• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Was sacking Ange a good idea?

  • Yes, I think it was a good idea.

    Votes: 73 64.6%
  • No, I think it was a bad idea.

    Votes: 40 35.4%

  • Total voters
    113
He had some good players. They had the best team ever.

Nobody is saying the European cup doesn’t count.. not even close. He won it. I will credit him with winning it. I’m just not gonna call shithousing Frankfurt and United spectacular because it objectively isn’t. They’re not great teams.

I’m fine with the approach, it worked, but I will give the proportionate amount of praise for the teams we beat. Spectacular is when we knocked out the 100 point City team in the CL. Calling beating Frankfurt by a goal spectacular muddies the term.

I won’t even include Bodo..

Fair enough.

Dunno why everyone's banging on about the manager when we should all be focusing on the massive great holes in our squad - let alone the overall quality. Let's hope for a big transfer window.
 
What if the kit launch tomorrow is Ange wearing the new kit for
Episode 3? :ange-arms:
1_Ange-Postecoglou-Announces-Celtic-visit-to-Australia.jpg
 
Did they win a European Trophy? No. Did they provide good league seasons? No.

Trophies won by Harry Redknapp at Spurs: 0
Trophies won by Mauricio Pochettino at Spurs: 0.

Brilliant league seasons. No fucking trophies.

I have now witnessed Spurs win a European Trophy live. Nothing else matters right now. I'm sad for you that you don't understand this.

I'm also pretty sad at this affair of things.

To me it seems that people do not understand context of things at all. Like for example difference between trophy and trophy. Saying "I have now witnessed Spurs win a European Trophy" and putting down Poch for 0 trophies is kind of weird.

He got us so freaking close in Champions League. You know, the most high profile and high level competition in the world. All while still being competitive in the league too. While under Ange we won Europa League. Which is so incredibly much weaker than CL that it is shocking. It is like saying that winning Championship is somehow better than to be 2nd or 3rd in EPL. That is plain wrong or overly simplistic. Just saying that trophy for sake of trophy is all that matters makes me think that so many fans would literally go around bragging about becoming U12 master in local spelling bee.
 
Is it ultimately though? For players you could say so.

For us? If the week to week is an absolute chore to endure, then what is the point?

I've been supporting Spurs for 30 years, I've seen 2 League Cups and this Europa, I've supported Spurs through George Graham, Christian Gross, and Tim Sherwood.

I was unequivocally not supporting us through those times because of the impending glory around the corner.

If you told me that next season is going to be another 38 game slog of a season with rarely a game to enjoy, but we'd some way or another pick up another silver pot, I'm not sure I'd bother to tune in tbh.

I realise that the last line might seem at odds with having said that I've supported through plenty of shit times, but the expectation is different now. If Ange had done what he's done with the squad that GG, or Gross had, then I'd have nothing but respect for him. For me, he's so detrimental to the development of the squad/players that we are left thinking that the squad full of internationals is barely above relegation fodder and we need a massive overhaul in personnel.

Sherwood, was probably the last time that I felt as apathetic about Spurs as I do right now, and at the time it felt bleak beyond salvage, so right now I'm hoping that the club can do the same again with a change of Manager.
I've supported the club for longer and through more trophies, and whilst the FA Cup meant everything, and Ramos' league cup was still a disappointing season, we were previously
regarded as a 'cup team' , so poor league form happened but I still had confidence in the cups.

The past 10+ years I haven't felt like we're a cup team that could win something. I knew we would get dumped out of every cup, but maybe that could change again and could once again see us as a realistic cup threat in every competition.

That only happens with managers that are allowed and take the cups seriously.
 
Lets be honest even if we'd have been superb in that final and done them by 3 or 4 you really shouldnt be changing your mind on 90 minutes when you have 17 months worth of evidence showing how poor we are. He stood a chance of staying on if we'd have shown more in the league, things like consistancy, clean sheets, more difficult to beat but we've just got worse and worse over time. There is zero cohesion to our play, we're boring to watch, individuals and the team collectively going backwards. There is also zero sign things would improve.
I was specifically told and said so here months ago he would not be judged on one game against Man United, no matter the happiness people derived from the win
 
I'm also pretty sad at this affair of things.

