What did Soldado score in the prem? 3 goals in open play during his entire Spurs career? How many goals did Townsend score in open prem play? 1 a season?
I think it's safe to say that claiming Ade would get a better goal return from those two players is not a moronic statement.
Once again. Soldado's and Townsend's returns are irrelevant because Adebayor was not dropped for them, he was dropped for Kane. Your statement that Poch sticking with Ade could have given us 4th is moronic because that would have meant no Kane, not no Soldado. Ade would not have done better than Kane, more likely worse, therefore finishing 4th would have been further from our reach, not closer.
I mean, am I saying it wrong? It sounds pretty straightforward to me, do you need me to draw you a picture or something?