Suarez is incredibly quick. He may not have top end speed, but he's absolutely quick. And far, far stronger both technically AND physically than Soldado. When was the last time Van Nistelrooy played in the BPL? Tactics change, athletes change. Soldado? Counter attacking football? You do realize you need to possess at least a modicum of speed to be successful counter attacking, right?
Suarez is not incredibly quick, that is just false. His intelligence gives him 5yds on defenders before they've even started running, which is why so frequently he ends up 1-on-1 with no defenders near him. Soldado is surprisingly physical for his stature, he doesn't often get shrugged off the ball. And i'm fully aware counter-attacking relies on pace, I figured we had some of that with Lennon/Townsend on the wings, no?[/QUOTE]
You refuted my statistics by providing faulty statistics of your own, though-- yes, Soldado scored penalties... but you cannot 100% without a doubt say he's the only player who would have banged them in, therefore the only points I feel he truly won us on his own were the 3 against Cardiff. Ergo, Kane has had about as successful a league campaign as Soldado has. I just don't understand how you could possible defend the fact that our 26 million pound signing has scored less from open play than a 20 year old who will probably never go for half that pricetag.
How did I refute your statistics with a post that was regardless of everybody else's? Did I quote your post initially? Must've missed that..
If we want to play this game, you could say that Kane would have missed some of Soldado's misses or that Soldado would've scored Kane's goals.. There's a trillion different variables and it's a ridiculous argument to have. I wasn't defending the fact at all initially, just saying that anybody can find a statistic that suits their agenda. I think he's had a terrible goalscoring season but my initial point (and one which again you seem to be failing to recognise) is that I would keep him for another season rather than accepting a £20m loss on him.
Again, I don't think you all realize that in order for Soldado to be successful for us we will need to build our entire team around constantly feeding him the ball. You think Mourinho/Martinez/Wenger/Pellegrini/Rodgers/Van Gaal (if ManU happen to sign him) wouldn't be able to figure out how to stop that? Players in this league are incredibly gifted athletically, it would literally require one athlete to shut him down for an entire game. He is simply not the type of player to bring others into the game, meaning our other creative players would suffer as a result. He is absolutely not the right striker to carry us forward.
I don't think you've been watching the same player as I have this season if you're arguing that he doesn't bring others into the game. That's been the one strength of his this season, he has some incredible, intricate touches that have created chances for us- obviously they haven't been finished off so it'd be impossible to find you highlights of this i'd imagine. I would be interested in strikers that you consider to create chances for themselves? They're incredibly rare and have a ridiculous pricetag, of course a striker needs service.. I don't even get how anybody could think otherwise.
There is ABSOLUTELY a reason Adebayor was brought back into the fold, and ABSOLUTELY a reason Adebayor is by far a better fit for our squad as a striker. You talk about Ade not "contributing enough"... what is exactly that you've seen Soldado ever contribute besides a few penalties, some cute passes and a whole bunch of shanked shots?
I'm not disputing that Adebayor has a part to play, but I absolutely disagree that he is a 'leading the line' striker. I don't usually vent on Adebayor because it seems to be an unpopular opinion, but for me he is never actually where a striker should be, spends all game fucking around on the wings and with the defensive midfielders, half his shots are passed straight at the opposing goalkeeper, he rarly seems to win headers, and his creative play is also terrible. Take the goal he scored from the Soldado cross (v Southampton?) - we're counter attacking 2-on-2, Adebayor has Soldado just to his left, and ends up smashing the pass out to the corner flag!? If he'd played a ball 10 yards ahead of RS then that's almost certainly a goal, with the pass he received there was SO much work to do and i'd argue Soldado made that goal
despite Adebayor, not
because of him.