To me it seems that people do not understand context of things at all. Like for example difference between trophy and trophy. Saying "I have now witnessed Spurs win a European Trophy" and putting down Poch for 0 trophies is kind of weird.

He got us so freaking close in Champions League. You know, the most high profile and high level competition in the world. All while still being competitive in the league too. While under Ange we won Europa League. Which is so incredibly much weaker than CL that it is shocking. It is like saying that winning Championship is somehow better than to be 2nd or 3rd in EPL. That is plain wrong or overly simplistic. Just saying that trophy for sake of trophy is all that matters makes me think that so many fans would literally go around bragging about becoming U12 master in local spelling bee.

I remember when Poch first said it wasn't about winning trophies but being able to consistently put yourself in a position to win them that mattered.

Many were pissed at this because they seemed to think he was disrespecting the FA and League cups but I always agreed with him because cup runs are nice but league position is the true marker. I still generally agree with this BUT a European Trophy is a big fucking deal and if it comes at the cost of league position for one year I'm more than happy with it.

BTW: When Poch got us to the CL final it came on the back of an end of year collapse in league form that would carry on into the next season and get him sacked.

Also Poch's 11 was lightyears better than what we have now.
 
Is it ultimately though? For players you could say so.

For us? If the week to week is an absolute chore to endure, then what is the point?

I've been supporting Spurs for 30 years, I've seen 2 League Cups and this Europa, I've supported Spurs through George Graham, Christian Gross, and Tim Sherwood.

I was unequivocally not supporting us through those times because of the impending glory around the corner.

If you told me that next season is going to be another 38 game slog of a season with rarely a game to enjoy, but we'd some way or another pick up another silver pot, I'm not sure I'd bother to tune in tbh.

I realise that the last line might seem at odds with having said that I've supported through plenty of shit times, but the expectation is different now. If Ange had done what he's done with the squad that GG, or Gross had, then I'd have nothing but respect for him. For me, he's so detrimental to the development of the squad/players that we are left thinking that the squad full of internationals is barely above relegation fodder and we need a massive overhaul in personnel.

Sherwood, was probably the last time that I felt as apathetic about Spurs as I do right now, and at the time it felt bleak beyond salvage, so right now I'm hoping that the club can do the same again with a change of Manager.

Would you take another season like last season, lose 22 matches and finish 17th if it guaranteed winning the CL?
 
To some degree this is just a different philosophy of enjoyment. It’s like trying to convince someone to switch political parties are religion.

Some people think that 17th and a trophy is having a better season than 2nd and no trophy. I’m not one of them and it doesn’t make a lot of sense to me. But it seems that trying to convince those so deeply entrenched on either side seems pointless.
 
Would you take another season like last season, lose 22 matches and finish 17th if it guaranteed winning the CL?

Thing is, it doesn't work like that does it? The vast majority of the time, the CL winners are either champions or 2nd place in their league that season. Success in the league has a very high correlation with cup success. You can't get to a CL final without beating some of the best sides in Europe along the way (one or two seasons might challenge that). This last season was, by any statistitical benchmark, an abberation. The Guardian 'Knowledge' column covered it off last week pretty well.


Edit: This article also contains a very relevant pearl from arguably the greatest manager in England: "The two clubs had drawn the first game 0-0 and Forest were 2-1 up in the first replay when a Roy Keane backpass led to John Salako chipping Mark Crossley from distance and Keane finding himself on the dressing room floor – Clough punched him in the face and said: “Never play the ball back to the goalkeeper.”
 
That's just stupid. The question is whether we'd have been more likely to win if we'd played like PSG and the answer is yes.

Pulling the wool over your own eyes by pretending that we played well in the final is not helpful. We played with our backs against the wall, and it worked out. Great - but most of the time it doesn't.
If you were available to play as a 10 you should have told Ange.
 
Thing is, it doesn't work like that does it? The vast majority of the time, the CL winners are either champions or 2nd place in their league that season. You can't get to a CL final without beating some of the best sides in Europe along the way (one or two seasons might challenge that). This last season was, by any statistitical benchmark, an abberation. The Guardian 'Knowledge' column covered it off last week pretty well.


:adesalute:
 
Back
Top