The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...
Im sureDisagree with this entirely. Poch is already a success by getting us into the CL 3 years in a row. I wouldn’t trade playing CL matches against Real Madrid, Barcelona , Dortmund, Inter Milan etc for winning a b grade trophy like the Carabao Cup and finishing 5th , qualifying to play the likes of Carrier Bag on Thursday nights. There are only 2 trophies which mean more than top 4 -winning the EPL or the CL neither of which we have any realistic chance of pulling off. So no, Poch will not be a failure if he doesn’t win one of those , neither does he need to win the EFL to turn him into a success.
Times have changed and getting into the CL is everything. Getting into the last 16 and avoiding Europa is an even bigger success.
For those reasons I don’t support risking our strongest team on Wednesday. A strong team yes,
but not risking players for who we currently have no back up or who need a rest ( Toby and Dele for instance ) .And I’d choose Gazza . He also has a track record of saving penalties...
Being obsessed with beating Woolwich over and above our Champions League aspirations is small club mentality.
To the best of my knowledge we have finished 3rd, 2nd, 3rd in the past 3 seasons. In the first 2 of those seasons we were challenging for the title. So we have done better than competing for the “4th place trophy “ .
Push on like we did in 2008?I used to take the piss out of Scum fans for Wenger’s relentless priorisation of the “Fourth Place Trophy” over all others, and disagree with your statement whole-heartedly.
Probably a bad example to use given the recent news, but I remember Mourinho’s first season in charge at Chelscum, when he was king of hype, “The Special One”, and one of the first things - statements - he made was to win the Mickey Mouse Cup. Why? Because winning creates winners.
If you are happy for us to finish top four each year and challenge for nothing but get to play - and get spanked in - Europe’s elite stadia, then fine, be of that opinion. But I want Spurs to make that next step and challenge for the League, the FA Cup and even the Champions League. But I know that progress is only ever going to be incremental; if we can’t win a quarter-final leg of a knock-out competition against our hated rivals then how can we expect to ever commit to a sustained period of winning that is required to win the League? How can we look at, say, playing Real Madrid over two legs of a semi-final in the UCL and have the belief we will push them aside?
That belief, that winners’ mentality has to come from somewhere, and potentially winning the Mickey Mouse Cup offers a way into changing the perception, the self-belief and the overall steeliness of our players.
Prioritise ALL competitions, irrespective of their perceived stature. Win whatever we can and don’t be satisfied with just finishing fourth each season.
If you are happy for us to finish top four each year and challenge for nothing but get to play - and get spanked in - Europe’s elite stadia, then fine, be of that opinion.
Push on like we did in 2008?
Liked the rest of your post, but cant remember this ever happening (apart from once in 2011)
No, it doesn't elevate the players to the next level, it didn't with us, Wigan, Leicester City, Portsmouth, Everton, Swansea, Birmingham and Boro. All of these clubs never kicked on after winning a cup, there is one common denominator here all of them are the only non-top four clubs to win silverware who weren't in the current top 4 when they won a trophy in the past 30yrs or so!!!Completely different context. In 2008 it was amazing to win a trophy, any trophy, despite how shit we were. Now it’s less about the trophy itself, more about how it can elevate our players to the next level.
I was a little over-dramatic on the ‘spanked’ comment, but surely many here might feel we bottled it against Juve last season? That’s why I feel we need to develop our mental fortitude rather than just be happy with where we are now. A little push and we can achieve great things.
The guy is obviously not well hope he gets help
R
To the best of my knowledge we have finished 3rd, 2nd, 3rd in the past 3 seasons. In the first 2 of those seasons we were challenging for the title. So we have done better than competing for the “4th place trophy “ . And I believe we have wins against Real Madrid, Inter Milan and Dortmund, with draws against Barcelona and Juventus. I don’t see that as being spanked.
This year is tougher because Woolwich, Chelsea and Liverpool have all strengthened while we have not strengthened, played our home games in a half empty “ home “ stadium , had numerous injuries and more players reaching the later stages of the World Cup . Not to mention the Nations Cup and the Asia Cup.
In all the circumstances it would be a big achievement to finish in the top 4 this season and would cement the successes Poch has already achieved. More so than finishing outside the top 4 and winning the B grade League Cup. Wenger won the FA Cup. When they finished outside the top 4 it didn’t prevent the fans calling for his head. Likewise Conte when they won the FACup but didn’t make the top 4 . Likewise Van Gaal when he won the FA Cup. Now Mourinho has been fired despite having won the Europa League and the EFL Cup.
Being obsessed with beating Woolwich over and above our Champions League aspirations is small club mentality. Of course I want us to win . But if I had to choose between winning tomorrow night and losing to Everton over losing but beating Everton I know what I would choose. Potentially an 8 point gap rather than a 2 point gap and falling below Chelsea. Yes, you can say that we might lose to Everton anyway. Equally we could beat Woolwich then lose in one of the next 2 rounds to City or Chelsea.
All the more reason why we shouldn’t risk Toby tomorrow night.
Davies did ok on Saturday
Notabadsquad please read this before every carabao cup thread post you makeNo, it doesn't elevate the players to the next level, it didn't with us, Wigan, Leicester City, Portsmouth, Everton, Swansea, Birmingham and Boro. All of these clubs never kicked on after winning a cup, there is one common denominator here all of them are the only non-top for clubs to win silverware who weren't in the current top 4 in the past 30yrs or so!!!
Your example of Chelsea pushing on, conveniently forgets that the Chelsea side was the most expensively assembled side in the history of the game, maybe just maybe that had something to do with them elevating themselves.