Rodrigo Bentancur

[Deuterz]

Whole lot of Hoddle-syndrome in here right now.

Or you’re just biased. Guess we’ll never know for sure.

 

[Shadydan]

IMHO by the letter of the law it’s dangerous play which is a sending off.

The ball is nowhere near, the tackle is side on and high on the leg.

It’s no surprise the tackle led to a nasty injury and as such it should be classed as dangerous play and red carded.

Orange card they call it I think

 

[Harrier]

Why does he want Cash retrospectively banned, are Utd playing them next?

Eh?!

He expands on why he thinks he should be banned.

 

[Harrier]

Orange card they call it I think

Did VAR even look at it?

 

[Fattynomates]

Nah I want them to actually introduce retrospective punishment, you never know if a player is hurt in the immediate aftermath of the challenge.

didnt this happen to Sonny against Everton was it? Was a Cynical Foul and a Yellow at most , nothing like Cash's yet when they saw how injured the player was Sonny got a red.

 

[Airfixx]

Nah I want them to actually introduce retrospective punishment, you never know if a player is hurt in the immediate aftermath of the challenge.

Well for a few seasons retrospective reds became a thing..... Not heard of that in years though.

Regardless; effective policing (i.e. prevention) is routed in punishing the act; not the outcome.

 

[Nuts]

The rule should have been to allow Vicario to squeeze Cash's bollocks for 10 seconds. I don't see a problem with that.

 

[Bazali]

didnt this happen to Sonny against Everton was it? Was a Cynical Foul and a Yellow at most , nothing like Cash's yet when they saw how injured the player was Sonny got a red.

Was that the Rudiger one where he had selective deafness?

 

[Bazali]

The rule should have been to allow Vicario to squeeze Cash's bollocks for 10 seconds. I don't see a problem with that.

You’re getting soft!!

10 seconds each one!

 

[GDG]

I don't think that's the case at all.

I do. It was a shitty tackle from a cowardly player who no doubt was frustrated that his team were being played off the park.

It’s just not a red.

If that got given against us as a red we’d be raging.

 

[Airfixx]

Did VAR even look at it?

There was a rumour that VAR wasn't working; but subsequent chatter from Dermot O'fuckoff claims it was reviewed.

 

[Nuts]

You’re getting soft!!

10 seconds each one!

Yeah and a cheeky twist at the end.

 

[Shadydan]

didnt this happen to Sonny against Everton was it? Was a Cynical Foul and a Yellow at most , nothing like Cash's yet when they saw how injured the player was Sonny got a red.

Yes but what I'm asking for is slightly different.

 

[Shadydan]

Did VAR even look at it?

They can't overturn bookings.

 

[Starks]

didnt this happen to Sonny against Everton was it? Was a Cynical Foul and a Yellow at most , nothing like Cash's yet when they saw how injured the player was Sonny got a red.

Thing is, it wasn't even Son who injured Andre Gomes. It was Aurier.

 

[Luiz Cláudio]

Bentancur injury will require surgery?

 

[Airfixx]

I do. It was a shitty tackle from a cowardly player who no doubt was frustrated that his team were being played off the park.

It’s just not a red.

If that got given against us as a red we’d be raging.

Aside from the fact I disagree with you over the decision.

This was the point I specifically contested: "If Benta gets up unhurt there isn’t even a discussion about it".

You punish the ACT; not the outcome.

 

[GDG]

They can't overturn bookings.

They can if they think it’s a red.

 

[Kaz Hirai]

Hopefully we get villa in the cup , get dier to break Cash's leg and ankle . See how he likes it

 

[Bazali]

Hopefully we get villa in the cup , get dier to break Cash's leg and ankle . See how he likes it

He’d probably miss though