Yes poch didn’t finish top 3 thrice (three times more than any other EPL manager in our history) and make a champions league final or anything
Some people are thick.
Under Poch, the quality of the squad improved at the beginning but declined after we made Sissoko and Sanchez our record signings in consecutive summer, and decided to gift PSG £50m for Aurier and Moura.
We finished 4th in Poch last full season and he left the team in 14th. If the squad was better, Poch wouldnt have left when he did. Poch is almost certain to win silverware with PSG, but not becuase he has a become a much better manager, but that he has the best squad in ligue 1. You cannot ignore the quality of a squad when considering the perfromance of a manager.
Zidan wone 3x CL when he had a great squad. Now that the squad is lacking and aged, he is struggling and will likely be fired at the end of the season. Doubt his quality as a manager has degraded.
People are still waiting for Pep to win another CL since he left Barcelona. He cant even get City into the CL finals despite spending almost £1bn on a championship winning squad. Pep has actually imrpoved as a manager compared to his Barcelona days, but no longwe has the luxury of a squad with Messi, Xavi, Iniesta etc.
Begining of this season, we were doing fine (not entertaining but effective, which is typical of a Mourinho team). But after some injuries, the lack of quality depth in the squad has been exposed.
At the end of the day, managers are not miracle workers.