• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Was sacking Ange a good idea?

  • Yes, I think it was a good idea.

    Votes: 73 64.6%
  • No, I think it was a bad idea.

    Votes: 40 35.4%

  • Total voters
    113
It's a cult. At this point they may as well be that newsreader on North Korean state television.


kim jong un GIF

Surprised Hold On GIF by GIPHY News

Every time I think you have taken it as far as you can, you surpass yourself!
 
On paper, our PL managerial record seems (from my recollections certainly) to be terrible when hiring someone who's never managed in the PL (thinking Gross, Santini, Ramos, Ange), and generally good when it is some kind of perceived underwhelming option (Jol [partial outlier from the previous], Redknapp, Poch) and a car crash overall when trying for the 'exciting' options (AVB, Mourinho, Conte).

As noted, there are outliers in there, but I think the only trend we need to be careful of is doing what United have done (and us, to a smaller extend) and hiring in some jazzy manager with no PL experience. It's a tough league.
I'm nervous about Glasner for that reason, but he's done well at Palace so I can see why he's a really good option.

People get underwhelmed by cheap/young signings too, when some of our best players have been exactly that.

Good post.

Agree that we need to look at managerial options with PL experience, albeit Glasner's is somewhat limited.
 
I loved winning a cup but you cannot seriously tell me that the Europa League win indicates a direction of travel but our league form somehow doesn't? The league is where we play most of our matches and forms the biggest body of work for us to judge. What in the league have you seen that says we won't be pissing around the bottom half again next season? I haven't seen anything that suggests that won't still be the case next year.
I think our league form will improve dramatically next season even with Ange.

From November to February this season, we had in my opinion the worst injury crisis I've ever seen at Spurs. Then from February onwards, it was clear that we were prioritising Europe and resting most of our team in all the league games. I don't think Romero and VDV started any league games together in 2025! So from November until May, we were never anywhere near full strength in any of our league games. I'm going to guess this won't be the case next year under any manager, be it Ange or not. Levy will drive home the message to go full strength in the league and rotate in other games if necessary (even CL).

For context, we played 12 games in the league last year before the injury crisis kicked in during the November international break. We were 7th in the league with 6 wins, 1 draw and 5 loses and a goal difference on +14. And that was the last time we were ever full strength in the league again for the remainder of the season. Vicario got injured after the City game and we rolled out the next week with Forster and a CB pairing of Dragusin and Davies. The rest is history. I know the first 12 games were not perfect. I know we lost at home to ipswich with our strongest team. But we were winning more games than we were losing! We aren't this bad!

Now I've no horse in this race. I really don't care if we sack him or not. I'm not going to pretend Ange has the answers or will dramatically change his approach next season. But I do think our league position is an absolute certainty to improve next season regardless of who the manager is. We will hit at least 50 points minimum and if I was to guess I think we could be in around the 60 point mark which will have us in around the European places, and just short of top 4. Playing your strongest team available every week in the league will make a massive difference. We didn't do this for most the season and you know what? It was worth it! For one season and one season only, our club binned off the league and won a trophy!
 
Good.

As for the Frank question, it's still irrelevant because its unknown other than he has done a good in the PL for 7 years.

Poxhettino didn't do that much before he came to us.

Same with some players. You take a punt.
We are Spurs, we shouldn't be taking these kind of Nuno punts again.

BTW. Frank has managed in the PL for 4 seasons not 7 and has a best finish of 9th... if that is doing good then fair play.

The difference with Pochettino was that he was young, up and coming, hadn't reached his ceiling and whilst I accept it was a punt he actually did finish 8th in his one completed PL season (higher than anything Frank has achieved). Frank is a known commodity across his entire coaching career. What you see is what you get... a bloke who will win some, lose some, not trouble the big sides and finish somewhere in the middle of the pack... not good enough to worry the elite, not bad enough to get dragged into a relegation battle. With Frank, our new rightful place in the world order (Premier League) will be 9th or 10th.
 
