Yeah but we KNOW that Toney is in a massive funk since coming back from his ban and in this league has never had a stretch as prolific as Guirassy since moving to Stuttgart. If you look at Guirassy's career as well he's had a real journey so he's used to adjusting and adapting to new situations.
I did some digging and tbh every level I dig, I'm encouraged by what I find.
View: https://youtu.be/0jqMwUYYbjA?si=Ot3AIL91DEFzqg0D
Scouting video (clearly made by a Guirassy fan so context here)
Wasn't prolific before Stuttguart but was largely due to circumstances of getting injured and/or playing on really bad teams. As soon as he touched a team that created chances he was banging them in.
His numbers and video for finishing, build up, movement, and aerial duels are on par with Kane and Haaland and he's clearly that technical player that we lack to hold the ball and bring others in.
Defensive contribution is a big question mark! Can he still be as technical and time his movement when you add in the extra aerobic workload of pressing?
It's taken Serhou Guirassy a while to find his feet in top-tier football, but now he's breaking records most weeks in a modern-day Cinderella story.
theanalyst.com
This was an interesting read as well. Rennes have a pretty good record for talent ID and the guy there (Stephens) was quoted as saying this which matches the video:
“It’s everything he does for the team, the runs he makes into space, the defensive work that he puts in, the way he puts himself about,”
He's been prolific for a good while now it seems:
"At the conclusion of the 2021-22 season, Guirassy had scored at a rate of one league goal every 144 minutes since the start of the prior campaign; that was better than players such as Victor Osimhen (148 mins), Neymar (148 mins), Son Heung-min (153 mins) and Kane (157 mins), and only marginally worse than Lionel Messi (143 mins)."
The rest of the article is just striker porn. There isn't an objective way to say that he's not statistically one of the best finishers and overall #9's in Europe. If we don't end up signing him, it will be Milan or Juve type of team and there's a really chance we'll all be sitting here next next season watching Toney or Gimenez look average and wondering why we "don't have good scouts".
TLDR: Sign fucking Guirassy for 17.5m you bald bastard. Even if he wants 190k pw and a 15m sign on bonus. Just fucking do it.