• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Was sacking Ange a good idea?

  • Yes, I think it was a good idea.

    Votes: 73 64.6%
  • No, I think it was a bad idea.

    Votes: 40 35.4%

  • Total voters
    113
I'm torn because I know if we sack him then players like Romero and Porro could look to leave and there is part of me that thinks we can really build on this current group of players. Player for player, this is the best back 4 we've ever had and probably will ever have. Its a generational back 4. I'd love us to keep them and build on it.
😶🔫
 
To be honest it’s quite obvious. Spurs fans waiting for the club to make a statement when in reality the only statement they could make is that he’s sacked. Other than that he’s under contract and is the manager.
I don’t know what people are expecting. A statement saying the manager is not sacked isn’t happening. Some comments backing him maybe forthcoming but we all know they don’t count for much once he loses more games.
I’ve always said I think he starts next season.
 
I'm not. How is he an upgrade? What has he achieved in football management? If it means getting more out of average players, well that's also a Sam Allardyce achievement!!!

Unless Levy finds someone who is a clear-as-day upgrade, he will be on a hiding to nothing when he loses 3 games in a row (Levy and the new manager).

If you said to me at the start of the season, you can win the Europa (in my mind, UEFA) cup and get into the CL, but you have to finish 17th as a price to pay, I'd take that all day. Finishing 4th, 3rd and 2nd as we have in the past decade, meant f'all to me. Winning something was badly needed. Can't sack a manager for winning a trophy under challenging circumstances (back 5 injured all at once, playing kids all season, injuries to key players).
 
This makes sense in what I think Levy wants, and that is he fancies Poch returning after the WC so will be very hesitant to bring someone in now to be potentially paying them off at the end of the season if they are shite!
This is the scenario I see happening too. I really don't think Levy will sack him after lifting a pot and someone like Frank or Xavi or whoever coming in would be a gamble anyway. They would be on a hiding to nothing with the previous man having got the trophy monkey off our back.
Ange stays, see how it goes - if its not a disaster in the league and CL group stage by winter break he will see out the year with Poch back in 26 is my bet and tbh I wouldn't be against it if the touted managers were the alternative.
 
IMO any whispers or statements to suggest he is staying - from players or otherwise - is the 'default' I'd expect to hear and nothing more.

The only way we'll know he's actually staying is if he's on the pre-season tour, or if we start signing players for him. At the minimum, we won't hear anything at all about any changes until end of June (IMO) when the new footballing administration comes in (Vinai and, I assume, Paratici)

Certainly won't even know if Ange himself is wanting to stay on until he's back off his holiday. Despite the fact he's about to turn 60, he has school age kids. I imagine, because of that, he will want to - or be under pressure to - consider carefully about whether he wants to put his kids in a new school year only to be at risk of moving them anyway in October/November time (such is the pressure to start the season well).

I wouldn't put it past him to leave with the Europa on his mantle, reputation (contentiously) enhanced, rather than gamble and leave Ramos style
 
What's the point of having all these supposed football directors Vini, Paratici, Munn, Lange if they can't make the correct decision.

Winning the europa league is great for the club and a fantastic achievement but cup football isn't a measure of sustainability, unless the club is extremely consistent in winning them year after year. Which we in recent times are not.

22 league defeats....22. it is clear as day there is something fundamentally wrong with Ange Postecoglou and his coaching staff.

We are never Pro active always hopeful and always reactive, we should be making clear and obvious steps to improve but it always feels undercooked.

We have got a head start now regarding champions league and we really need to put some distance between us and the rest of the chasing pack.
 
If Levy wants to sack him - he can't until Ange gets back from his holiday.
I suspect one factor will be their personal relationship.
It normally ends it breaking down - and the manager mouthing off about Levy and the club.

Ange has sort of done it - but nowhere near to the extent others did. We forget how crazy Poch went in the press towards the end. We don't know what is happening behind the scenes.
 
You really think this back 4 is better than prime Rose Toby Vert Walker? That's quite the statement.

Personally don't think they're in that bracket yet to be honest.
Yeah thats the only comparison and its close. Right now I can see why you'd have the Poch back 4 ahead as you can see their full careers.

Personally I think Porro Romero VDV and Udogie will all go onto have much better careers than the 4 you mentioned. Romero has already surpassed them. VDV is destined to become one of the best and will either do it with us or at a bigger club.

Porro might not get to Walker levels of success so he'd the debatable one. Prime Rose is better than current Udogie but I'd back Udogie to end up with a much better career.

Big statement but I could see us reflecting on this back 4 in 5 years time and kicking ourselves for not building on it. Could see all 4 of them playing for the best teams in Europe if they can't make it work here.
 
I'm torn because I know if we sack him then players like Romero and Porro could look to leave and there is part of me that thinks we can really build on this current group of players. Player for player, this is the best back 4 we've ever had and probably will ever have. Its a generational back 4. I'd love us to keep them and build on it.

But I'm not convinced Ange is the man to bring us forward. Its almost a shame that the players love him so much because it makes sacking him a massive gamble where it could ruin morale and we probably will lose Romero and maybe Porro too.

