• The Fighting Cock is a forum for fans of Tottenham Hotspur Football Club. Here you can discuss Spurs latest matches, our squad, tactics and any transfer news surrounding the club. Registration gives you access to all our forums (including 'Off Topic' discussion) and removes most of the adverts (you can remove them all via an account upgrade). You're here now, you might as well...

    Get involved!

Manager Ange Postecoglou

Latest Spurs videos from Sky Sports

Was sacking Ange a good idea?

  • Yes, I think it was a good idea.

    Votes: 73 64.6%
  • No, I think it was a bad idea.

    Votes: 40 35.4%

  • Total voters
    113
Newcastle have been a better team than Spurs this season.
Can't argue with that...
Yup, Facts are facts....
... even their opponent in their cup final was far superior than who we beat in ours.
Up for debate, and slightly irrelevant, as you COULD argue that Liverpool had priorities elsewhere....

Anyway, the point is, whilst all of those points have true elements to them, here we are, Spurs AND Newcastle both in the Champions League...

...and at least WE didn't have to wait until the final day of the season to discover OUR fate in the CL!!!

ALL I'm saying is, at the start of the season, the rules said whoever wins the EL Trophy gets a place in the CL next season...
There was NO caveat to where that team was obliged or required to finish in their respective domestic League table....

No we don't deserve CL football based on our league position... But then again, we're not trying to appeal to UEFA's compassionate side by asking to be let in anyway
... We did what was required and won the ONE trophy (other than the League) that gets you CL football.
Had Newcastle 'just' won the League Cup but finished 6th, they would NOT be where we are...

Face it, we beat the SYSTEM!

...and in doing so, have sent the rest of football into meltdown cause the CAN'T HANDLE THR TRUTH!

Newcastle deserve their place based on league position.... We deserve ours based on winning the Europa League!!

Sounds fair to me.... I don't see the problem officer!
 
This isn't a cheat code it's idiotic and borderline theft under the trades descriptions act , perhaps a wee note to people spending hundreds each week to watch what you are now claiming we're glorified freindlies. It's utterly disgusting. He should be fired for this admission alone

Lol because Liverpool aren’t fucking shit like United. Even United created stuff. Liverpool would’ve battered down the door. They have actual creative players and athleticism and individual goals across the pitch.

When are we going to fundamentally accept that the way we played worked because we played a team as bad as we are? It was a shit off. We scraped it through a hilariously scrappy goal and clung on.

I will gladly take the EL win but we were up against a team that were terrible and played terrible so we got a break at long last to break our trophy drought. We are unlikely to be as fortunate again so a change is needed for all concerned .

Oh come on, no they didn't. The odd half chance but we completely snuffed them out. With our fit and rested defense, no creativity available in midfield, and knowing that United are in fact shit, it was a setup to win that one all-or-nothing game. We were well worth the 1-0.

Far, far from a tactical masterclass and strange in the context of Ange's words and deeds about tactics previously, but it's ridiculous to make that performance a stick to beat him with.


40 I'll grant you. 38 was a disgrace and I do believe others would have done better even under the same circumstances, it really couldn't have been any worse.

But anything above like 50 would be pure fantasy. The league form was primarily dictated by the availability of bodies with form and fitness to give to league games.

It needs to be very different next season. Is Ange capable of building and maintaining a squad that can sustain quality twice a week for a full campaign at elite physical level? Many reasons for doubt.
Tell you what, shall we just hand back the Europa League trophy (seeing as we're SO undeserving!) in exchange for what people deem an acceptable number of league points, they still probably wouldn't have got us into the Top 5...

Our aim this season was to WIN A TROPHY ✓
...and somehow qualify for the Champions League ✓✓

We did BOTH... with ONE TROPHY!!

yes, the League was piss poor as a result, but I wouldn't swap last Wednesday-Sunday for anything
... Least of all an 'acceptable' 6th place finish and NO trophy, which would be had us pretty much back to where we started in August!
 
Tell you what, shall we just hand back the Europa League trophy (seeing as we're SO undeserving!) in exchange for what people deem an acceptable number of league points, they still probably wouldn't have got us into the Top 5...

Our aim this season was to WIN A TROPHY ✓
...and somehow qualify for the Champions League ✓✓

We did BOTH... with ONE TROPHY!!

yes, the League was piss poor as a result, but I wouldn't swap last Wednesday-Sunday for anything
... Least of all an 'acceptable' 6th place finish and NO trophy, which would be had us pretty much back to where we started in August!

What does this emotional nonsense have to do with whether we should keep the coach or not? We know we won it. We know that doesn’t make Ange good automatically as we can all reel off cup winning coaches who aren’t good.

This thread is for debating. We all know that trophy + CL qualification is a good result on paper but people are questioning the method and if we will ever progress.

There will be no Europa league to enter next year, no Bodo or United in a final to save us, so you’ll be staking everything on the horrific league form drastically improving. Good luck.
 
I don't think Ange is fraudulent. I just don't think he's good enough at this level. He may have won a cup but, anyone one on any given day can do that. He lucked out. 22 defeats cannot be ignored
Come on...this is demonstrably false - unless you count things like the Audi cup, etc.

As much as I admit that I'm caught up in the romanticism of the occasion, I'm no more keen than anyone else to watch another PL season of the dross we've been served up under Ange.

Of course, 22 defeats cannot be ignored, but to say anyone on their day can win a major trophy is frankly absurd. At the risk of sounding like a broken record - he's the first bloke in 41 years to do this for this club!!!
 
That’s just factually incorrect. Go watch Australia at the 2014 World Cup!

I think your idea of solid and most people’s may differ slightly.

But I will say playing attacking football where losing 3 games out of 3 while scoring 3 goals and conceding 9 is definitely something we have all got used to giving Ange credit for!

Even he acknowledged that it was not working and went full on Italian defensive style football.
 
He didn’t want eze last summer he preferred players like Solanke and oddbert.
I think he'd have taken Eze over Oddbert all day long if he had that choice. He'd have taken Neto over him too. And there's probably a bunch of strikers He'd have taken over Solanke if we were prepared to pay the wages to secure them.
Like any other manager we've had, our limited wage structure means he has a very limited pool of players in the transfer market to choose from.
 
This is his squad he has spent nearly £400M. Got rid of players like PEH who he didn’t want, discarded Spence and sent on loan all our academy players except Moore. Who he has treated badly. All the while bringing in other youngsters same age as our own and giving them minutes. If the squad that got 5th was better than the one now how comes people say he came into a shit show in 23.

Both can be true.

The club had finished 8th. The morale was poor, the relationship between fans and the club had taken a dive. Kane had one foot out.

Not talked about much is the loss of Perisic-he was very important before his injury.
 
Back
Top