Totally agree
I agree with this too, but the belief in an "outdated fairytale made up god mantra" isn't confined to the Middle East, albeit to different degrees.
The point I was making was that the examples you quoted (apartheid-era South Africa and Nazi Germany) were easy wins. Of course, if we took the values we hold today back in time, we'd react differently. But contemporaries had different values.
Take homosexuality as an example, since that's one of the main criticisms of Qatar. Go back to the '66 World Cup in England and you'll find homosexual acts were still a criminal offence in the UK. I suspect many of our parents and grandparents had no qualms with this. Had the World Cup been held in Qatar in 1950 instead of Uruguay, I doubt anyone would have cared what their stance on homosexuality was.
Cultures' moral compasses move at different speeds. I'm sure Qatar and others will eventually follow a similar path to us when it comes to attitudes towards homosexuality. It may even be that one of the positive things to come out of this World Cup is an acceleration of that shift.
Given how comments can sometimes be misinterpreted, I should add that none of I've said is intended to delegitimise the criticisms of Qatar today.
I think the date of things is key....
You're right, had Qatar been awarded a WC 70 years ago, us English wouldn't give two shits about LGBT issues, let alone Women's rights.... but that's 'cos it was 70 years ago...
Thankfully, we've moved on from those dark days, been educated, and now see the previous errors in our ways.
Which is why, in 2022 there is justified outrage.
Yes, it might take Qatar another 50 years (or more) to 'catch up' with Western values... but that said,
don't award them a GLOBAL COMPETITION with Western Counties competing...
award them it in 2072 or whenever it is they finally realise the 'God' they pin so much importance and 'culture' on is a racist, sexist, homophobic mysoginistic made up a coupla thousand years ago by equally racist, sexist, homophobic mysoginistic men no doubt!
It's an extreme example, but if it was their culture to rape and murder babies, would the West be expected to comply, and 'respect' local culture by bringing over and offering their own babies for ritual sacrifice..? No, 'cos it's fundemetally wrong!
So is stoning Gay people to death, and treating Women like 3rd rate citizens! We're allowed to have a voice, and disagree with those 'values'.
Just cos a Middle Eastern backwards nation decides it's their law/culture, doesn't make it right.
They're quick enough to flash their cash if it gets them what they want.... I thought Capitalism was a Western disease?!
Yet unfortunately, and inevitably, Middle Eastern money has spoken loudest to the West.... Moral compasses, scruples and human rights are easily bought it seems! Qatar are happy to throw money at a problem, as long as they get to spout their outdated, fundemetally wrong 'values' on the same Western countries they pretend to 'invite with open arms'!