Doherty has been woeful though.
Auriers performance against Utd alone was better than anything Doherty has conjured up. I'm not sure there should be any argument.
Aurier was not good against United though, he just wasn't challenged because they went down to 10 men so early so weren't able to exploit the space he left wide open by drifting into the middle of field, not running back in defense and tuning out of the game to chase butterflies.
Doherty against Everton was much better than any game Aurier has had this season.