I agree with most of your posts, mate, but I must say that in my opinion you were wrong when in your first post tonight (I am paraphrasing, correct me if I am wrong) you said: " what achievements ? he hasn't won any trophy"
I have never heard that Poch was hired to win trophies, nor I have ever expected that. Yes , it could have happened and I feel sorry we didn't, but that to me has never been the objective he would have been assessed on.
We all have our opinions and we all had our personal emotions from that time that now has gone for good, but I don't think that it's fair to judge Poch for the lack of trophies. On the contrary, ll the comments about such lack are one of the biggest sign of how well he did with him, because we went on to play for some trophy that was unimaginable before him
What was unimaginable before him?
Only CL win, I'd say. Now look at the replays of semi- and quarterfinals. Are you suggesting that this was some epic tactical masterclass or was there huge amount of luck also involved?
At the same time he had literally ALL the resources to win a domestic cup. Yet in decisive games we crumbled to the ground under him, despite having more talented squad that beat very same opponents in same seasons (ManU and Chelsea in cup semifinal and final) in the league.
There is no doubt that he done some remarkable work with us and gave us few good seasons. But to claim that "I have never heard that Poch was hired to win trophies" then... sorry but what HAVE you heard what was he brought on for? To lose in cup semifinals and finals? Very, very weird claim to make, sorry.