Ish

His record against City and Villa isn’t bad,

He’s beaten Liverpool twice as well.

But the results against Woolwich and Chelsea are shite. Unacceptably shite

Our record against City is freakish. It's as good as it is bad against that filthy club.

We have regressed re: Woolwich.

Postecoglou has failed to add value,or to create anything of substance.

Take the bloke out of it, and simply ask yourself are we really better now than when he arrived? That's 2 years to put something in place.

It's not a hard question.
 
Last edited:
Our record against City is freakish. It's as good as it is bad against that filthy club.

We have regressed re: Woolwich.

Postecoglou has failed to add value,or tocreate anythjng of substance.

Take the bloke out of ut, and simply ask yourself are we really better now than when he arrived? That's 2 years toput something in place.

It's not a hard question.

Winning our first European trophy in 41 years is nothing of substance?

Deary me
 
I want a coach who knows how to win. Winning breeds more winning.
For the record, I want Ange gone but why are we not trying to upgrade. Plenty of managers our there with better pedigree's than Frank. I don't think you can guarantee we finish bottom 3-4 again under Ange. You say it like it's a given clearly forgetting he finished 5th in his first season. How many ppg did Frank get against Spurs last season under shitty Ange?

Have you convinced yourself that because we won the Europa league under Ange every one else is a downgrade?
We won't even be in the Europa League next season. We'll get spanked in the CL and we won't finish high enough in the PL to get back into the Europa league in 26/27 to give him another chance. Heck, we might not finish high enough to be in the PL in 26/27
You say you want Ange gone, but you're not willing to gamble on anyone else. Be brave. Fuck it. Throw caution to the wind. We have to try something else and we aren't employing a coach who's ceiling is 9th here.
This has been explained but you seem to chose to ignore it. I think Brentford could go down pretty quickly after Frank leaves, wherever he goes.
 
It's a cult. Deny the truth that is evident and established. Rubbish any alternative, over inflate the achievements of our chosen one and overlook the multiple data points that if given longer he will cause the club real harm. I admire the people still bothering to contend them, but it's a waste of time. At this point they may as well be that newsreader on North Korean state television. When Postecoglou is replaced all these heroes of the upside and positivity will be queuing up to kick the new coach at every turn because their man was 'better'.


kim jong un GIF

Cult of Ange v Cult of Levy.

Quite a match up. Wonder if they are both the same people?
 
We are Spurs, we shouldn't be taking these kind of Nuno punts again.

BTW. Frank has managed in the PL for 4 seasons not 7 and has a best finish of 9th... if that is doing good then fair play.

The difference with Pochettino was that he was young, up and coming, hadn't reached his ceiling and whilst I accept it was a punt he actually did finish 8th in his one completed PL season (higher than anything Frank has achieved). Frank is a known commodity across his entire coaching career. What you see is what you get... a bloke who will win some, lose some, not trouble the big sides and finish somewhere in the middle of the pack... not good enough to worry the elite, not bad enough to get dragged into a relegation battle. With Frank, our new rightful place in the world order (Premier League) will be 9th or 10th.

Frank, yes 4 years in the PL. 7 in total. Apologies.

By your token we should not then sign players who aren't already at top clubs or from the lower leagues.

And Slot at Liverpool. Punt or inspired?
 
Oh, the ironing.

Shaking Head No GIF by GIPHY News

You claim everybody you know wants Ange out...
Why can't you just accept the fact that not everybody agrees with you and also accept the possibility that you Ange Abusers might be in the minority among the fanbase?
Anyway the poll has rattled your and other's cages so my job here is done.
What’s your laundry got to do with anything?! 😂

The irony is you accepting the validity of a poll on the cesspit that is X as fact!

You couldn’t make it up!

:dembelelol:

BTW I haven’t abused Ange other than to question his ability as a Premier League manager.
 
Frank, yes 4 years in the PL. 7 in total. Apologies.

By your token we should not then sign players who aren't already at top clubs or from the lower leagues.

And Slot at Liverpool. Punt or inspired?
All we need is a sensible manager with ambitious transfers.