As things stand, it sounds like no players will want to leave if Ange stays. Maybe the sensible thing to do is keep him and see how this united group of players do under him next season. I'm torn really. Don't mind which way it goes. Just hope we make the decision next week and can start building for next season.
:pochshock2:
it's not even the best back 4 we've had in the last 10 years, much less the best we've ever had. Player for player, Rose was far better than Udogie, Vert>Romero, Alderweireld>VDV, Walker>Porro. And it's not even close.
There's a strong shout to say BAE/King/Woodgate/Corluka were better than this lot considering our current defenders can't fucking stay fit for 5 games in a row either.
 
Guys..I've never, ever, claimed to be some kind of ITK, but a reliable geezer I'm in occasional business contact with (yesterday afternoon being one such occasion) who liases regularly with the club is absolutely adamant that the decision has already been made to run with Ange next season.

Whether there is any truth to this or not I believe he will stay and the club will look at the injury crisis and point to that as a factor of the poor results in the league.
 
:pochshock2:
it's not even the best back 4 we've had in the last 10 years, much less the best we've ever had. Player for player, Rose was far better than Udogie, Vert>Romero, Alderweireld>VDV, Walker>Porro. And it's not even close.
There's a strong shout to say BAE/King/Woodgate/Corluka were better than this lot considering our current defenders can't fucking stay fit for 5 games in a row either.
Game of opinion. I think in 5 years time we'll be reflecting on this back 4 as generational and we'll probably see most of them playing for the best sides in Europe.
 
Game of opinion. I think in 5 years time we'll be reflecting on this back 4 as generational and we'll probably see most of them playing for the best sides in Europe.
It's an objective fact that this back 4 has conceded 126 league goals in 2 seasons, there's absolutely no chance this is a generational defence. I think of the lot, VDV is the best, and I agree with you that he has the potential to be world class, however big question marks over his fitness, and he is not without his faults, very susceptible in the air considering his height, and he is still somewhat naive in his positioning, so definitely gaps to fill. Porro is nothing like good enough defensively or athletic enough to make up for it to ever be in the world class bracket at RB, I very much doubt anyone at CL level is looking at him seriously considering what they'd need to part with. Udogie is very young and I want to see him in a proper defensive system before making serious judgement. Romero, yes, great on his day, so many fucking individual errors though, and been a sicknote for his 3 seasons here, the best ability is availability and that's something both our CBs have not been for large stretches of the last 2 seasons.
 
One thing I give him full credit for is his prioritizing on winning a trophy because it would mean more to the fans than another top 4 finish

A "no brainer" you might say but recent history would say not so.

I remember the presser where he asked one of the journo's "What do you think winning this trophy would mean". "it would be massive..." "....yes it would be massive"

His emotional IQ amd ability to motivate is off the charts.
 
To be honest it’s quite obvious. Spurs fans waiting for the club to make a statement when in reality the only statement they could make is that he’s sacked. Other than that he’s under contract and is the manager.
If Ange is staying than how about we start working on our summer signings - that’s the STATEMENT I want to see.

Our rivals in the Big Six have wrapped up at least one signing:

Red Scum - Zubumendi
Mancs - Cunha
Chavs - Delap
Scouse - Frimpong

… and they are hot on the heels of others.

Meanwhile crickets from us. If Ange is staying then what are you waiting for you bald f’in cunt? Get off ur arse and start working on our transfers!
 
Last edited:
:pochshock2:
it's not even the best back 4 we've had in the last 10 years, much less the best we've ever had. Player for player, Rose was far better than Udogie, Vert>Romero, Alderweireld>VDV, Walker>Porro. And it's not even close.
There's a strong shout to say BAE/King/Woodgate/Corluka were better than this lot considering our current defenders can't fucking stay fit for 5 games in a row either.
Recency bias in full effect.
 
If Ange is staying than how about we start working on our summer signings - that’s the STATEMENT I want to see.

Our rivals in the Big Six have wrapped up at least one signing:

Red Scum - Zubumendi
Mancs - Cunha
Chavs - Delap
Scouse - Frimpong

… and they are hot on the heels of others.

Meanwhile crickets from us. If Ange is staying then what are you waiting for you bald f’in cunt? Get off ur arse and start working on our transfers!
Should be used to this by now. Every year same shit, I don’t know why it even bothers people anymore.
 
Ange does gaslight.
He made a .massive deal about the City game last year - and how fans didn't want us to give Woolwich the title. And then year - he pretends losing all the matches waa a master plan. So we win the EL without having a shot on goal l.

He says he us all about entertaining football - but process to play two of the most boring uncreative front players imaginable week in week out.

Fair play he won something and that's what we wanted - and all the utterly shit football was worth it this year.

But like JM and Conte watching Ange's anti creative skillful forwards is only worth it if we win something.

On reflection - our football really has been off the scale terrible - I doubt we have had one goal in the top 100 goals of the season.

if he didn't do that I'd be the first to criticize for him for being stubborn and inflexible, unable to adjust. Hell I'd even post

a witty gif of him saying "Its who we are mate"
 
Guys..I've never, ever, claimed to be some kind of ITK, but a reliable geezer I'm in occasional business contact with (yesterday afternoon being one such occasion) who liases regularly with the club is absolutely adamant that the decision has already been made to run with Ange next season.

Yeah, heard that from a couple of places now. Sounds legit to me, tbf.

Probably the wrong decision but if that is the case, the very least that Levy can do is fucking back him in the market.

He won't though.
 
Back
Top