Of course, your scenario 2 is much better. That's quite a long way from the previous discussion.
But it isn’t is mate ? Spurs fans are clearly stating they feel getting to a CL final the other year far outweighs winning the league cup, so clearly certain supporters would prefer just to be in a CL final, over winning a league cup for instance which is absolute nonsense mate. Unless you win the champions league, it means jack shit. Getting to a final is no achievement mate.