation lmao.

City are at the end of a cycle. The squad is exhausted having won everything there is to win. He’s been there for years. Every manager (other than fergie) has a cycle. The off field stuff is obviously impacting them.

It’s not JUST the injuries for City - although they don’t just have one injury at all. They’ve had massive success and now that cycle of success is over.

It’s less fucking tolerable the second season in to a reign minus all the success. We’ve fast forwarded to all the shit. Ange isn’t at the end of a cycle, he’s just a crap manager.
 
Ange in for the rest of the season IMO, no viable alternatives at the moment...let's see if he can turn it round, if he can't then change in the Summer.

I'm not having no Ryan Mason managing this club for the rest of the season sorry, you can do one and anyone that wants that is an impatient fool who doesn't want the best for this club.

It would honestly be hard for Mason to do any worse than Ange is currently doing. Like you could stick a fan in as coach and probably get similar results.
 
Because it IS a completely different situation lmao.

City are at the end of a cycle. The squad is exhausted having won everything there is to win. He’s been there for years. Every manager (other than fergie) has a cycle. The off field stuff is obviously impacting them.

It’s not JUST the injuries for City - although they don’t just have one injury at all. They’ve had massive success and now that cycle of success is over.

It’s less fucking tolerable the second season in to a reign minus all the success. We’ve fast forwarded to all the shit. Ange isn’t at the end of a cycle, he’s just a crap manager.

Sorry this is the team that everyone expected to win the league at the start of the season, they're currently on a run on 1 win in 14 matches with one of the best squads in Europe and the best manager, I sorry what have I missed?

There's actually a lot of similarities between Pep and Ange notably that both managers are stubborn and won't change their philosophies, Pep could easily get them to sit in a mid block and cull the pressing and they would be winning more matches, Ange could do something similar...both in that respect are doing terrible jobs.
 
It would honestly be hard for Mason to do any worse than Ange is currently doing. Like you could stick a fan in as coach and probably get similar results.

A completely pointless change that doesn't prove anything, it's a short term shot in the arm for over emotional fans who haven't thought about the consequences of sacking this manager, not having it sorry.
 
You'd have to respect it if he did.

Finish 16th and win the EL and it's still our best ever season in the PL era.
It's the main reason that I can't hit the Ange out button yet, at least not until there's a real threat of relegation. Not that I for one minute really believe he will drive us on to win the EL - there are better coached, mentally stronger teams than us in the competition - but intrigue is currently getting the better of me. I want to see if this overblown strep-throat navel-gazer and our weird assembly of misfits can actually go full Dodgeball and do it. Like one of those 'science' experiments you do as kids when the teacher's not looking and you grab any old combination of chemicals to hand and pour them into a beaker to see if they explode.

Also, Shadydan Shadydan is right: who exactly is going to come in at this stage? Who's out there? I'm all for a really good manager who isn't such an idealist as Ange nor as stone-cold a pragmatist like Conte, but I have zero idea if such a person is currently available.

What I wrote before stands; I don't personally care if he stays or goes. But will the players be happy with his departure? There are a fair few things to consider here. It's not as simple as chucking something in the bin and shouting "next!".
 
Sorry this is the team that everyone expected to win the league at the start of the season, they're currently on a run on 1 win in 14 matches with one of the best squads in Europe and the best manager, I sorry what have I missed?

There's actually a lot of similarities between Pep and Ange notably that both managers are stubborn and won't change their philosophies, Pep could easily get them to sit in a mid block and cull the pressing and they would be winning more matches, Ange could do something similar...both in that respect are doing terrible jobs.

It's actually beyond a coincidence that both teams are struggling hard, with remarkably similar tactical issues being exposed because - for different reasons - they can't maintain a level of physical dominance.

Pep because they are either burnt out or off-cycle PEDs (most likely both)
Ange because he doesn't have the depth to be physically dominant when key players are overplayed or injured.

The consequence is exactly the same for both where the system is easy to play through and chaotic.
 
Back
Top