As an introduction I have been running a player ratings thread on another site and have transfered all the data across to this site.
It's a bit long winded this first ice breaker but try and stay with it.
Ratings are taken from newspapers, TV , Spurs sites and neutral sites. But most importantly and kept separate are forum posters ratings. A couple of days after the match or before the next one I collate the ratings and display the averages for each player.
The thread stays the same, no new thread per game. This makes tracking back easier.
I rate all games and there will always be around 10 from the media etc. It would be good to get some forum input but I realise it may take some time to get going. I may have to do some prompting but its down to personal choice. The more data goes in, the better because it gives a more reliable average.
My findings after 3 years is that for a player to achieve a rating of 7 across the season is nigh on impossible, its not been achieved yet !!
As a guide a 5 is poor, a 6 acceptable, a 7 good, 8 very good, 9 excellent, 10 exceptional. 0.5 marks are encouraged and the difference between a 6 and 6.50 is significant as you will find out. Likewise up and down the scale.
Here are the 20/21 season averages.
1. Kane........6.63
2. Hojbjerg 6.41
3. Toby..........6.35
4. Lloris.........6.22
5. Ndombele 6.20
6. Son..............6.19
7. Dele............6.18
8 . Lo Celso....6.16
9. Dier.............6.10
10. Lamela ....6.08
11. Aurier.......5.86
12. Davies.......5.84
21/22 Season averages.
1. Dier.........6.65
2. Romero 6.58
3. Lloris......6.45
4. Skipp/ Son 6.37
5. Kane..........6.25
6. Hojbjerg...6.21
7. Sanchez....6.18
8 . Moura .....6.17
9. Royal........6.08
10. Davies.....5.91
22/23 First 5 games.
1. Kulu 6.96
2. Kane 6.91
3. Dier....6.75
4. Hojbjerg 6.69
5. Davies...6 40
6. Royal....6.20
7. Lloris...6.10
8. Son.......5.52
Second 5.
1. Richarlison 7.07
2. Bentancur 6.78
3. Kane............6.52
4. Lloris...........6.48
5. Hojbjerg.....6.46
6. Dier...............6.40
7. Son................ 6.35
Next 5
1. Hojbjerg 6.98
2. Bentancur 6.88
3. Lloris .........6.79
4. Kane.........6.71
5. Romero ...6.48
6. Son.............6.47
7. Dier...........6.31
Sorry if that was painful but its all set out and ready to follow on now.
As you can see the 6 bracket with small increments is the main measure. Anything less than 6 over a long period probably means the club gets rid !!
Thanks for reading if you made it and I look forward to some interesting input.
...
It's a bit long winded this first ice breaker but try and stay with it.
Ratings are taken from newspapers, TV , Spurs sites and neutral sites. But most importantly and kept separate are forum posters ratings. A couple of days after the match or before the next one I collate the ratings and display the averages for each player.
The thread stays the same, no new thread per game. This makes tracking back easier.
I rate all games and there will always be around 10 from the media etc. It would be good to get some forum input but I realise it may take some time to get going. I may have to do some prompting but its down to personal choice. The more data goes in, the better because it gives a more reliable average.
My findings after 3 years is that for a player to achieve a rating of 7 across the season is nigh on impossible, its not been achieved yet !!
As a guide a 5 is poor, a 6 acceptable, a 7 good, 8 very good, 9 excellent, 10 exceptional. 0.5 marks are encouraged and the difference between a 6 and 6.50 is significant as you will find out. Likewise up and down the scale.
Here are the 20/21 season averages.
1. Kane........6.63
2. Hojbjerg 6.41
3. Toby..........6.35
4. Lloris.........6.22
5. Ndombele 6.20
6. Son..............6.19
7. Dele............6.18
8 . Lo Celso....6.16
9. Dier.............6.10
10. Lamela ....6.08
11. Aurier.......5.86
12. Davies.......5.84
21/22 Season averages.
1. Dier.........6.65
2. Romero 6.58
3. Lloris......6.45
4. Skipp/ Son 6.37
5. Kane..........6.25
6. Hojbjerg...6.21
7. Sanchez....6.18
8 . Moura .....6.17
9. Royal........6.08
10. Davies.....5.91
22/23 First 5 games.
1. Kulu 6.96
2. Kane 6.91
3. Dier....6.75
4. Hojbjerg 6.69
5. Davies...6 40
6. Royal....6.20
7. Lloris...6.10
8. Son.......5.52
Second 5.
1. Richarlison 7.07
2. Bentancur 6.78
3. Kane............6.52
4. Lloris...........6.48
5. Hojbjerg.....6.46
6. Dier...............6.40
7. Son................ 6.35
Next 5
1. Hojbjerg 6.98
2. Bentancur 6.88
3. Lloris .........6.79
4. Kane.........6.71
5. Romero ...6.48
6. Son.............6.47
7. Dier...........6.31
Sorry if that was painful but its all set out and ready to follow on now.
As you can see the 6 bracket with small increments is the main measure. Anything less than 6 over a long period probably means the club gets rid !!
Thanks for reading if you made it and I look forward to some interesting input.
...