Slot would not get this team in champions league.

I reckon Ange would get this pool team playing some pretty good football TBF.

No manage can polish turds in the long run.
 
We are Spurs, we shouldn't be taking these kind of Nuno punts again.

BTW. Frank has managed in the PL for 4 seasons not 7 and has a best finish of 9th... if that is doing good then fair play.

The difference with Pochettino was that he was young, up and coming, hadn't reached his ceiling and whilst I accept it was a punt he actually did finish 8th in his one completed PL season (higher than anything Frank has achieved). Frank is a known commodity across his entire coaching career. What you see is what you get... a bloke who will win some, lose some, not trouble the big sides and finish somewhere in the middle of the pack... not good enough to worry the elite, not bad enough to get dragged into a relegation battle. With Frank, our new rightful place in the world order (Premier League) will be 9th or 10th.
What do you suppose the mean average you are using for Frank tells us about the expected league position for Postecoglou? Go head tell us what we have too look forward to. As for your reached the coaching ceiling...its entirely your subjective opinion.
 
We are Spurs, we shouldn't be taking these kind of Nuno punts again.

BTW. Frank has managed in the PL for 4 seasons not 7 and has a best finish of 9th... if that is doing good then fair play.

The difference with Pochettino was that he was young, up and coming, hadn't reached his ceiling and whilst I accept it was a punt he actually did finish 8th in his one completed PL season (higher than anything Frank has achieved). Frank is a known commodity across his entire coaching career. What you see is what you get... a bloke who will win some, lose some, not trouble the big sides and finish somewhere in the middle of the pack... not good enough to worry the elite, not bad enough to get dragged into a relegation battle. With Frank, our new rightful place in the world order (Premier League) will be 9th or 10th.
He gets 9th or 10th with Brentford already, with more resource you're saying he will be the same?
Terrible assessment.
Sad John Cena GIF
 
yeah it wasnt a great final - but our perfoamces towards theend of that season were dogshite forthemost part - Poch had just run out of ideas.

People get very blinded by the feeling of coming back from basically being out of the CL vs Ajax and mistake that high feeling with one that we were somehow in form and playing well at that time. Don't get me wrong - the comeback was incredible - inspired - i was buzzing for days - but that doesn't mean we were a good footballing outfit at that time.
Our league form under Poch from Jan to May in 2019 was 10 wins, 2 draws, 7 losses. 55% win ratio. Extrapolate it out to a whole season and he would be 4 pts worse off than Ange was last season with no Europe and out of both cups early. He did that whilst maintaining a CL push, getting to a league cup semi (only losing on penalties), and signing absolutely zero players for 3 windows in the process. Poch had not run out of ideas, he just wasn't ever given the tools to properly succeed. I hold the belief he should not have played a half-fit Kane in the final, even though I also would happily admit I don't think starting Lucas Moura would be very likely to have made a difference, but he was literally the only reason we were there in the first place. Despite that we certainly did not get walked over in the final, we played well enough where having a fully fit and sharp Kane would have 100% been a huge "what if" factor in a different outcome.
 
4 years. Before that he was busy not achieving automatic promotion from the Championship with Toney, Benrahma, Raya, Mbuemo, Janelt, Norgaard, etc.

They had an insane team for that division, with Frank's player development abilities playing a role in that of course.

Yes, 4 years in the PL. My mistake.

Look mate. I think Frank is okay, but that's not really the point.

The issue is the absolute paucity of Postecoglou, and that in my opinion we must change things.

It's up to Levy to find that objectively best option. Let's not make this Frank or Postecoglou, because even on that binary choice I think it's easy.
 
All we need is a sensible manager with ambitious transfers.

Slot would not get this team in champions league.

I reckon Ange would get this pool team playing some pretty good football TBF.

No manage can polish turds in the long run.

Fair enough but we ain't getting the best players, so we need a better manager. Much better.

The very best players would not want to be coached by Postecoglou in my opinion. Not a chance.
 
Back
Top